• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 1x05 - "Stardust City Rag"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    323
Bjayzl didn't display any of the telepathy of a Betazoid and Seven specifically has guilt over telling her about Icheb, which would be meaningless if Bjayzl could just read her mind about him.

True. She just has the look.

By the way, you're Charlemagne19 at theforce.net right? sidv88 here , I just don't use that screenname on this board

Cool. Yes I am. Nice to see you.
 
Take away the goofiness of The Way to Eden, there are a lot of folks looking to escape the planned civilization of the Federation. The Eden folks were one group but Spock made it an easy inference that there are a lot more than a few kooks. Later in the episode we find Severin is host to a super disease that is a result of diseases evolving in the highly sterilized environments the Federation maintains.

You've got shady guys like Mudd trading in women and folks like Cyrano Jones living in the grey area of the law probably on planets like Freecloud. The Federation was never a perfect world when looked at too closely.

Essentially, a consistent element across all of the Federation stories is that there's a large colonization effort of humans who want to leave the Federation's perfection because they want a sense of accomplishment from doing labor that means something versus living on Earth's nanny state. There's also "wild cat settlements" that exist on non-Federation worlds that are complete ****holes.

See Ezri's world and Tasha Yar's.

The Federation IS paradasical but most of its colonies aren't by design. They're places you work hard because you don't want to just lounge around the holodeck in.
 
Icheb: Admiral Janeway will get you, you villain!
Bjayzl: Oh, you mean her? :lol:

Icheb looks on in horror at the corpses of Janeway, Torres, and Tuvok while hardcore fans recall they were briefly assimilated in "Unimatrix Zero".

Admiral Janeway: I went through time to make sure everyone lived.

7 of 9: Icheb was horribly torn apart by cybernetics harvesters.

Admiral Janeway: Just Icheb?

7 of 9: Yes.

Admiral Janeway: Eh, close enough.
 
My feelings regarding this episode is kind of similar to how I felt about the Discovery "Magic to make the sanest man" episode. For its first 6 episodes Discovery established it's own style that was different than previous Trek series. Then came the "Magic" episode which could have been done as an episode of any of the previous series. It was a very popular episode, with many Discovery detractor liking it. But, while I liked it, it was my least favorite episode of Discovery first season, and I was happy for Discovery to go back to its own style.

I feel the same way about "Stardust". I liked it and was entertained, but I prefer the first 4 episodes. They may have been too slow moving for some people, but they established Picard's own style of storytelling, different from previous Trek series, which I liked a lot. "Stardust" probably is more tied in to the Picard main story arc than "magic" was to Discovery, so it was better in that regard. But I will be happy if Picard goes back to its own style next week.
 
What an ending, indeed.

Next episode:
Picard: What happened, Dr Jurati!

Jurati: I don't know, I panicked, I don't do well under pressure. He was dying, the hologram came on and was pressuring me I just tried to make it stop talking but I hit the puree his arterial system button instead of the fixit button.

Picard: We all make mistakes, Doctor... me most of all. Let's move past this.

[Entire Crew] WTF JL!
 
I don't know...Star Trek has had some weird scenes...

Ugh, I can't stand this scene to this day!

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

I read that those parasites were intended to be the Borg originally (as in a primary, powerful antagonist), but not only was the technical budget high, they looked terrible so it was (thankfully) scrapped.
 
What an ending, indeed.

Next episode:
Picard: What happened, Dr Jurati!

Jurati: I don't know, I panicked, I don't do well under pressure. He was dying, the hologram came on and was pressuring me I just tried to make it stop talking but I hit the puree his arterial system button instead of the fixit button.

Picard: We all make mistakes, Doctor... me most of all. Let's move past this.

[Entire Crew] WTF JL!

Exactly, how does she really expect to get away with that?
 
commodore Oh is one of the conspirators and successfully brainwashed Dr Jurati.

Or what if she didn't brainwash her? What if she just told her the truth? And the truth, whatever it is, is just THAT bad. That would be way more interesting. I hope that's the way it goes.
 
Or what if she didn't brainwash her? What if she just told her the truth? And the truth, whatever it is, is just THAT bad. That would be way more interesting. I hope that's the way it goes.

What could possibly be bad enough to kill her friend/mentor/lover for? Plus, he already told Picard where Soji is, that was the main purpose of Picard tracking him down in the first place.
 
When I saw the episode I thought Raffi's daughter in law was Vulcan, but I have been hearing she was a Romulan which makes it more interesting.

I liked Rios calling Picard Jefe.

I immediately thought she was Romulan. A Vulcan wouldn't be nearly as controversial considering Raffi was/is on a mission against the Romulans (although specifically the Tal Shiar).
 
Was she the first Romulan we've seen in Picard with a traditional old skool hair cut?

I noticed the big bump too, human-romulan babies are big
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top