Spoilers General Disco Chat Thread
- Thread starter Lord Garth
- Start date
Probably not, given that this is not the Kelvin timeline.
So the Enterprise we saw on Discovery is from the TOS timeline? I guess then we will see Vina next week.
Well, it's sure not the Abrams Enterprise. If you don't want to think of as the TOS Timeline, just go with a Third Timeline.
This. I've said before that if it helps you enjoy the product more to place it into an alternate universe, then more power to you. It's all a fictional construct anyway. However, the timeline of events don't match up for it to be the Kelvin universe.
Last edited:
Another one?
Now I'm imagining Burnham down in the cave complex watching the events of 2254 on one of their jagged screens:
"Who's that guy? That's not Pike. Lasers? Time warp barrier? What's with all the paper? Why are you laughing, Spock? And where's your beard? I like the eyebrows. You guys sure messed up the look of the Enterprise."
Yes
I can't think of any reason why they would show her, it's not relevant to the story.
I'd be surprised but it's possible, if, as Tuskin38 points out, irrelevant.
As if the critics don't have enough fan service to gripe about.
I could see the Talosians making some comment to Michael about how "only one human lives on Talos IV" or something of the like.
Please describe in detail what you get for dinner
Gagh.
What sauce?
Death Sauce. I'm typing through a Ouija board.
I think it's funny that you think this board is an echo chamber. I'm sure you would have zero issue if everyone was agreeing with your opinion. Honestly, if I didn't like Discovery I wouldn't watch it. It wouldn't matter to me that it is Star Trek. Discovery isn't perfect by any means, and I'm not saying that some of your criticisms are not valid, but i think the notion that it's doing all these horrible things that other Trek series have never done doesn't hold water.
Take 'Gene's vision' for example, Deep Space Nine was all about rebelling against that vision. It was dark, had good characters doing bad things, featured a war and generally depicted the Federation in a harsher light and with a more critical eye than any other series did. Yet it is held in high regard by much of the fan base. Showrunners of Star Trek have been critical of 'Gene's vision' since the Wrath of Khan. Even TNG tried it once or twice while Rick Berman wasn't looking.
There is a reason that Star Trek died in 2004 and didn't come back to television for another 12 years, you know.
Last edited:
no doubt man, that stuff is spicy
I can't think of any reason why they wouldn't. There's a human visiting, and they have a human. Definitely needs a reference to their menagerie.
the last time I saw a clip show was back in the ole Stargate SG-1 and Atlantis days.
And even there only if he's a plane.
Similar threads
