• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek Discovery Season 1: Overall Review Thread

Overall grade for Discovery Season 1

  • 10 - Amazing!

    Votes: 9 5.2%
  • 9

    Votes: 25 14.4%
  • 8

    Votes: 34 19.5%
  • 7

    Votes: 38 21.8%
  • 6

    Votes: 15 8.6%
  • 5

    Votes: 23 13.2%
  • 4

    Votes: 10 5.7%
  • 3

    Votes: 6 3.4%
  • 2

    Votes: 6 3.4%
  • 1 - Awful!

    Votes: 8 4.6%

  • Total voters
    174
All I know is, THIS was me during and after at least 13 of this season episodes.
Don't worry. You'll soon be depressed like everyone else ;)

Only True Star Trek fans hate Disco ;)

is its total lack of value as a show that you can rewatch.
I have never had this problem with any serialized show, from Daredevil on forward. There are moments that I will rewatch, episodes that I think are great for dissecting and enjoying.

Far from having no rewatch value, I think it has greater value because I want all the details within the show.
 
I think it's fitting that Disco has a Starship that was designed in the '70s. :evil:

But now I wonder if "haters" will have any Disco Sucks rallies.
 
You cannot really do that with a serialised show, and I really have no desire to rewatch this season of DIS, as I already know that the overarching story as a whole was a dud.

That hit the nail on the head. Serialized shows can be great, IF they can pull it off. If they cannot, the rewatchability of the whole season/series can go down the drain.
Episodic shows you can rewatch by watching just the good episodes (even TNG Season 1 had some) But imagine if TNG Season 1 was one long arc with no stand-alone episodes at all. The whole season would be wasted.
 
As I told my daughter at the beginning of her Star Trek journey - one watches all of Star Trek, in order, or one does not watch Star Trek :bolian:
Production order, broadcast order, or continuity order? ;)

Well, watching an episode / series grants you the right to bitch about it. Not watching it somehow excludes you from the club :guffaw:
Kinda like voting in an election?... :(

Interstellar is a film I watched where, towards the end I was balling my eyes out.
I trust you meant "bawling" there. Otherwise a whole different image springs to mind... :lol:

If I did my math correctly, the average score for Season 1 from this poll is ~6.6
For what it's worth.
Mean or median?

...now tell me which episodes of star trek: discovery you throw on while you're folding the laundry, cooking dinner, bored on a sunday afternoon, or are just bummed out and needing a pick me up.
Well, none. But I don't do that with any show. If I'm going to put a television show on, it's because I'm going to sit down in front of it and give it my focused attention.

And I think that's the standard shows should aspire to, really! Being "rewatchable" as something in the background that a viewer can semi-ignore isn't exactly a very high bar.

(FWIW, probably my most re-watched show in recent years is Game of Thrones. I've watched quite a lot of it multiple times, with multiple friends. With full, focused attention. Most episodes stand up to that remarkably well despite the show's heavily serialized nature. You pick up on terrific little nuances of storytelling and acting you might've missed the first time around...)
 
People keep making this comparison. Mass Effect is a video game, right? I am totally not a gamer, so this is basically lost on me. Care to elaborate a bit? How are they similar?

Mass Effect established a certain kind of design aesthetic that melded Trek curves with Galactica grit and its own flavor of hologram-based computer interface. You can definitely see its influence on Discovery, especially in set design, but also in smaller details like uniforms.

Take a look at this video, which is simply a walkthrough of the main player ship, the Normandy SR-2:
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Half the rooms on the Normandy feel like they could be just behind those black doors on the Discovery, right down to the lighting scheme and lens flare.

(Thing is, you can see Mass Effect's influence in practically everything SF these days, so there's not necessarily a direct lineage. When it came out, Mass Effect felt like something really very fresh and new, which was remarkable, given all the other space-SF stuff that had come out in the previous ten years, from Enterprise to Farscape. But it's really suffered from the Seinfeld Effect, and doesn't seem fresh anymore because of its many imitators.)

I don't think Mass Effect's influence on Discovery goes beyond that, though. Mass Effect has a very different feel to it than Discovery, particularly in its first two, when you really felt like you were exploring a brand new galaxy.* Frankly, Mass Effect regularly feels more like Star Trek than Discovery does. In the early 2010s, I thought ME would be a good source of inspiration for a new Trek series, but Disco didn't really take from ME what I think it should have -- and put my design sense into permanent revolt when it decided to set the whole thing in the 2250s, when things were supposed to look quite different (and much brighter) than this.

*(Ironically, the final game in the series, Andromeda, which actually did claim to send you to explore a brand new galaxy, feels much smaller and more cramped than its predecessors.)
 
Thing is, you can see Mass Effect's influence in practically everything SF these days, so there's not necessarily a direct lineage.
This illustrates my personal irritation with Mass Effect and why I don't regard it with anything more than mild eye candy.
 
Last edited:
Mass Effect established a certain kind of design aesthetic that melded Trek curves with Galactica grit and its own flavor of hologram-based computer interface. You can definitely see its influence on Discovery, especially in set design, but also in smaller details like uniforms.

Take a look at this video, which is simply a walkthrough of the main player ship...
Hmm, okay, thanks. There's a definite aesthetic there, and I can see what you mean. I don't so much see any Trek influence in ME, although the BSG influence is obvious. But the influence of ME on DSC (and other shows) does indeed seem pretty clear.

...but Disco didn't really take from ME what I think it should have -- and put my design sense into permanent revolt when it decided to set the whole thing in the 2250s, when things were supposed to look quite different (and much brighter) than this.
Hear, hear.
 
Yes, fixed that. Thanks!



YouTube Comments Sections. To quote Spock, "Splendid examples of Homo Sapiens."
95p2y8w.jpg
 
Some good stuff, but a flat ending. Not as much character development as I'd have liked other than Staments. A Klingon war that never felt like a big deal. Lots of fun in the Mirror Universe. Some deeply shitty plot decisions (Mirror Lorca, taking a complex character and turning him into a WWE villain for his last episode) and somehow everything always felt rushed.

Hoping for better in season two.
 
I'm just sticking it here because I don't know where to put it, but I read a (mostly negative) review on my phone of the season last night which brought up a good point.

The reason L'Rell was in the brig for all of Arc 2 was because they knew they needed her for the last episode.
We know this because by Harbets' own account they started with the ending and then filled in the middle. Yet they had no idea what to do with her up until the end of the season, which is why she just sat in the brig doing nothing (except occasionally talking to people who came in - and "fixing" Tyler) for five episodes straight.
 
Some good stuff, but a flat ending. Not as much character development as I'd have liked other than Staments. A Klingon war that never felt like a big deal. Lots of fun in the Mirror Universe. Some deeply shitty plot decisions (Mirror Lorca, taking a complex character and turning him into a WWE villain for his last episode) and somehow everything always felt rushed.

Hoping for better in season two.
Since I agree with everything you wrote, I'm just quoting because I can't be arsed to type it my self :biggrin: :bolian:

Q2
 
I'm just sticking it here because I don't know where to put it, but I read a (mostly negative) review on my phone of the season last night which brought up a good point.

The reason L'Rell was in the brig for all of Arc 2 was because they knew they needed her for the last episode.
We know this because by Harbets' own account they started with the ending and then filled in the middle. Yet they had no idea what to do with her up until the end of the season, which is why she just sat in the brig doing nothing (except occasionally talking to people who came in - and "fixing" Tyler) for five episodes straight.
Wish they had done more with her, but I was glad to see her in the finale. Good wrap up.
 
Wish they had done more with her, but I was glad to see her in the finale. Good wrap up.
Well, they had perfect opportunity to create some sort of connection between her and the crew so that the ending would have not been so absurd, but they didn't. Because why would they. It is apparently enough if characters just do plot convenient things at appropriate moments without any sort of internal logic or emotional impact.
 
Well, they had perfect opportunity to create some sort of connection between her and the crew so that the ending would have not been so absurd, but they didn't. Because why would they. It is apparently enough if characters just do plot convenient things at appropriate moments without any sort of internal logic or emotional impact.
I found it logical and emotional :shrug:
 
I found it logical and emotional :shrug:
So you think there was a good buildup towards L'Rell being willing to relinquish her hostility towards the Federation? That she had an emotional connection with Burnham, so it made sense and had emotional impact that it was Burnham who convinced her?
 
So you think there was a good buildup towards L'Rell being willing to relinquish her hostility towards the Federation? That she had an emotional connection with Burnham, so it made sense and had emotional impact that it was Burnham who convinced her?

Yeah. She was still defiant at the beginning portion of that very episode.

Although, trapped in the brig, what the hell could they have done? I mean I suppose they could show her data when they got back to the Prime Universe that the Klingon Empire was divided into factions, but she couldn't trust that it wasn't doctored.

Really, they should have found some way to get MU Voq onboard the Discovery. If he had a conversation with her, it might have made some sort of difference in her character arc.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top