• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

MLP:FIM S5E21 - "Scare Master" - Grading & Discussion

Episode Grade

  • B

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • C

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • D

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • F

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    5
  • Poll closed .
A

Amaris

Guest
Episode Title: "Scare Master"
Air Date: October 31st, 2015, 11:30 AM Eastern Time (3:30 PM GMT/UTC)

Summary: " Fluttershy decides to face her fears and take part in Nightmare Night with her friends."

Live Streams:
HaxMega
BronyState Theaters
Brony Network
Equestria TV
Otaku Ascended

REMEMBER: NO OPEN SPOILERS UNTIL 3 PM ET (7 PM GMT)

=-

Ruminations:
This episode was the one leaked a while back, so I'm sure many have seen it. Since I have not, and I'm sure others have also remained unspoiled, please do not post any open spoilers until after the episode airs, and only after the time listed above. This gives everyone time to see it. That said, I look forward to Fluttershy's Nightmare Night bravery, and I hope the fun will be doubled!
 
I downloaded the HD copy at the time, but I've managed not to watch it and I'll probably just be in the live stream with everyone else anyway. :lol:
 
I managed to wait until this morning to watch as well. It's my reward after being up until almost midnight carving pumpkins and baking. After it's over, I'm fixing a birthday cake! :)
 
Glad I waited to see it, it's a cute holiday episode. They did a great job with the costumes and background art.
 
**SPOILERS**
Since it's after 3 PM EST, spoilers do not have to be behind tags. So be warned!

If you haven't seen the episode yet...


Id_Turn_Back_If_IWere_You_Oz.png



For the rest of you, onward!

What a fun little episode! Very slice of life, and filled with that Nightmare Night atmosphere we love so much. Fluttershy was pure adorable in this episode, as I think we knew she would be, plus I can't be the only one who always wants to squeeze the stuffing out of her every time I see her. Also, did anyone else also feel that the cubby hole Fluttershy was staying in on Nightmare Night was rather appealing? I couldn't be the only one who found it cozy.

The costumes for the Mane Six and Spike were great. I was giggling just watching Rarity's mermaid tail slap the *yay* out of Flutters every couple of seconds. Spike's two headed dragon was cool, Applejack's cowardly lion was too cute for words, Rainbow Dash's astronaut was awesome (of course), Twilight's royal guard uniform was seriously ho-, uh, really cute *ahem*, and Pinkie Pie's roller girl was out-of-the-box and wonderful, just like herself.

The little games were cute, the candy bags were adorable! We also now know that Fluttershy loves fruit flavored taffies. Letting Flutters try to scare everypony was brilliant, and I think the attempt showed us far more about Fluttershy's own insecurities than anything else. For our other Five (and Spike), it was just a minor inconvenience, but for Fluttershy it was truly scary. I like that we get to see this insight into her psyche.

So we get to the corn maze, and it just looked like so much fun. Granny's way too real horsehead, Big Mac's very obviously Big Mac mummy (lol), all of it made for the perfect seasoning. To be honest, the scene that did make me go "Eek!" was the fake Granny Smith skeleton. That was actually creepy to me, and Applejack's reaction would have been my own!

Of course, then there's Flutterbat, whom I find utterly precious. They show her hear in costume as a fruit bat, but I'm curious as to whether or not she still has those former traits. Oh well, either way, she was too cute for words, as well. Still, she did a great job scaring the ponies (it would have scared me!), and we get to see that special deviousness from Angel Bunny, who uses his powers for good this time around.

I also like that Fluttershy, having seen her friends scared, couldn't live with the idea that she caused it, and so graciously bowed out. I like that her friends didn't pressure her into doing it with so many reservations. That's how good friends work.

All in all, this is one of those Halloween episodes they need to show on regular TV every year as a special, just like they do "It's The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown." Seriously, it's that good. Wow, for a slice of life episode, I had a lot to say! I think I just love these types of episodes, and hope for many more of them next season (since we're coming up on the last few closing out this season).

This episode gets an "A" from me, and makes me want to say "Nightmare Night, what a fright! Give me something good to bite!"
 
This one was a one off just for the fun of the holiday and it was adorable. Big Mac wasn't scaring anyone but I love how the CMC at least got into it and screamed anyway kind of following on Luna Eclipsed's lesson.

RD was a little iffy this episode, she can really be one way or the other about Fluttershy and it's annoying when she gets this impatient with her.

The goodie bags were cute and Fluttershy's original attempt to scare them all was sweet, not scary but you know.

Flutterbat was a nice touch, even briefly.

But I think we all know what the real lesson of this episode is. Fluttershy should have cooked Angel years ago.
 
I totally digged Fluttershy's original attempt at scaring the others with social anxieties. It would have worked on me! ;)

One other thing I also found very funny was that everypony relaxed after the Star Trek salt monster was revealed to be Fluttershy's bear friend. Uh, he's still a big, dangerous bear.

I think I like the first Nightmare Night episiode still the best but this was pretty good.

Apologies if this was discussed last week but why did we get the Halloween episode today but the Christmas episode last week? Shouldn't last week's episode have come after this one?
 
Apologies if this was discussed last week but why did we get the Halloween episode today but the Christmas episode last week? Shouldn't last week's episode have come after this one?

This was originally episode 16, which is why the episode "leaked" early. As the digital files sent to the distribution sites still had the 16 tag on them, some mix up at Hasbro or Shout.

So we should have had this one about the same amount of time before Hearthbreakers as Luna Eclipsed was before Hearthswarming Eve.

I listened to the Friendship Games commentary today finally and the entire time they had to not comment on Twilight not responding to Sunset because of the season 5 finale not airing, which you could tell was not going down well with them.

It looks like when season 5 started, there was to be no hiatus, the whole thing over before FG and the holiday episodes over with over the summer.

So, it's all out of order and priority now.
 
This one was a one off just for the fun of the holiday and it was adorable. Big Mac wasn't scaring anyone but I love how the CMC at least got into it and screamed anyway kind of following on Luna Eclipsed's lesson.

RD was a little iffy this episode, she can really be one way or the other about Fluttershy and it's annoying when she gets this impatient with her.

The goodie bags were cute and Fluttershy's original attempt to scare them all was sweet, not scary but you know.

Flutterbat was a nice touch, even briefly.

Yeah, Dashie was a bit cold and callous this episode, though it's still in line with who she is. I did laugh when she got pinged with a piece of candy after one particularly insensitive remark. :lol:

When it came to the spooky tea party, I couldn't help but giggle because Fluttershy's idea of scary is still adorable.

But I think we all know what the real lesson of this episode is. Fluttershy should have cooked Angel years ago.
Amen. :lol:
 
Rainbow still doesn't think at times, and yet I still love her.

This episode was wonderful and it was also fun that it aired right after Luna Eclipsed. I also loved the anime references when Fluttershy attempted her spooky tea party... Revolutionary Pony Utena! That was an A right there!
 
Nice fun episode. Angel continues to be a jerk. The Derpy sighting made me giggle for about five minutes...
 
Rainbow still doesn't think at times, and yet I still love her.

This episode was wonderful and it was also fun that it aired right after Luna Eclipsed. I also loved the anime references when Fluttershy attempted her spooky tea party... Revolutionary Pony Utena! That was an A right there!

I only recognized one or two of the anime characters, but I knew that fans everywhere were all over the rest. :lol:

Nice fun episode. Angel continues to be a jerk. The Derpy sighting made me giggle for about five minutes...

Once I went back and saw it, I started laughing. I wonder how I missed that?!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top