• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 1x07 - "Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    335
Entertaining and never dull, with a quick and lively pace, but to me the weakest of 1x03-1x07. I prefer Discovery's usual tone and ongoing story. I found the other episodes to be measurably more fun, despite being more serious. This felt like an episode for folks who prefer a more traditional Trek, which is fine...just not so much my thing.

Still, I had fun.

EDIT to add: as a major TNG fan, what this show is showing me is that I do NOT want more TNG, have very little interest or faith in the Berman-era storytelling format, and very much want a show that upsets the Trek status quo...which is to say that Discovery, generally speaking, is a good fit for me. Less so this episode.
 
I gave it a 7 initially. Good fun. Some development for Burnham, Stamets, Tyler, & Lorca. A twist on a Trek trope. Nothing wrong with that.

Or was there? I mean, did we just forget about the Admiral getting kidnapped? Apparently the war is going swimmingly. No rescue OP from Star Fleet. Everyone is just all Okey-Dokey with that? Sure, save the space whales & tardigrades. Enforce the 24th century Endangered Species Act (that Lorca doesn't know/care about). But save an admiral wiyh intimate knowledge of your secret weapon who is in the hands of the enemy? Nah!

Should have downgraded it for that.
 
Star Trek has always had its planets weirdly underpopulated. Colonies with a few thousand people, and homeworlds with millions, rather than billions, of people.

Maybe it's just that in the post-scarcity future, people are too busy enjoying life to have kids very often, so the population is continually shrinking?

Yeah, but sometimes they're kind of all over the place. A lot of planets have hundreds of millions, I remember that one in Dark Frontier had a few hundred thousand (I refuse to believe that wasn't a colony), but there have been higher numbers as well. I believe there were 12 billion Denobulans, and there were 50 billion Husnock. Then in the DS9 episode they said that the Dominion War would have 900 billion casualties if the Dominion conquered everything.
 
I gave it a 7 initially. Good fun. Some development for Burnham, Stamets, Tyler, & Lorca. A twist on a Trek trope. Nothing wrong with that.

Or was there? I mean, did we just forget about the Admiral getting kidnapped? Apparently the war is going swimmingly. No rescue OP from Star Fleet. Everyone is just all Okey-Dokey with that? Sure, save the space whales & tardigrades. Enforce the 24th century Endangered Species Act (that Lorca doesn't know/care about). But save an admiral wiyh intimate knowledge of your secret weapon who is in the hands of the enemy? Nah!

Should have downgraded it for that.

Well, we know Lorca doesn't want to save her and left it to Starfleet who doesn't want him ever using their super teleportation ship.

The only person who wants to use it is Lorca.

Everyone else just wants him perfecting how to replicate it.
 
I have a bad feeling about Sara for the next episode. hopefully, he doesn't get killed off.
 
My issue is with the music, lighting etc... The party looked too much like a party from today rather than from the future.

There's no way the writers could possibly know how humans will really think, act, party, etc. this far in the future. But that's never been what Trek's all about, anyway.

Trek has never been about the real future, or how humans will really act in that future. It's about US - present-day humans, just in a future framework.

Besides, they try to get too futuristic, they'll alienate present-day viewers... ;)

though I'll be very worried if we ever see a
USS Nowak

I'm not following. :confused:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top