• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Batwoman - Season 1

I had a weird thought, how would Julia Pennyworth work for picking up the mantle. Like for some reason Kate is put on a bus and then bring in Julia as BW but not as Kate. She would seem to have the chops.

Surely that's not true. ...What about Ellen DeGeneres, for example?
I would assume they mean superhero series.
 
I had a weird thought, how would Julia Pennyworth work for picking up the mantle. Like for some reason Kate is put on a bus and then bring in Julia as BW but not as Kate. She would seem to have the chops.


I would assume they mean superhero series.

yes I should have been clearer and specified superhero.

Would also point out that Ellen and her tv show character were both in the closet initially.

Rose and Kate Kane were both out from the get go.

And personally I think the replacement for Ruby Rose should simply be treated as Kate Kane as if she'd been there from the get go.

no face swaps, no twisted theories.

Just pretend she's never changed because frankly it would add nothing to the story.
 
Apparently Stephanie Beatriz from Brooklyn Nine Nine has hinted as well.

IvswsAA.gif
 
On Twitter, Alaina Huffman volunteered herself to be the new Kate. She already played Dinah “Black Canary” Lance on Smallville.

Not gonna happen since the producers only want an LGBT actress for the role of Kate and Alaina doesn't fit that criteria.

I wonder if Arrow alum Bex Taylor-Klaus would be interested in the role, especially now that Deputy has been cancelled.
 
Not gonna happen since the producers only want an LGBT actress for the role of Kate and Alaina doesn't fit that criteria.

I wonder if Arrow alum Bex Taylor-Klaus would be interested in the role, especially now that Deputy has been cancelled.
I'm picturing everyone having to google each candidate to see if they are worthy of praise or outrage.
 
It might be a while before we hear anything. I'm guessing they'll want to do chemistry reads, and who knows how long it'll be before they can do those. Plus, I suspect they might want to include Melissa.
 
It might be a while before we hear anything. I'm guessing they'll want to do chemistry reads, and who knows how long it'll be before they can do those. Plus, I suspect they might want to include Melissa.


Not so long ;)

https://www.superherohype.com/tv/481756-report-ruby-roses-batwoman-exit-wasnt-entirely-her-call

“It wasn’t 100-percent her decision,” according to an unnamed source working on Batwoman. “It was a breakup. She wasn’t happy working on the show, and did that make her fun to work with? No. So everyone decided it would be in the best interests of the show, and for all concerned, if they parted ways. It just wasn’t a good fit.”

Makes sense because rather than hearing "We wish her the best luck" it was more like "Thank God she's gone" just after the announcement.

Living in Vancouver and long hours were making Rose miserable so she chose to leave and the CW agreed because she was making everyone on set miserable.
 
Well maybe this will lead to a shorter seasons if the work load is to much..
actually rather prefer the Story dictate the season length.. to much filler on some seasons that could have been 13 but streached to 22..
 
Just replace her with Batman. :)
I find it funny they’re just looking for gay ladies to replace her. Surely that part of her can be acted by a straight lady.
 
Not so long ;)

https://www.superherohype.com/tv/481756-report-ruby-roses-batwoman-exit-wasnt-entirely-her-call

Makes sense because rather than hearing "We wish her the best luck" it was more like "Thank God she's gone" just after the announcement.

Living in Vancouver and long hours were making Rose miserable so she chose to leave and the CW agreed because she was making everyone on set miserable.

That's sad to hear. It's Genevieve Bujold on Star Trek: Voyager all over again, although this time it took them more than a year to figure it out.
 
Ruby Rose just quit.

https://deadline.com/2020/05/ruby-r...ead-role-season-2-shocker-shakeup-1202938863/

I hated her casting at first because I'd never liked her in anything else she'd been in but after a shaky start she turned out to be really great.

This is quite shocking and so very disappointing. I thought she made a strong Kate/Batwoman, who was really shaping the role to be her own. Batwoman is my second favorite CW-DC series, so this is a blow to the chemistry its built.

I've seen people say that they should get Rachel Skarsten to takeover the role.

That would not work at all--especially if they mean Alice takes over the role (as if there would be any believable way Luke would accept that).

Again, this is so disappointing. Well, good luck to RR in her career going forward.
 
Not so long ;)

https://www.superherohype.com/tv/481756-report-ruby-roses-batwoman-exit-wasnt-entirely-her-call



Makes sense because rather than hearing "We wish her the best luck" it was more like "Thank God she's gone" just after the announcement.

Living in Vancouver and long hours were making Rose miserable so she chose to leave and the CW agreed because she was making everyone on set miserable.

In my experience, "Unnamed sources" are not always reliable and often fueled by agenda. I would like to see other, more reliable sources come forward before buying the idea that Rose was difficult to work / get along with and the production was happy to show her the door.
 
Surely that part of her can be acted by a straight lady.

Yes, a Straight actor could very easily play the role, but the producers have chosen to make the role exclusive to members of the LGBTQ community... which is both entirely reasonable and entirely their prerogative.
 
That would not work at all--especially if they mean Alice takes over the role (as if there would be any believable way Luke would accept that).
I think the idea is the actress would play the part, maybe doing double duty with Alice as needed, same as if they recast the role with another actress now except it'd be a familiar face.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top