• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Christopher Nolan's D U N K I R K

Also sorely apparent: Nolan's fetish-level hate for CG. Apparently 30 or so boats evacuated those 300,000 troops, but it never looked like more than 3,000 to moi.

I'm guessing you've transposed your numbers there. To be honest I had an issue with the scale (probably about the only issue I had with the film) and would have loved to have seen more little boats. That said, I think what Nolan was trying to do was show a snapshot rather than encompass the whole damn evacuation which would have necessitated Churchill, strategy meeting etc. I mean, did Saving Private Ryan feature the entirety of the Normandy landings? A larger scale film may well have swamped the screen with men, Spitfires, little boats, Messerschmitts and the like, and frankly whilst I don't hate CGI, I like the fact that Nolan eschewed it here for the most part.

My understanding is a lot of men were in the town rather than on the beach, and from a stylistic angle the lack of hundreds of thousands of men on the beach only added to the apocalyptic isolation those men must have felt.

There were women on the Royal Navy ships in the film so they weren't just waiting at home. Again though we're talking about a snapshot, and the same applies to non white characters. My understanding is that there were some colonial troops at Dunkirk, but we were talking hundreds within hundreds of thousands, and one imagines they were clustered together rather than scattered amongst the troops. It seems likely there were probably more black French soldiers than we saw though.

There's no doubt films to be made detailing the experiences of many people at Dunkirk, doesn't mean Nolan is beholden to detail every one of those stories, and who knows, maybe the very success of Dunkirk will help someone get the funding for a film about those telephonists, or the Indian troops who were there.

This is interesting
 
The trailer that immediately preceded Dunkirk for me was Churchill and focused on his role in the Dunkirk evacuation.
 
I watched the movie today and honestly I was bored. Technically it was really good and you are immersed in the war, but when there is no emotional connection to the characters, it's hard to accept the message of sacrifice this movie was trying to portray.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top