It certainly seems that way, especially once you get to the "Statement of Additional Material Facts" proposed by the defense. So let's talk about some of those now.
1. Axanar states, "The Vulcan Scene features an original plot never before used in Plaintiffs' Works." C/P disputes this:
2. Axanar states that Prelude "features an original 'mockumentary' style never used before by Plaintiffs." C/P says this is "disputed and irrelevant":
3. There are a bunch of attempts by LFIM to claim other "inspirations" for his story outside of Star Trek. For example, he claimed he "modeled his performance of Garth of Izar after the veterans depicted in 'Band of Brothers,'" the HBO war documentary mini-series. He also claims Axanar was "inspired" by an episode of MASH called "The Interview," that was "shot like newsreel footage that gave an intimate look at the characters feelings on the war." C/P dismisses all of this as "irrelevant" and points out "Prelude speaks for itself."
4. There are a number of statements taken from J.J. Abrams' deposition regarding how only certain characters are "central to Star Trek." C/P objects to all of this as irrelevant, but there is one section here worth mentioning:
