• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What else will be discovered then classified

I agree with this 100%. If they don't come back, it doesn't affect what comes later. This is what I expected (and still do to an extent) from the beginning. I have a feeling it won't happen though, because they are saying the closer we get to TOS, the more we'll see how this all ties in.
The crew of Discovery wind up in the Wormhole, become prophets and just chill.
 
Drexler had some good ideas for Enterprise J, the idea of it being esentially a city or series of cities inside, capable of going to other galaxies. (though all we see of it is fighting sphere builders with some very famliar looking ships, alongisde). But I dont think that type of future would work for trek.
My concern with this sort of thing is - ok it's a new type of ship that travels between galaxies instead of stars or whatever - but how does that actually make a different show? We go to New planets and meet the people who are all similar and allegorical to a modern day problem. We fight aliens, we have moral quandaries. Does it make any real difference to the story that those things are in the Andromeda galaxy?
 
My concern with this sort of thing is - ok it's a new type of ship that travels between galaxies instead of stars or whatever - but how does that actually make a different show? We go to New planets and meet the people who are all similar and allegorical to a modern day problem. We fight aliens, we have moral quandaries. Does it make any real difference to the story that those things are in the Andromeda galaxy?

No, we'll just just talk about the ship being measured in miles instead of metres, talk about star systems with different names, we'd replace light years with millions of light years, we'd replace Romulans, Klingons and Ferengi with.....I dunno, Dubians, Handrons and Zaruthians?

the show would stay the same, just different terminology
 
My concern with this sort of thing is - ok it's a new type of ship that travels between galaxies instead of stars or whatever - but how does that actually make a different show? We go to New planets and meet the people who are all similar and allegorical to a modern day problem. We fight aliens, we have moral quandaries. Does it make any real difference to the story that those things are in the Andromeda galaxy?
Indeed. It could depend on how different things really are out there. Maybe the future federation gives up Prime Directive and gets actively involved in civilization building. Not sure. I'm not really in favor of a post-nemesis show right now until there's a good reason for going there.
 
Indeed. It could depend on how different things really are out there. Maybe the future federation gives up Prime Directive and gets actively involved in civilization building. Not sure. I'm not really in favor of a post-nemesis show right now until there's a good reason for going there.
The issue is that, whatever nominal 'era' Trek is set in, it's basically the same thing. Ship and crew buzz around the galaxy by warp drive, carrying phasers, tricorders and communicators, having adventures. The only thing marching onwards into the future does is make technobabble dues ex machina easier and more tempting.

If we change that fundamental setup, we'll have a different show, but then we'd probably say it isn't Star Trek anymore.
 
We have had a bomb planted at the heart of Qo'noS, and never mentioned again, functional faster-than-transwarp drive, never mentioned again

Both things probably classified by Starfleet. The bomb removed/deactivated by the L'Rell once the unification is solidified.
 
Data's head, which is reverse-engineered by Dr. Noonian Soong's father, Dr. Aron Soong, and later perfected by Noonian to become Data, Lore, and B4. Which is, then, reburied under San Francisco so as not to create a time paradox.
 
...Sorry for being anal-retentive, but I think the fact that TOS did this a lot is a good way to demonstrate why it might not be so outlandish after all...

(I did click "like" before typing the deconstruction, tho!)

Timo Saloniemi

You seemingly missed the Guardian being under ongoing investigation as of TAS ;)
 
What I do think would work, and it was a proposal made to CBS was for a kind of emerging-from-dark ages type series. Something bad happens, galactic civilization falls apart, Starfleet rebuilds, or attempts to. THAT might be a post nemesis show I'd watch.
This isn't that hard. The Dominion War took its toll on the Federation. Some members left, and some new territory was exposed by the losses. The Federation is rebuilding, in its Reconstruction, like the Civil War in the U.S., were lots of things are going to need to be sifted through.

Post-Nemesis, with Romulus struggling with its own internal conflict, Cardassia and the Klingons also struggling, there is a lot of ripe territory for conflict, Starfleet rebuilding and trying to forge new alliances.
 
We have had a bomb planted at the heart of Qo'noS, and never mentioned again, functional faster-than-transwarp drive, never mentioned again - glancing at canon isn't the same as using it judiciously - do you think if they wanted Q in the show, or the Borg, that good taste will restrain them? I mean I wish that was true as much as you man.
How exactly do you know they were never mentioned again???? It's a big universe with trillions of people. A lot more than thimble full we see on screen.
Outside the fictional universe, the franchise isn't dead. There will be more episodes. There might even be more series and films. So never say never.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top