Best guest star

[Green]

So many good ones.......
Michael Forest as Apollo -- he pulls it off.
Lockwood
Windom
Barbara Anderson as Lenore -- that's damn fine work for a 19 year old kid.
Oliver
Kellerman
Lenard
W. Marshall
Colicos
Lovsky
Belli -- just checking to see if you were paying attention

 

[Green]

OCD me has to do a worst list.....

Not that they are bad actors -- just happened to not like them in their role. Maybe script or direction fault.

Ihnat -- good in other things, just shrill and hammy in this.
Campbell in Tribbles -- I get the episode was comedic, but he just seemed wrong
Pollard -- no doubt the script was responsible but he's too annoying. Darby was good.
Fix -- great actor in westerns and such but showed nothing with his few lines in WNMHGB
Belli -- 'nuff said
Solari -- just didn't work as a native American for me. I'm not saying only a indian actor could have pulled it off, just that he didn't IMO
S. Howard as Mara -- she was like 20 years younger than Ansara and seemed a little light for the role of an officer and wife of such a man.

Hmmm, there aren't really many bad performances in TOS. For the most part the worst acting was by really young and inexperienced actors with a line of two -- like the transporter operator who Lazarus knocks out or the guard assigned to Harry Mudd. And it's not really fair to bash them.

 

[UnknownSample]

Blacula and Yeoman Barrows...

 

[Spock's Barber]

Michael Ansara was the guy who made any production that he was in worth watching! Could play sinister at the drop of a hat and you could understand where he was coming from as Kang in the episode!
JB

My favorite Kang line...."I don't propose to spend the rest of my life on this ball of dust arguing your fantasies! THE ENTERPRISE IS MINE!"

 

[TLOZ Lover]

It was mentioned in the book yes but not in the actual film unfortunately! So I wonder if it is...canon?
JB

Sure, why not?

 

[TLOZ Lover]

Any love for Roger Carmel as Harcourt Fenton Mudd?

I love Harry Mudd!

 

[johnnybear]

My favorite Kang line...."I don't propose to spend the rest of my life on this ball of dust arguing your fantasies! THE ENTERPRISE IS MINE!"

"Only a fool fights in a burning house!" is the obvious one apart from the.."For three years The Federation and The Klingon Empire have been at peace, a treaty we have honoured to the letter!" I wonder if he's ever heard of the planet Neural or the Tellun star system?
JB

 

[TOSalltheway]

William Campbell was perfect as Trelane but horrible as Koloth.
Who can forget Joanne Linville as the Romulan Commander.

 

[Spock's Barber]

"Only a fool fights in a burning house!" is the obvious one apart from the.."For three years The Federation and The Klingon Empire have been at peace, a treaty we have honoured to the letter!" I wonder if he's ever heard of the planet Neural or the Tellun star system?
JB

...or when Kang tries the friendly approach with Kirk and his gang : "I will torture you....to death..."

 

[Kor]

John Colicos, of course.

Kor

 

[stoneroses]

Joan Collins and William Windom.

 

[sbk1234]

Mark Lenard as the Romulan Commander. He was fantastic as Sarek, of course, but the Romulan Commander had such depth, especially for the villain of the week.

 

[DS9ers]

1) Mark Lenard was perfect as both the Romulan Commander and Sarek.
2) I really enjoyed both performances by Diana Muldaur as Dr. Anne Mulhall and Dr. Miranda Jones.
3) I also enjoyed William Campbell a lot as Trelane and not so much as Koloth (well TOS, but I liked him in Blood Oath)

 

[Commishsleer]

Mark Lenard - showed why Spock turned out as he did
Joan Collins - wow

 

[johnnybear]

...or when Kang tries the friendly approach with Kirk and his gang : "I will torture you....to death..."

Apart from the fact that he didn't intend to argue your fantasies and The Enterprise was his, he did it so professionally I thought!
JB

 

[johnnybear]

I wonder if Kang took the layouts and specifications of The Enterprise back with him to The Klingon homeworld? Or was he an honourable Warrior who had finally seen the light? Probably not but hey...
JB

 

[RColtrane]

Do I really have to answer this?

 

[johnnybear]

You like an actor who played Rick Graves and Michael Tressider I think you're trying to tell us, RC! And also I do believe he acted as a certain Commodore someone or another?
JB

 

[Nerys Myk]

"Only a fool fights in a burning house!" is the obvious one apart from the.."For three years The Federation and The Klingon Empire have been at peace, a treaty we have honoured to the letter!" I wonder if he's ever heard of the planet Neural or the Tellun star system?
JB

That's just Federation spin and propaganda.

 

[johnnybear]

But we saw those Klingon devils interfere on Capella, Neural and Elaas, Nerys!
JB