• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

“Jean-Luc Picard is back”: will new Picard show eclipse Discovery?

The main appeal for their Picard show really is, well, Picard.

I guess if they had the chance, they would probably much more prefer to create other new series in the DIS-timeframe, where they could re-use a lots of props and sets, and easily have cross-over events. Their return to the 24th century is probably simply only owed to the circumstances of Picard living there.
 
The main appeal for their Picard show really is, well, Picard.

I guess if they had the chance, they would probably much more prefer to create other new series in the DIS-timeframe, where they could re-use a lots of props and sets, and easily have cross-over events. Their return to the 24th century is probably simply only owed to the circumstances of Picard living there.

You're probably right. You could have Patrick Stewart as Picard reciting Yiddish limericks, and it would probably still be a homerun with a big enough percentage of the fanbase.

Picard isn't even my favorite character, and I'm still eagerly looking forward to the new show, and will support it unless it turns out to be abysmal...which I can't imagine. Stewart is a great guy and a very good actor.
 
The Briefing Room scene in The Corbomite Maneuver is my favorite.
^^^
For me TOS - "The Corbomite Maneuver" is the best episode ever made in the Star Trek franchise as in encapsulates everything I like (including the premise of the series itself) in a neat, engaging 55 minute package. To this day, I LOVE the fact that Kirk's epiphany about a possible way to get out of the situation comes BECAUSE he's having a minor argument with Doctor McCoy over another small issue - (and as to the issue, they both ralize that it was stupid to be worrying about that then, BUT it just shows they're both Human, with Human weaknesses; but they still remain good friends and colleagues and work together, etc.)

I ALSO love that at this point, Spock is not a 'know it all':
KIRK: There must be something to do, something I've overlooked.

SPOCK: In chess, when one is outmatched, the game is over. Checkmate.

KIRK: Is that your best recommendation?

SPOCK: I'm sor...I regret that I can find no other logical alternative.

and just after Kirk's epiphany:
BALOK [OC]: Three minutes.
KIRK: All right, Doctor. Let's hope we have time to argue about it. Not chess, Mister Spock, poker. Do you know the game? Ship to ship.

and after the deadline passes and Balok doesn't fire:
SPOCK: A very interesting game, this poker.

KIRK: It does have advantages over chess.

MCCOY: Love to teach it to you.

And yes, the briefing room scene is good too. A lot of great character interplay and tension.
 
They may try to tie Discovery into the picard show somehow. Discoverys vulcan admiral terral could theoretically still be alive in 2399 (if terral is 37 in 2256 he would be 180 in 2399, younger than sarek when he died at 203).
 
They may try to tie Discovery into the picard show somehow. Discoverys vulcan admiral terral could theoretically still be alive in 2399 (if terral is 37 in 2256 he would be 180 in 2399, younger than sarek when he died at 203).
I doubt they’ll do anything that ties in that directly.
 
You're probably right. You could have Patrick Stewart as Picard reciting Yiddish limericks, and it would probably still be a homerun with a big enough percentage of the fanbase.

Picard isn't even my favorite character, and I'm still eagerly looking forward to the new show, and will support it unless it turns out to be abysmal...which I can't imagine. Stewart is a great guy and a very good actor.
Maybe. I’m actually a little worried that Stewart may have too much input. After all, he *liked Picard as action hero in the movies and wanted him to be more of a ladies’ man.

Actors may act well, they may know their character better than anyone, but they, like any of us, are subject to the will of the gods. When they’re not, it doesn’t quite ring true.
 
Maybe. I’m actually a little worried that Stewart may have too much input. After all, he *liked Picard as action hero in the movies and wanted him to be more of a ladies’ man.

Actors may act well, they may know their character better than anyone, but they, like any of us, are subject to the will of the gods. When they’re not, it doesn’t quite ring true.

Good point, but I'd hope/suspect that 16 years later...he's developed a more mature and realistic view of his character.
 
I think it's safe to say we won't be seeing JeanLuc "McClane" Picard this time around. ;)

Thank God for that. If we do see John McClane Picard then, no matter how much several of us might disagree about Discovery, at least we'll have something we can all agree about.

It'll be weird arguing with some people about DSC here, but then for the Picard Series we might possibly be on the same page. Talk about serious whip-lash going from one forum to the other.
 
Last edited:
Thank God for that. If we do see John McClane Picard then, no matter how much several of us might disagree about Discovery, at least we'll have something we can all agree about.
Can we at least have Picard climbing through a Jeffery's tube sarcastically saying "Come down to the coast, get together. Have a few laughs?" :D
 
I had heard he wanted the dune buggy scene - which was the most out of place part of nemesis. If they had cut that and added in more character development it could have been a much better movie.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top