• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers On the subject of Riker/Troi's kid

Genuinely curious... how can you tell this just from the picture??

baby-thad-and-picard.jpg


(I didn't realize while watching the episode that Thad was wearing a little Starfleet romper... how adorable!)
He’s got a man sized head.
 
I mean, you can say it’s a different ship and all Conference Lounges look pretty similar, but you can make out the gold Ambassador- and Excelsior-class models, so it depends on how much you want to stretch it (and that if they wanted to show it was definitively not the Enterprise, it wouldn’t look like the Enterprise. Photoshop is a magical thing).
Well, going back to my theory they could be models of ships Riker served on, we know Riker served on two Excelsior class ships. Would it be impossible to insert an Ambassador class in there somewhere?
 
As I pointed out in the other thread, since Picard is definitely holding a baby boy in the picture we see of him and Thad,
It's impossible to tell the gender or sex of a baby that age. And it doesn't matter what kind of actor/model played the baby in that photo either.

Well considering Ian is soaking wet.
It's possible that he was sweating heavily or that he wrestled and drowned the wolf in order to protect the family, or as revenge.
 
So Troi could have Kestra soon with some alien intervention (which could explain the linguistic creativity).
It was Thad who had the linguistic gift (he invented all the languages). Kestra's only special abilities seen so far are badass bunnicorn hunting, fashion sense, and love for her family. She has only learned and uses Viveen, the language of the Wild Girls of the Woods... But it was invented by her elder brother.
 
There's also a line in the script that didn't make it into the final episode:

MISTER TROI
(anguished)
The current was too strong...

So it was the original writer's intention that she drowned.
Deleted scenes aren't canon though. Saavik half-Romulan, Saavik pregnant with Spock's kid, E-E First Officer Martin Madden, etc. Just because they originally considered including a version where she drowned, it was then deliberately directed and produced, edited, sound edited, and then released in such a way that makes the wolf attack the much more plausible explanation for Kestra's death.
 
It's possible that he was sweating heavily or that he wrestled and drowned the wolf in order to protect the family, or as revenge.

No.

it was then deliberately directed and produced, edited, sound edited, and then released in such a way that makes the wolf attack the much more plausible explanation for Kestra's death.

You have to be kidding right? Again no. The wolf is a symbolic image designed to by Lwaxana's mind to keep Troi out. Troi says this herself:

ROI: That's right. A child might represent vulnerability. Hedril may depict some fragile part of my mother.
PICARD: A part that she's protecting. You said that everything you encountered when you were in her mind was a barrier of one kind or another.
TROI: Yes. You, the wolf, my father. It was though she were summoning all her defences to keep me away. But keep me away from what? What is she protecting?

Not sure whether you're trolling or whether you actually believe this nonsense.
 
If dreams and visions experienced by Star Trek characters were meant to be taken literally then it would be very likely that every bit of Star Trek since "The Cage(TOS)" has been a direct or at least indirect result of a mid-20th century science fiction magazine writer inventing a 24th century space station. Everything we'd have seen over the past half-century of the franchise would be a fantasy from the mind of Benny Russell. ;)
 
If dreams and visions experienced by Star Trek characters were meant to be taken literally then it would be very likely that every bit of Star Trek since "The Cage(TOS)" has been a direct or at least indirect result of a mid-20th century science fiction magazine writer inventing a 24th century space station. Everything we'd have seen over the past half-century of the franchise would be a fantasy from the mind of Benny Russell. ;)

And Troi is actually made out of cake. :)
 
Deleted scenes aren't canon though. Saavik half-Romulan, Saavik pregnant with Spock's kid, E-E First Officer Martin Madden, etc. Just because they originally considered including a version where she drowned, it was then deliberately directed and produced, edited, sound edited, and then released in such a way that makes the wolf attack the much more plausible explanation for Kestra's death.
What would it take to convince you then? The word of Les Landau, the director of Dark Page? Unfortunately, I can't find his contact details anywhere. I don't even know if he's still alive.
 
It's impossible to tell the gender or sex of a baby that age. And it doesn't matter what kind of actor/model played the baby in that photo either.
Okay, but for what reason is there to assume Thad Riker was a transgender person besides an attempt to be consistent with a continuity this show has already proved to be inconsistent with?
It's possible that he was sweating heavily or that he wrestled and drowned the wolf in order to protect the family, or as revenge.
Granted, I've never been in this situation and hope never to be, but I don't think one's reaction to seeing their child eaten by a wolf is to wrestle with the wolf, drag it to a nearby lake, and drown it. But I'll accept no one really knows how they'll react until they actually are in this situation.
And Troi is actually made out of cake. :)
With mint frosting.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top