• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Disco: One thing I wish we had seen

Gingerbread Demon

Yelling at the Vorlons
Premium Member
Why didn't we see some of the fallout from the Red Angel visiting Kaminar and what happened to the Ba'ul?

Unless of course it was that single solitary one on the base ship or they were very few in number and relied on their technology to frighten people away....

NOTE: They only scanned Discovery's weapons, nothing else. So they wanted to see if they'd be outgunned in a fight. I wish Pike had called their bluff but then people would complain he's not being "Federationy"
 
Why didn't we see some of the fallout from the Red Angel visiting Kaminar and what happened to the Ba'ul?

Unless of course it was that single solitary one on the base ship or they were very few in number and relied on their technology to frighten people away....

NOTE: They only scanned Discovery's weapons, nothing else. So they wanted to see if they'd be outgunned in a fight. I wish Pike had called their bluff but then people would complain he's not being "Federationy"
I'm betting the Kelpians will be the Big Bad of season 3, and it's all Saru's fault for starting a revolution 900 years before.

So I think we'll learn a lot more of the aftermath.
 
I'm betting the Kelpians will be the Big Bad of season 3, and it's all Saru's fault for starting a revolution 900 years before.

So I think we'll learn a lot more of the aftermath.
That would be nice, I felt the whole episode was rushed.
And didn't the temporal anomaly threaten the planet in the next episode? We never found out how badly it was damaged.
 
I think he's hot. (Perhaps it's the hooves? #yestallmen)

In theory, the guy with the three pips in "Magic to Make" whom Mudd guns down at the shuttlebay could be our elusive Chief Medical Officer, alive and active (even if unseen) through at least the entire S1 and perhaps parts of S2.

In theory, Nhan could be our Chief Security Officer for all of S2, never having been an engineer at all (the transporter operator would just be mistaken in "Brother", what with garbled comms and all); we still wouldn't know who initially succeeded Tyler for the first half of "Brother", but at least we're not having much of a gap anywhere else. In practice, Nhan is absent till the start of "An Obol for Charon", being rather explicitly introduced back to the circle of top officers, so we do have a gap.

It's just that we don't have any sort of a theory for the Chief Engineering Officer. He or she can't be any of the characters seen, because all of those are always accounted for and otherwise engaged when a reference to the mystery CEO is made. No high-ranking extras are ever spotted in bronze, either.

Then again, we now have plenty of reason to believe the ship has at least two major engine rooms, one refitted for spore stuff but the other probably still powering the ship for warp and impulse flight. Perhaps the haphazardly cobbled-together flying lab is in need of constant engineering attention and the CEO hasn't left Starboard Engineering since the ship first sailed? (Probably it was him or her who raised the shields in "Such Sweet Sorrow I", having been left behind!)

We did return to the Ba'ul in the finale: the Kelpien have now stolen their fightercraft, so it's pretty clear there have been changes. The planet already has a history of such things, so we can probably predict neat and tidy genocide again, with the Kelpien eating all the Ba'ul just as originally. That is, unless an alien again intervenes on behalf of the underdogs.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Last edited:
Only the Ba'ul were not the underdogs, not by a bloody longshot. If they had really wanted to be alone they could have taken their base and left the planet and been on their own. They wanted to rule, and to subjugate the Kelpians. They deserved whatever they got.
 
Why didn't we see some of the fallout from the Red Angel visiting Kaminar and what happened to the Ba'ul?

Unless of course it was that single solitary one on the base ship or they were very few in number and relied on their technology to frighten people away....

NOTE: They only scanned Discovery's weapons, nothing else. So they wanted to see if they'd be outgunned in a fight. I wish Pike had called their bluff but then people would complain he's not being "Federationy"
There's always: "Strange New Worlds"... ;)
 
Only the Ba'ul were not the underdogs, not by a bloody longshot. If they had really wanted to be alone they could have taken their base and left the planet and been on their own. They wanted to rule, and to subjugate the Kelpians. They deserved whatever they got.

Oh, that's just a function of time. When Pike intervenes, the Kelpians are the underdogs. A few years later, the Ba'ul might be. A few thousand years earlier, they apparently very much were. (And then the Preservers came and gave them obelisk tech to defend themselves with?)

But yes, definitely SNW material. Although we don't yet know for sure if SNW will predate or postdate DSC S1/2...

Timo Saloniemi
 
Oh, that's just a function of time. When Pike intervenes, the Kelpians are the underdogs. A few years later, the Ba'ul might be. A few thousand years earlier, they apparently very much were. (And then the Preservers came and gave them obelisk tech to defend themselves with?)

But yes, definitely SNW material. Although we don't yet know for sure if SNW will predate or postdate DSC S1/2...

Timo Saloniemi

Would the Preservers be that generous with their tech?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top