• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Series 11 News & Spoilers

I can't wait till RTD is gone with his gay agenda and soapy shit.
Moffat too complicated and sexist. Moffat Out!...
Wait I mean Chibnall is boring and a terrible write. Get rid of him!

Fans are the fucking worst.

In all fandoms.

Just started the series today and I could easily watch a few years of it, putting up with the same small minded scared little shits whining because someone or something they can't handle being the focus could wear on the nerves though.
 
It's more honest than "I love everything they do" because....well, just because. Rose colored glasses and all.

S11 is different, maybe too much so. Good stories, good cast, not so much on the action and monsters I really do like to see from DW.

I've been watching for 40 years and I'll keep watching. Even bad Who is better than 95% of the crap that's out there, but I'm not going to say all Who is great. There's always room for improvement.
It isn't any more honest to hate on everything than it is to love everything.

Admitting some episodes are good, some are bad, some of decent, some are fun but not really good, that's honest. And "Bad X is better than 95% of the crap out there" is hardly honest either.
 
A friend of mine on Facebook was the same. He hated Moffat and never, ever gave him due, even in his better episodes (he's not a fan of Heaven Sent, although he appreciates Capaldi's turn in it). He repeatedly praised Peter Capaldi while slamming everything else. And now, he really hates Chibnall and doesn't like Whittaker at all. And found Demons tremendously boring.

There really is no pleasing some people.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Looks like Jodie and Chibnall are calling it quits early
 
Hasn't the same thing been claimed every single year the show has aired since 2005?

I'll believe it when the BBC announces it and only when they announce it.
 
Geez... Chibnill is complaining about 10 episodes being overwhelming. I don't think he'll ever be producing in the US.

Bring back RTD! :)
 
Chibnall may or may not leave, that's "50-50" as you put it. But Whittaker is under a three year contract. She can't leave until she's done her third year.
Unless she and the BBC came to an arrangement. I agree it'd be unlikely though and we might finally get the one thing we're yet to see in modern Who, the same Doctor under multiple showrunners.
 
Thinking about this matter, assuming Whittaker did leave with Chibnall, couldn't that potentially damage her career? It'd be one thing if BBC were unfairly forcing Chibnall out against his will, in that case I can see showing solidarity with your producer would make you look better to other potential producers you'd work with later on. But, according to these "reports" Chibnall is voluntarily leaving, in which case if Whittaker chose to leave the show just because of a change of producers, wouldn't others be hesitant to cast her since there's every bit the possibility she'd leave again due to change in producers?

Of course, there's too much wrong with this story. BBC didn't want RTD to leave after five years, and tried to make him stay by backing a dump truck loaded with cash to his doorstep. When he refused that, they considered ending the show. Moffat also tried to call it quits after five years, and they persuaded him to stay two more years to produce one more season. I highly doubt BBC would let Chibnall after only one successful season that has arguably reinvigorated the show.

Also, Whittaker seems very happy with the show and appears to be enjoying herself. Also, she knows how important many of audience in general, but most especially the female audience consider having a female Doctor to be. As a self-described feminist (according to her Wikipedia page) I do not see why she would leave a job she enjoys where she is able to be an inspiration and positive role model to other women/girls (and even men/boys of course) just because a man is leaving. That just doesn't add up at all.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top