• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Wars Books Thread

Another year, another group of the least interesting books. I can't wait until we get a Claudia Grey book all about Yoda's foot fungus, or a James Lucerno book about that one time Space FedEx didn't deliver Palpatine's new Space Ipad withing the estimated delivery date. At this point, the books are so boring an unimportant they might as well make them all non canon so they can go back to writing actually interesting stories, as opposed to only being allowed to touch stuff that Disney has no desire to touch, which is almost nothing based off the outright terrible, obscure topics for these books.

Disney only puts out 2-3 real SW books a year, wouold it kill them to allow those authors to do something meaty once and awhile? Something that effects the whole Universe or at least some of the biggest characters in the universe, even if its just in a time period before the main movies? As opposed to just publishing novelizations and one or two pointless side stories about minor characters like Phasma (that don't even really explain who she is because the movies needed to keep that option even though they never used it) or dead, boring characters like Padme (seriously, even TCW cartoon couldn't make Padme interesting, and that show actually made me give a shit about Anakin Skywalker).

Edit: Actually, apparently the Padme book might be a kids book, but regardless my point still stands about the real SW books all being about small, pointless crap even though they could easily tell important stories that the movies/shows will never need to mention.
 
You have very high standards. Maybe too high.

The Obi-Wan/Qui-Gon book seems the most interesting.

I love 95% of the old EU books. I even like most of the generally hated stuff (outside of the bad Insect trilogy and the Jason Solo stuff in LotF, which I hate along with most readers). Most people seem to think I don't have standards when it comes to SW books at all :lol: I just prefer the books to have a point, and to cover something somewhat interesting. Even TCW cartoon couldn't make Padme into a good character. Plus, the books were the perfect place to make Phasma a well rounded character, and they didn't. It wasn't even because the movies were going to do it, because she barely had any screen time in either of them. The books are no longer even allowed to flesh out the barely used side characters any more, iunless the character in question is strictly from the books, comics or cartoons. if there is any movie connection (to the new main movies, at least), then any book about the character is just fluff that doesn't change anything.

Give me a book really about characters like Phasma, Hux, Snoke, Maz, etc, or about important events after RotJ, and I'd be at least somewhat happy even if they only put out 1 or 2 real SW books a year. As of right now though, it looks like the Thrawn sequel will be the only decent SW book released this year.
 
I love 95% of the old EU books. I even like most of the generally hated stuff (outside of the bad Insect trilogy and the Jason Solo stuff in LotF, which I hate along with most readers). Most people seem to think I don't have standards when it comes to SW books at all :lol: I just prefer the books to have a point, and to cover something somewhat interesting. Even TCW cartoon couldn't make Padme into a good character. Plus, the books were the perfect place to make Phasma a well rounded character, and they didn't. It wasn't even because the movies were going to do it, because she barely had any screen time in either of them. The books are no longer even allowed to flesh out the barely used side characters any more, iunless the character in question is strictly from the books, comics or cartoons. if there is any movie connection (to the new main movies, at least), then any book about the character is just fluff that doesn't change anything.

Give me a book really about characters like Phasma, Hux, Snoke, Maz, etc, or about important events after RotJ, and I'd be at least somewhat happy even if they only put out 1 or 2 real SW books a year. As of right now though, it looks like the Thrawn sequel will be the only decent SW book released this year.

We had an entire novel dedicated to Phasma and her backstory.
 
And a comic series, she'll be appearing in Resistance, and I believe she made some appearances in the Poe Dameron comic series. Phasma has been underused by the movies, but she's had a pretty big presence in the tie-ins.
Some of the big events right after ROTJ were dealt with in the Aftermath books, and the immediate aftermath of the battle of Endor and the death of the Emperor was covered in Shattered Empire. There's also the story mode for Battlefront 2, but I'm not sure where exact;u that one is in the timeline.
 
We had an entire novel dedicated to Phasma and her backstory.

Yeah, and it wasn't exactly revealing from what I saw/read of it. Nothing connected to the new movies will ever be fleshed out in the books, even if Disney knows it has no intention of expanding on certain elements in the movies. It obviously doesn't like publishing books, so its just handing out table scrap assignments to a few writers to make a few bucks off of the fans who will buy anything they decide to print.

And a comic series, she'll be appearing in Resistance, and I believe she made some appearances in the Poe Dameron comic series. Phasma has been underused by the movies, but she's had a pretty big presence in the tie-ins.
Some of the big events right after ROTJ were dealt with in the Aftermath books, and the immediate aftermath of the battle of Endor and the death of the Emperor was covered in Shattered Empire. There's also the story mode for Battlefront 2, but I'm not sure where exact;u that one is in the timeline.

Aftermath was a travesty, one of the worst written books series in SW history (including some of the worst of the old EU). Shattered Empire was a badly done 4 issue mini that edidn't explain shit. There is thirty years of post Rotj stories that could be told about the whole universe and wouldn't have to effect the new movies at all. Instead we're getting mostly fluff and stories based on characters that have been done to death or are just kind of crap.
 
Claudia Grey's writing another book? I was sold even before I saw that it was about Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan.
A Claudia Grey written Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan novel just became my most anticipated novel. I want it right now.

The Padme book also seems promising. EK Johnson is the one who wrote the Ahsoka novel, right? That's definitely some points towards it.
I can't wait until we get a Claudia Grey book all about Yoda's foot fungus
I won't lie, that would probably be awesome.
 
I won't lie, that would probably be awesome.

It will have a tween romance with his ear wax, because the ear wax is secretly a follower of the sith but the fungus just loves the wax's dark, broody personality and thinks it can turn the wax back to the light.
 
I didn't think of the whole Satine/Obi-Wan story being part of Master and Apprentice, I would love if it was, but I don't see it as real likely.
Yeah, and it wasn't exactly revealing from what I saw/read of it. Nothing connected to the new movies will ever be fleshed out in the books, even if Disney knows it has no intention of expanding on certain elements in the movies. It obviously doesn't like publishing books, so its just handing out table scrap assignments to a few writers to make a few bucks off of the fans who will buy anything they decide to print.
I haven't read it, but from what I have read in excerpts and reviews, Phasma deals with her early life back on her homeworld and how she was recruited to The First Order. Those are some pretty big parts of her backstory to cover.
We've also had the Bloodline, which I believe dealt with how Leia went from the New Republic to The Resistance, and the Poe Dameron comic series, which fleshes out Poe and his fellow pilots, and deals with the events right before TFA.
There were also a couple books dealing with Rose and her sister before TLJ, and we've had the two Visual Guides, which fill in a bit of backstory.
We've also had several Forces of Destiny shorts and comics, and Star Wars Adventures comics focused on TFA and TLJ characters.
We might not have gotten the big questions answered, but there have been quite a few stories that help to flesh out the characters from TFA and TLJ.

Aftermath was a travesty, one of the worst written books series in SW history (including some of the worst of the old EU). Shattered Empire was a badly done 4 issue mini that edidn't explain shit. There is thirty years of post Rotj stories that could be told about the whole universe and wouldn't have to effect the new movies at all. Instead we're getting mostly fluff and stories based on characters that have been done to death or are just kind of crap.
The quality of Aftermath doesn't change the fact that it does reveal a lot of what went on after ROTJ.
I enjoyed Shattered Empire, and while it didn't have any huge reveals it did still give us a pretty view of what our heroes were up to right after RotJ ended.
 
The quality of Aftermath doesn't change the fact that it does reveal a lot of what went on after ROTJ.
I enjoyed Shattered Empire, and while it didn't have any huge reveals it did still give us a pretty view of what our heroes were up to right after RotJ ended.

Aftermath talked about one or two events, but not well. Its explanation for the end of the empire was garbage, and none of it was good or that important. The dumbass magic brainwashing plot wasn't important either, unless you're super interested in the adventures of Porkins 2.0 as a kid with his stupid kill droid, I guess.

I haven't read it, but from what I have read in excerpts and reviews, Phasma deals with her early life back on her homeworld and how she was recruited to The First Order. Those are some pretty big parts of her backstory to cover.
We've also had the Bloodline, which I believe dealt with how Leia went from the New Republic to The Resistance, and the Poe Dameron comic series, which fleshes out Poe and his fellow pilots, and deals with the events right before TFA.
There were also a couple books dealing with Rose and her sister before TLJ, and we've had the two Visual Guides, which fill in a bit of backstory.
We've also had several Forces of Destiny shorts and comics, and Star Wars Adventures comics focused on TFA and TLJ characters.
We might not have gotten the big questions answered, but there have been quite a few stories that help to flesh out the characters from TFA and TLJ.

Bloodline wasn't bad, but its extremely skippable fluff. I haven't read the kiddie Rose books, but they're fluff at the very least. The Poe dameron comic is both terrible and fluff. Visual Guides don't count and aren't really canon (no writer or director is being held to what a kids picture book says), Forces of destiny cartoons are shit and show nothing important, same with the little kid Star Wars Adventures stuff (that are also of questionable continuity even though they don't show anything important.
 
I thought it covered the beginning of the New Republic, The Battle of Jakku, and set up the beginning of The First Order?
 
I thought it covered the beginning of the New Republic, The Battle of Jakku, and set up the beginning of The First Order?

It barely did those things. Honestly, all that could have been in one book, its padded out by the irritating story of "Snap" and friends.
 
But it still did them, that is all I'm talking about.

And its still barely anything, and there is still an uncountable number of potential stories in the era. But, instead, we get worthless junk, the table scraps that Disney allows the non-movie/TV stuff to use even when they aren't going to use most of the SW universe for the movies anyway.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top