Spoilers New Short Trek - Q&A
- Thread starter Tuskin38
- Start date
The computer is voiced by Jenette Goldstein https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001280/ from Aliens, T2, Titanic etc.
Btw for those of us outside of North America the episode is available on the high seas.
Btw for those of us outside of North America the episode is available on the high seas.
As far as Spock's hair, it was short for 5 minutes at the end of DSC S2, and for all of 14 minutes in Q&A. No real need to cut Ethan's hair for those scenes. Plus Q&A was showing a younger Spock, so a different style was in order.
If we get a Pike series, that would be a different story. They'd probably cut his hair or give him more Nimoy like wig.
If we get a Pike series, that would be a different story. They'd probably cut his hair or give him more Nimoy like wig.
Last edited:
Found this on Youtube for all non-US/Canada viewers. It's the first 5 minutes of the episode.
It's so awesome to hear bits of Enterprising Young Men!! If they do a Pike series, Michael Giacchino is a must for the soundtrack
Also I love the Enterprise Turbolift Funhouse™. There's no way that fits anywhere inside
Also, my headcanon is that Upjohn is Scotty's mum.
It's so awesome to hear bits of Enterprising Young Men!! If they do a Pike series, Michael Giacchino is a must for the soundtrack
Also I love the Enterprise Turbolift Funhouse™. There's no way that fits anywhere inside
Also, my headcanon is that Upjohn is Scotty's mum.
And Star Trek Generations.
What's up with the new short treks in europe? When and where will they be released? Netflix or Amazon?
This is what, a year or so before The Cage? In The Cage, Spock was smiling at vibrating plants and screaming when THE WOMEN disappeared from the transporter room. If someone told me a year before that Spock was laughing while singing Modern Major General, I'd have no problem believing that.
Of course it fits. The turboshaft is bigger on the inside. There is precedent for such objects in Trek.
Perhaps it was Spock's experiences with the Red Angel that got him to abandon this kind of overt emotionalism.
He was smiling pretty big in “Where No Man...”.
I tend to go with Dorothy Fontana’s explanation, he smiled and showed emotion in an attempt to fit in.
Except that he didn't abandon it.
He didn’t abandon emotion, but there was a definite shift to a more publicly stoic Spock as TOS progressed.
And how is anything presented in the episode antithetical to that? He was sharing an intimate moment with someone he was connecting with in private.
For 98% of theime in the episode, he was completely 'stoic.'
For 98% of theime in the episode, he was completely 'stoic.'
With the previous Shorts, Netflix Netherlands didn't get them untill the season 2 premiered. Or a week before or so maybe. I would asume the same will happen this time.
This is easily my favorite Short Trek.
My wife hated it.
On my end, I got the impression that it was all about Una dealing with the fact she's trying to tease the New MeatTM and encourage him to both come out of his shell a bit while also reminding him that he needs to also project how he wants to be. Basically, giving him the "fake it until you make it" speech. It backfires horribly because she gave this advice right before being trapped for what is apparently a day in an elevator where she literally goes crazy for a bit and ends up singing to pass the time.
She also refuses to tell Spock to shut up in his questions and undermine her own point.
My wife hated it.
On my end, I got the impression that it was all about Una dealing with the fact she's trying to tease the New MeatTM and encourage him to both come out of his shell a bit while also reminding him that he needs to also project how he wants to be. Basically, giving him the "fake it until you make it" speech. It backfires horribly because she gave this advice right before being trapped for what is apparently a day in an elevator where she literally goes crazy for a bit and ends up singing to pass the time.
She also refuses to tell Spock to shut up in his questions and undermine her own point.
last year's "season" of short treks began with what was arguably the weakest installment ("runaway"), i wonder if the same will hold true this year.
i liked this a lot, it's an auspicious beginning that continues to support the argument we need a USS enterprise spin-off (weird, it's always been the other way around). loved the kelvin timeline musical nods and i'm real curious how memory-alpha is going to turn itself into a pretzel to explain away all the visual discontinuities.
i liked this a lot, it's an auspicious beginning that continues to support the argument we need a USS enterprise spin-off (weird, it's always been the other way around). loved the kelvin timeline musical nods and i'm real curious how memory-alpha is going to turn itself into a pretzel to explain away all the visual discontinuities.
Last edited:
Similar threads
