Archimago, you are a genius ...I would predict a positively joyful response from Mr Paris incoming very soon haha


In any case, I like what tomalak wrote albeit I like SCORPION for partly different reasons.
(And DEADLOCK is my second fav episode so you're all right by me ...

Scorpion
Well, here we are. The Season 3 finale and the Season 4 premiere to Voyager. The episode that gave us Species 8472, really reintroduced the borg, and made an alien race more scary than the Borg.
I've mentioned this before in this thread, but I think overall, Scorpion is my favorite episode of Voyager, with part 1 just beating out Part 2, but both being at the top. People always talk about Best of Both Worlds being Trek's biggest cliffhanger and having that OMG moment at the end with Riker telling Mr. Worf to Fire on Picard. Well, the problem I've always had with that episode is when I rewatch it, it's still a damn great finale, but it's a little overrated and the reason for that is we know Picard is going to survive. Now I watch that episode for the Riker moments, the music, and because it is such a big show, but the Cliffhanger has lost something over the years.
I compare that episode with Scorpion because I think I find Scorpion much more rewatchable. I mean take a look at part 1 first of all. If there was ever a reason for Voyager on blu ray, Scorpion I is it. This was just as CGI was starting to gain prominence, and what we got in this episode is still mind blowing today. We get 15 borg ships flying almost through Voyager, we get a truely alien race in 8472, and a scary one at that, we get the bioships which look so cool, and then the cliffhanger is the ultimate oh my god moment: Janeway has made an allience with the Borg and the Bioships combined their resources and destroyed an entire planet, in one of the best looking Visual Effect shots the Franchise has ever seen. I was too young to remember Best of Both Worlds, but I remember the Scorpion two parter, and I was counting down the days to Part 2. I remember that Wednesday night of the Season premiere and couldn't wait, and when it started I was instantly glued to the set.
Part 2 is a little bit below part 1, but it still has some awesome moments. For one, I loved the look of fluidic space. You had this blurry shot and the bioships flying through it was some nicely done work. I would love to know how this did this episode, with CGI in it's infancy still. That space looked really convincing. We also got a nice shot of the borg being sucked out of the ship, which was a precurser to Enterprise I think.
These episodes also provided some great character moments. I made a mention about the "Road to Scorpion" because these episodes had many callbacks to before. We had that scene with Janeway and Chakotay in the ready room, somewhat calling back to any other Janeway and Chakotay moment (Namely resolutions). We had Chakotay being linked to 7 of 9, calling back to Unity. And then there was Kes, who's telepathic powers have really grown and escalated with Species 8472's arrival. Her communication with them was eerie and really spoke to how scary 8472 were. Everytime I see these episodes though, I really wonder about Janeway's decision to make the alliance and if it was the right one. Hindsight is 20/20 of course, but 8472 did attack first when they almost killed Harry. Also, how was Voyager to know first hand that the Borg had started the War. Maybe this was a Prime Directive issue, but what should they have done, added 6 months to the journey? Also, when they tried to communicate with 8472, they said they wanted the weak to parish. It seemed like In the Flesh and Hope and Fear kind of retconned these great aliens, which is a bit of a shame. Would have loved to spend more time with them.
We also had the music of Scorpion and I have to ask, why isn't there a soundtrack to this episode yet. I really hope to see LaLa Land records at Star Trek Las Vegas and maybe buy the Voyager score that should be coming out because the music really made these two episodes movie quality. Heck, I wouldn't mind if these two episodes were stitched together a la Best of Both Worlds on Blu Ray and made a 90 minute movie. I love the main theme (What you hear on the Season 4 DVD sets), and just the action music was some of the best music of the McCarthy/Chattaway/Berman era. It's a shame Voyager got treated badly in terms of the music because there really should be a soundtrack to Scorpion out already.
I know I'm rambling and this is probably the longest review I've given, but I do think this is Trek at it's very best. We have action, great visual effects, great character moments, the introduction to 7 of 9, (Who I will talk more about after I see The Gift), and just two really great episodes. This might have been Voyager at it's very best and yes, I do think these two episodes on the whole are better than Best of Both Worlds.
I agree with everything - still SCORPION is partly different in my book. I can see you attribute a lot of importance to CGI - that doesn't really matter so much for me. It's nice to have this kind of thing occasionally but for me this is not particularly important and it's definitely not important in the case of Voyager, the essence of which for me is the family feeling - a sense of belonging - and not how it's done technically/technologically. But it's good to know that SCORPION has succeeded in this respect as well.
Voyager is the big borg show and although we've had hints at this in previous episodes, this arc actually starts here. We've only seen a dead borg drone in BLOOD FEVER and the characters of UNITY had long ceased to be borg any more and had become ex-drones. Which means that the "real" borg story only starts with SCORPION and then stays with us for the rest of the show. For me, the borg are the second best villain in the world of Star Trek (Voyager), perceded only by the Hirogen (love those guys

To me, none of this is true. First off, the borg are so interesting I could have watched twice as many borg episodes on Voyager as we got. Second, I think those stories are hugely entertaining and it's easy to find explanations for the changes, such as the fact that Seven knows the Collective a lot more than anyone else or that it was the producers intention to get us acquainted with the borg in more detail because the knowledge Star Fleet in the Alpha Quadrant had of the borg was sporadic and by far not as in-depth as when you get to their heart in their very home in the DQ. Third, I've never felt they are not scary enough. Any time our characters have set foot on a borg ship, I've always enjoyed every second of it but at the same time I've also feared for their safety. To me, the borg reamined exciting and frightening throughout the show.
SCORPION is my favourite episode for a number of reasons. This episode is about the borg - in great detail. It's also about their biggest enemy, who turns out to be the Milky Way Galaxy's biggest enemy, too. The viewer is transported into the heart of their conflict and is immediately hooked. Species 8472 turns out to be even more dangerous than the borg - surprising, isn't it? You'd've thought that by now you've encountered the most dangerous villain but now you learn you haven't. Then their conflict gets more complicated partly because Voyager is added to the equation. That changes everything: who presents the biggest danger and how to beat them? To answer that question, Janeway finds herself in a predicament. She has to take someone's side. She can't see the solution at first but later, it presents itself. With the help of Leonardo da Vinci, my fav holographic simulation on Voyager. His intervention is not direct - it's only a few shadows created by Leonardo that give Janeway an idea. Then Janeway finds herself at odds with Chakotay. Then she ends up on a borg cube. Enter Seven of Nine. Who would have guessed at that point that she'd become a regular?
The list goes on and on. But really, to me the best thing about this episode is that Kes is still with them and Seven is already with them. The idea of having 10 main characters on Voyager is tempting. It sounds like a dream. It is a shame I have to wake up from that dream in the next episode.
Some of the most memorable moments for me are shown in the following desktop wallpapers:





