5/10
This was a close call, I made a decision to cancel CBSAA if this episode fell below 5/10 and it turned out to be the best episode yet. Interestingly enough it came after Orville's weakest episode and for the first time they almost tied in quality. So I guess I'm going to continue watching both for now.
I enjoyed the pace, a significant improvement on previous episodes, probably because we didn't get 20 minutes of mumbling "Klingons"
The science is still iffy, but at least it's been explained a tad bit better.
The characters are, I'm shocked to say, coming together. I still don't get a feeling of the crew as I have with every Trek series and my disdain for the michael-point-of-view has only been reinforced. I want to see the crew as a team and it's also time to kill off Michael and change POV to Lorca.
The Mudd scene was okay, which is substantially above of what I expected.
Still don't like the underlying long arc format, but it had a bit of an episodic feel to it, which is great. Overall it still feels like a StarTrek movie instead of an episode, which is not a good thing, I've always felt that movies were all worse than most of the episodes, but in STDs case it's a very slow dragged out movie.
StarTrek was often mediocre and STD achieving mediocrity with this episode is no small feat, I was pleasantly surprised.
I still can't imagine how and if STD is going to be able to pull off a great episode of 8/10 and above, but I saw a glimmer of hope in this one.