• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

CBS/Paramount sues to stop Axanar

Status
Not open for further replies.
Everything I've read of the man leads me to believe Roddenberry would've sued the piss out of Alec Peters over Axanar.
 
Everything I've read of the man leads me to believe Roddenberry would've sued the piss out of Alec Peters over Axanar.

Likely, yes. Let's be honest, for whatever his public image (and I'm not commenting as to his personal life, cause I don't know that side), everything about him from people that's had business dealings with Gene point to never getting between him and a dollar when it came to making money on Star Trek.
 
Balrog said:
I never gave them a dime, but liked what they did with the 20 min prelude video. But this was exactly when I bailed. It was a "bait and switch" on the donors. And worse still, using donated funds to create a new business that would profit THEM. Be damned CBS/Paramount's beef, the donors should have been up in arms at that point.

Exactly. Bait and switch is an apropos description.
 
Everything I've read of the man leads me to believe Roddenberry would've sued the piss out of Alec Peters over Axanar.

Likely, yes. Let's be honest, for whatever his public image (and I'm not commenting as to his personal life, cause I don't know that side), everything about him from people that's had business dealings with Gene point to never getting between him and a dollar when it came to making money on Star Trek.

Yes, he would of sued Alac & Co, day 1, long before it got to the point where it is now.
 
Don't know if this was shared here yet - http://1701news.com/node/980/axanar-will-ruin-fan-trek-everyone.html

Is anyone else seeing Legal Zoom ads in the sidebar? Kinda amusing.

No i see Ikea ads as I have been on their site today... I assume at some point you must have Googled some legal information maybe?

Its a random ad display based on your google searches over 24 hours. For me, it displays nipple piercing cleansers and airline tickets to North Korea
 
Question for the fan-film producers in here:

If you were willing to work with AP before, does all this make you less likely to work with him in the future, or are you willing to cut him a break because of what he could bring to your project?

I'd never have worked with him in the first place. He had no track-record in filmmaking, and his hubris, bad temper and knee-jerky reactions put him on my "steer clear of" list a long time ago.

You think Paramount is gonna get people working on Star Trek Beyond for freebies?

At the same time, it's not true that Hollywood happily pays everyone what they're worth. VFX houses in particular have seriously gotten the shaft (Rhythm & Hughes situation anyone?) And Hollywood is notorious for its creative accounting that cheats people out of their contractual royalty cuts. And as for unions, well, think of how much work winds up moving to non-Union locations these days. Seems like more the norm than the exception, and it's been tilting that way at least since the early 90s (X-Files in Canada was kind of a trendsetter, and one of the major locations of ST: Beyond)
I never implied any of that. I simply said Paramount doesn't expect work for "freebies".

So let's not go overboard on presenting the TV/Film industry as a paragon of virtuous business practices.
There was nothing "overboard" about my very simple statement.
 
Last edited:
Yeah I don't think I'd be comfortable working with Peters in any field - film or otherwise -after this debacle.

Meanwhile...

534_10102580713441527_1529719277420692046_n.jpg


Nice to see Change.org being used for such noble purposes. :lol:
 
Let's just settle down folks, remember who the real bad guy is in all this.
Let's not go attacking one another here.
 
Yeah I don't think I'd be comfortable working with Peters in any field - film or otherwise -after this debacle.

Meanwhile...

534_10102580713441527_1529719277420692046_n.jpg

I wonder if these people would be okay with folks coming into their house and squatting for free, if they had enough signatures?
 
The thing I've found most humorous about this is on the one hand, the producers call Axanar a "ground-breaking independent Star Trek film," then say on the other hand, Peters says, "We're doing what other fan films have done for thirty years."

I wonder what the average donation to this project was? The price of a movie ticket, perhaps?

Probably most if not all prior fan films that were derivative of "Star Trek" were at least technically copyright infringements, but just not worth pursuing because they did no real damage. At first, Axanar may not have even seemed like a big deal.

But I don't blame CBS for drawing the line here. The availability of crowdsourcing, relatively affordable high-quality FX production equipment, and more ways than even ten or fifteen years ago for mass viewings of the product does at least threaten the integrity of the original product (and not just Trek, but all franchises where fan films are made). After Axanar, whose to say someone won't come up with a $3 million professional production values "fan film" for "Star Trek" or whatever?
 
The thing I've found most humorous about this is on the one hand, the producers call Axanar a "ground-breaking independent Star Trek film," then say on the other hand, Peters says, "We're doing what other fan films have done for thirty years."

It's the New Shimmer of fanfilms! (link)

I wonder what the average donation to this project was? The price of a movie ticket, perhaps?

Kickstarter stats:
Backers: 8547
Average Pledge Per Backer: $75 <—

Funded: $638,446 of $100,000
Dates: Jul 25th -> Aug 24th (30 days)
Project By: Axanar Productions
 
The thing I've found most humorous about this is on the one hand, the producers call Axanar a "ground-breaking independent Star Trek film," then say on the other hand, Peters says, "We're doing what other fan films have done for thirty years."

Such extreme and egregious cognitive dissonance is the only language Peters understands. That, and bloviating.


But I don't blame CBS for drawing the line here. The availability of crowdsourcing, relatively affordable high-quality FX production equipment, and more ways than even ten or fifteen years ago for mass viewings of the product does at least threaten the integrity of the original product (and not just Trek, but all franchises where fan films are made). After Axanar, whose to say someone won't come up with a $3 million professional production values "fan film" for "Star Trek" or whatever?

Crowdsourcing is a big part of it, yes. I remember some people being strongly opposed and disappointed with entities like Warner Bros. and people like Zach Braff using it to fund their pet projects (Veronica Mars, Wish I Was Here) when there were plenty of by-the-book, standard procedure ways of either getting the films made or not, and that doing so via crowdsourcing would diminish the ability of other, upstart filmmakers who could really use the help and exposure.

Clearly, those projects as well as Axanar (and New Voyages and Continues, the two other biggest fundraisers in fan film community) are having that same effect. I would not be surprised at all to find CBS/Paramount trying to include Kickstarter and Indiegogo as part of their complaint with the lawsuit for not abiding their own "Don't use our service to make money off other people's IP" rules.
 
How about we launch a kickstarter for some beer, food and hookers...

Erm.............

I mean to help us film a fan movie about the early days of Trek BBS?
 
I'm wondering... MST3K raised a ton of money though Kickstarter ( run by the shows creator )

Did Alac see that success & get it in his head to do the same ?

Wouldn't put it past him to think they got millions & millions, I can do that too.

MST3K broke the record for largest crowd funding ever in Kickstarter history.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top