• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The MOST Disliked Episode of VOYAGER - Season Five...

Nothing Human. A good examination of the merits of using ethically questionable research in the name of saving lives, only slightly let down by the Doctor coming off a little too moralizing in the last scene.
...

Not to mention that the idea of punishing a hologram (the last scene sounded like an execution) for the misdeeds of the person his likeness has been made after, seems a bit stupid.

It's like taking a picture of hitler and then throw darts at it...
Apparently, nothing would have happened if the doctor had just chosen a hologram from another species... which sounds stupid when you think about it.
 
I think that the overall winner of this game is going to be a ‘Kim meets a girl’ episode rather than one of the incredibly stupid ones.
 
I am saving "JUGGERNAUT". Well directed, and Roxann Dawson brings in another great performance. And it had some creepy moments, too... love that.

IN THE FLESH
ONCE UPON A TIME
INFINITE REGRESS
THIRTY DAYS
GRAVITY
THE DISEASE
 
Not sure I can get behind any of these episodes. I will remove Gravity, it is the only one left besides Thirty Days that isn't either really boring, really stupid, or ruins a good villain.

IN THE FLESH
ONCE UPON A TIME
INFINITE REGRESS
THIRTY DAYS
THE DISEASE
 
I am saving ONCE UPON A TIME. I totally feel with Naomi in this episode, especially when she's sneaking into the bridge and hears the bad news.

IN THE FLESH
INFINITE REGRESS
THIRTY DAYS
THE DISEASE
 
THIRTY DAYS: Tom Paris tries to do the "right thing" but behaves like a terrorist and endangers everybody. He's demoted and sentenced to thirty days in the brig but somehow will still manage to get promoted back before Kim is. Janeway works in mysterious ways...

IN THE FLESH
INFINITE REGRESS
THE DISEASE
 
"Infinite Regress" shouldn't be anywhere near the final two! For this exchange alone, after Naomi tells Seven she is determined to become Janeway's assistant.

Seven: "You hope to achieve this goal by emulating me?"
Naomi: "Are you mad?"
Seven: "No. There are many on this crew that would benefit from your example."

IN THE FLESH
THE DISEASE
 
"The Disease" didn't have Ray Walston, and did have an entire Starfleet code of conduct that we had literally never heard about until this point. Therefore, I am saving "In the Flesh."

THE DISEASE
 
My theory about 'Kim finds a girl' episodes is supported by this conclusion. The last three seasons have either been won by 'Kim meets a girl' eps or a 'Chakotay meets a girl' eps.
 
The 'winner' of this season is "THE DISEASE".

I have to say, I am surprised by the end results this season.

I shall begin season 6 shortly.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top