• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Poll Who's the Red Angel?

Who's the Red Angel?

  • Burnham

    Votes: 25 33.3%
  • Zora

    Votes: 8 10.7%
  • Ariam

    Votes: 4 5.3%
  • Someone else who we've seen before

    Votes: 24 32.0%
  • Someone else who we've *never* seen before

    Votes: 14 18.7%

  • Total voters
    75
Here's who I think it's not:

- Airiam. She has obviously been taken over by some kind of malevolent force - probably the same one which is intending to wipe out all life in the galaxy, as we've seen in the 'flash forwards' - and I'm not seeing her working against the DSC crew while at the same time being the Red Angel who's working WITH them.

- Burnham. If it had been, then why didn't Spock sense his own sister during the mind meld on the ice planet?
 
Is another thread really necessary? what's wrong with the old one?

This is specifically a poll thread with poll results at the top. I don't believe Xenforo allows you to create polls inside posts that aren't the original. Even if you could, any poll I'd create would end up lost in a sea of future pages.

And it's not about theories. Just a simple vote.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it makes much logical sense for the Angel to be Burnham, but regardless that was my intuition when I saw the Angel up close, so that's my vote. After all this is Burnahm's story, so if it is someone who we know, it is most likely her. Also, I think the Angel's physique matched SMG.
 
Penultimate Scene of Season 2:

PIKE: I'm the Red Angel.
BURNHAM: No, I'm the Red Angel.
DETMER: I'm the Red Angel.
AIRIAM: I am the Red Angel.
TILLY: F***, okay I'm Red. And an Angel.
DISCOVERY COMPUTER: I am really the Red Angel.
AMANDA: I am and was the Red Angel.
NUMBER ONE: I am the first Red Angel.
LORCA: Maybe I'm the Red Angel?
MAY: If Tilly's the Red Angel, then I am also the Red Angel.
PICARD: I!... am the Red Angel.
GEORGIOU: (whispers to camers) Actually, I was the Red Angel all along.
 
As a matter of interest, why Zora ?
Is this the Zora from "The Savage Curtain" who experimented genetically on prisoners ?

No, that's a different Zora.

The one from DSC is...

the computer system of the Discovery, which has become sentient after drifting in space for a thousand years

Penultimate Scene of Season 2:

PIKE: I'm the Red Angel.
BURNHAM: No, I'm the Red Angel.
DETMER: I'm the Red Angel.
AIRIAM: I am the Red Angel.
TILLY: F***, okay I'm Red. And an Angel.
DISCOVERY COMPUTER: I am really the Red Angel.
AMANDA: I am and was the Red Angel.
NUMBER ONE: I am the first Red Angel.
LORCA: Maybe I'm the Red Angel?
MAY: If Tilly's the Red Angel, then I am also the Red Angel.
PICARD: I!... am the Red Angel.
GEORGIOU: (whispers to camers) Actually, I was the Red Angel all along.

SAREK: I'm the Red Angel and so's my wife!
 
Last edited:
I say it's Detmer, Owosekun got to go on an away mission, Airiam gets to be a possessed villain, now it's Detmer's turn.
Bryce and Rhys will get a moment too but this one's Detmer's.
 
Penultimate Scene of Season 2:

PIKE: I'm the Red Angel.
BURNHAM: No, I'm the Red Angel.
DETMER: I'm the Red Angel.
AIRIAM: I am the Red Angel.
TILLY: F***, okay I'm Red. And an Angel.
DISCOVERY COMPUTER: I am really the Red Angel.
AMANDA: I am and was the Red Angel.
NUMBER ONE: I am the first Red Angel.
LORCA: Maybe I'm the Red Angel?
MAY: If Tilly's the Red Angel, then I am also the Red Angel.
PICARD: I!... am the Red Angel.
GEORGIOU: (whispers to camers) Actually, I was the Red Angel all along.

:techman:

Will the real Red Angel please stand up....

#totellthetruth

Truth.jpg
 
It absolutely will not be some minor character like Detmer, Airiam, or Zora. If it is someone we know, it will be major character.
 
I voted for the field: someone else that we know. It could be Tilly, Cornwell, Amanda or someone else.

Is the assumption that it is female based on it looking kind of like a female shape? That could be a red herring. Spock only said that it’s a human.
 
I voted for the field: someone else that we know. It could be Tilly, Cornwell, Amanda or someone else.

Is the assumption that it is female based on it looking kind of like a female shape? That could be a red herring. Spock only said that it’s a human.

The hips and shoulders look very feminine. The area around the chest is also very dark as if to obscure. I think it's a woman. It could be male but the shoulders aren't very broad so he'd have to be either a boy or petite.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top