• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

CBS/Paramount sues to stop Axanar

Status
Not open for further replies.
Two things can be true at the same time: there aren't enough Axanar fans to do any real damage to the box office of the new film -and- Abrams can be concerned about the negativity from being perceived as going after fans productions.
This. JJ and Justin are worried about the way "CBS SUES THE FANS!" could play with the wider fanbase.
 
I just wonder if this could backfire if peters gets a big ego and goes from thinking he's behind the eight ball to thinking he's in control of settlement talks now that he has the approval of jj.

'So CBS here is what I'm going to do. I won't use the word start trek at all on anything but I'm keeping rights to the axanar brand and can release anything I want under that brand as long as I don't call it Star Trek. You can claim a win that I won;t make anymore Star Trek items. If you don't agree I'm going to jj because he said this lawsuit much go awsy'
 
This idea that fans have the power to bend the Hollywood executives who control Star Trek to their will is something that's baked into Star Trek fandom, all because of that one successful letter-writing campaign in 1968 that brought the show back for a third season....
That's the legend. The reality, according to Herb Solow & Justman's book, is somewhat different.
 
What settlement talks? I thought JJ said the law suit was dropped by CBS?

Abrams said that

"A few months back there was a fan film, Axanar, that was getting made and there was this lawsuit that happened between the studio and these fans and [Star Trek Beyond director Justin Lin], I'll tell the story because he probably wouldn't, was sort of outraged by this as a long time fan. We started talking about it and realized this was not an appropriate way to deal with the fans,.

"The fans should be celebrating this thing. Fans of Star Trek are part of this world. So he went to the studio and pushed them to stop this lawsuit and now, within the next few weeks, it will be announced this is going away, and that fans would be able to continue working on their project."

The only response or comment that Paramount has offered to this statement thus far is:

"We are pleased to confirm we are in settlement discussions."

13263864_10154884351402729_3331542648334386127_n[1].jpg
 
Last edited:
I just wonder if this could backfire if peters gets a big ego and goes from thinking he's behind the eight ball to thinking he's in control of settlement talks now that he has the approval of jj.

'So CBS here is what I'm going to do. I won't use the word start trek at all on anything but I'm keeping rights to the axanar brand and can release anything I want under that brand as long as I don't call it Star Trek. You can claim a win that I won;t make anymore Star Trek items. If you don't agree I'm going to jj because he said this lawsuit much go awsy'

"That's outrageous. Call us when you are willing to negotiate close to our terms, or don't waste our time. If we don't hear from you, we are ready for discovery."
 
Are sure sure that ranaxA doesn't get to do their thing this one last time while everyone else has to toe the line?

JJ said the "fans would be able to continue their project" (meaning Axanar). I doubt he said that thinking that Axanar would wind up being constrained to a 5 minute short. Even Prelude was longer than that. So either the pending rules will not put time-limit constraints on or Axanar will be grandfathered in. I suspect the former.
 
JJ said the "fans would be able to continue their project" (meaning Axanar). I doubt he said that thinking that Axanar would wind up being constrained to a 5 minute short. Even Prelude was longer than that. So either the pending rules will not put time-limit constraints on or Axanar will be grandfathered in. I suspect the former.
Why isn't there a "Shakes my head sadly" button? :shrug:
 
JJ said the "fans would be able to continue their project" (meaning Axanar). I doubt he said that thinking that Axanar would wind up being constrained to a 5 minute short. Even Prelude was longer than that. So either the pending rules will not put time-limit constraints on or Axanar will be grandfathered in. I suspect the former.
Chuckle. Or it could be that JJ was shooting off at the mouth and no one knows what the end result will be....
 
Only said it was going away in a few weeks.

If they wanted to drop it they could have already done that today. That is not normally a long process.

Ok, cool. I never specifically heard that they're settling out of court. but given the statements, that's apparently what's going on.
 
I just wonder if this could backfire if peters gets a big ego and goes from thinking he's behind the eight ball to thinking he's in control of settlement talks now that he has the approval of jj.'

I'll hazard a guess that the license CBS will grant to fan films puts a ban on crowdfunding. That alone will piss off a vast swath of the fan community, both current donors and those who have dreams of making their own films that way. If there are run-time restrictions or content restrictions, Alec won't be seen as the savior of fan films, but the slayer of them.
 
I'll hazard a guess that the license CBS will grant to fan films puts a ban on crowdfunding. That alone will piss off a vast swath of the fan community, both current donors and those who have dreams of making their own films that way. If there are run-time restrictions or content restrictions, Alec won't be seen as the savior of fan films, but the slayer of them.

Yep. By pushing the limits of fan films he's likely going to make life much more difficult for them but as long as he makes his film, get praised for it, and keeps his studio I don't think he cares.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top