• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

If Leonard Nimoy was still alive today and able and wanting to work, would the show be different?

maybe IDW could do a comic where Spock faked his death in Kelvinverse (bc of Cronenbergs explanation in Disco) to return to the Primeverse ..he meets Picards golem and is like 'yes as you know the same happened to me, sorta' - Star Trek Countdown 2: This Time Its Canon
IDW did do a leadup to Spock's death in their comics I think, and it showed that he was very much not popular with the Vulcan refugees. They blamed him for having the red matter that Nero stole that was used to destroy Vulcan. Only at the very end in the final panel was their a statue of Spock Prime on New Vulcan showing they changed their opinion about him.

Regardless, although non-canon, these licensed comics show that Spock being this ultra-essential asset for Vulcan refugee survival that some on this thread are claiming was definitely not a set in stone thing. I don't think Spock Prime traveling home to the Prime timeline is out of character at all. People are claiming he won't abandon the Vulcan refugees, but if those same Vulcan refugees don't want him, blame him for their homeworld's destruction, and then get angrier when he won't reveal future info, what else should Spock do? Force his presence where he's not wanted? Spock never struck me as that sort of guy, and even when he was on Romulus he had Pardek's backing. Spock would logically just go home.
 
Last edited:
I think either decision is perfectly in character for Spock. I think the whole "well, he's not popular" argument holds little weight since he had already gone against the grain of popular opinion with the reunification effort, and engaged in "cowboy diplomacy" as it was described. Even with Pardek's blessing the reunification effort was not popular. So, I think Spock would say both out of a sense of duty as well as guilt.
 
No. Nimoy promoted the awful films so he would have just went with the flow on this series as well.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top