• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

MeTV's SuperSci-Fi Saturday Night

"The Deadly Rock"

So we get to see natural Kryptonite, I presume...

But it's still not green.


but it makes Clark's friend invulnerable even while it weakens him?

Interesting that they seem to be calling back to the events of "Panic in the Sky", though they're sort of retconning Kryptonite into that asteroid when it wasn't specifically mentioned in that episode.

Well, it's by the same writer, Jackson Gillis. So he's calling back his own episode, but changing the details -- which is about as much continuity as you'd be likely to get in the fifties. I suppose it's not entirely incompatible, since Superman's memory loss in "Panic" could perhaps be attributed to kryptonite exposure.

Still, this was the first real misfire from the normally reliable Gillis. It's totally random that Clark's friend happens to be the one human who's affected by kryptonite, without any explanation for why, and it's even more random that the same radiation that takes away Superman's powers somehow gives them to this guy even though it weakens them both the same way. It just doesn't make any sense. Plus the ethnic-caricature professor was the most annoying goofy scientist they've had on this show yet, and that's saying something.
 
But it's still not green.
Honestly, the color quality is so crappy in these episodes (Clark's suit shifting from grey to greenish-yellow) that it's hard to tell.

Also, I understand that standard Kryptonite was actually colored red in its first appearance in the comics in the late 40s, so it's possible that the exact color hadn't set in enough yet that they felt the need to make it consistent across various media. Was it specifically described as being green on the radio?

Plus the ethnic-caricature professor was the most annoying goofy scientist they've had on this show yet, and that's saying something.
Worse than even the professor with the speech impediment, worse than even?
 
Also, I understand that standard Kryptonite was actually colored red in its first appearance in the comics in the late 40s, so it's possible that the exact color hadn't set in enough yet that they felt the need to make it consistent across various media. Was it specifically described as being green on the radio?

Yes, it was. The first kryptonite story is almost entirely missing, but it is described as a "green, glowing meteor" in the September 25, 1945 episode. The initial comics appearance you're referring to, in which it was red, wasn't until late 1949; and it was white when Luthor first used it in 1950's Action Comics #141 -- but it was green in #142. It was a little inconsistent for a while after that, but it seemed to be locked in as green by the end of 1951. The first overt mention of red kryptonite as something unusual, because kryptonite is normally green, is in 1958. (http://goodcomics.comicbookresource...et-the-evolution-of-green-and-red-kryptonite/)


Plus the ethnic-caricature professor was the most annoying goofy scientist they've had on this show yet, and that's saying something.
Worse than even the professor with the speech impediment, worse than even?

To me, yes. At least that guy wasn't an ethnic caricature. And he was annoying in a much blander way.
 
"The Phantom Ring"

Jimmy: "It's a bird!" (wink wink, nudge nudge)

If Superman saw a lead panel concealing the instruments, why didn't he just bust it open? Somebody must have been of the school of thought that lead just made things invisible to him, despite the fact that the show has previously contradicted that idea.

There's Paul Burke again...this time a partner in crime of Not Perry White's Nephew.


*******

"The Jolly Roger"

Can't let that island set and those khakis from the other episode go to waste...!

I do believe that this was the very first episode of the series that I watched, when they finally started playing it on a station that I got ca. '79. I almost thought it was that other episode because of the similar set and costumes, but remembered there being pirates and a naval bombardment involved.

"...and Lieutenant Schultz!"
"I know nothink!"

Generations of pirates on that island...with no children currently evident, and all of the women youthful, pretty, and mute....

And there's Clark letting Lois and Jimmy get a good, long look at his face again. I'd love to know what the show-makers were thinking when they put in all these scenes of him without his glasses.

Wait, did Superman actually deliver the picture to the Navy and I missed it?
 
Wait, did Superman actually deliver the picture to the Navy and I missed it?
Not that I saw. He was on his way to the ships with it when they opened fire.
He just blew the shells up in mid air and made them give up thinking something was wrong with the artillery.
 
"The Phantom Ring"

Nice to see bad guys with an actual superpower, and even a main villain using a supervillain nickname, the Spectre. I think the latter has only happened maybe once before on this show, if that.

And I like Clark's careful honesty to Lois and Jimmy at the end -- "They tried to push me out of a plane, but fortunately Superman was there when I fell."

Another Star Trek guest star -- Peter Brocco (the Organian Claymare) as the Spectre. Actually this is his third and last appearance on the show.


If Superman saw a lead panel concealing the instruments, why didn't he just bust it open? Somebody must have been of the school of thought that lead just made things invisible to him, despite the fact that the show has previously contradicted that idea.

On the contrary, I've complained before about how both the radio and TV series treated lead as invisible to Superman rather than just black. Like that one where Lois, Jimmy, and Uncle Oscar were trapped in a lead-lined room and Superman couldn't even see that the room existed.


"The Jolly Roger"

Can't let that island set and those khakis from the other episode go to waste...!

This one was a bit too silly for my tastes.


Generations of pirates on that island...with no children currently evident, and all of the women youthful, pretty, and mute....

Well, one of the women had a line, but yeah... there are some not very kid-friendly implications when you think about how they must've propagated themselves. Those girls were too young to be their wives; were they captured as breeding stock?
 
Season 5 of Superman begins now, and apparently they've dropped on-screen episode titles.

"Peril in Paris" was fairly good, aside from the silly opening scene with Robert Shayne playing a Henderson-lookalike cop in Paris -- obviously a contrivance to save money on guest casting, like having Perry suddenly become a scientist a few episodes back. The bit where Superman thought he'd been tricked into committing a crime was effectively dramatic, although it kind of belies his earlier statement that he intended to investigate the background of Anna's claims. Of course, she was telling the truth, but Superman seemed rather easily duped by the fake gendarmes, suggesting he didn't really do much more than take people at their word.

The rest wasn't as effective, but giving the bad guys French accents gave a certain elegance to the proceedings. And the story did have a fair number of twists and surprises -- though I think one was cut out, since the guy who was initially with Anna seemed to have switched sides to the bad guys by the time Jimmy got there.

Anyway, I see they've started animating the bullets bouncing off Superman's chest now.


"Tin Hero" was pretty dumb. Perry White berates Jimmy for not being a good reporter by bringing the guy in to tell his story, but then when the guy does tell his story, Perry just hires him on the spot without bothering to verify any of his claims as any competent reporter would do. What if he'd been lying about having a psychic "nose for news" or whatever? Of course, the episode assumed he did, but Perry couldn't have known that.

And then the characters' behavior is contradictory. First Clark is saying that Frank just stumbled into success and could endanger himself by buying into his own hype, but then, both as Clark and Superman, he actively encourages Frank's delusions by convincing him he saved the day on his own. And Perry is there when Clark convinces him that Frank just got lucky, but by the finale, Perry still believes Frank is some master reporter he can't bear to lose. It just doesn't add up.
 
"Peril in Paris" was fairly good, aside from the silly opening scene with Robert Shayne playing a Henderson-lookalike cop in Paris
Interesting how they make such a big deal about Henderson's lookalike, but nobody ever comments about Clark's resemblance to Superman, even when they see him with his glasses off....

Superman seemed rather easily duped by the fake gendarmes
You'd think he'd at least want to accompany them to the police station, rather than being cowed into moping in the park.

And Clark assumes that they'd be in the jail at the station where Not Henderson is...as if a city the size of Paris wouldn't have more than one police station.

Add to this episode's flaws...the bad guys wanted the gems, right? And this was established right after they tried to blow the girl up...while she was carrying the gems.
 
"Tin Hero"
...
Perry just hires him on the spot without bothering to verify any of his claims as any competent reporter would do.
Yeah, Perry is far too eager to hire him and offer him a big salary. I've got some swampland outside of Gotham that I'd like to sell Perry.

To further the gun-jumping, the episode skips from a scene of Frank considering whether or not to take the job to a scene of the criminals discussing whether or not to knock off the hot new reporter. Seems like it all would have played a bit more naturally if Perry had sent the guy on an assignment to test him out and he'd come back with some seemingly spectacular results to back up the initial impression that he'd made.
 
Wonder Woman season one tonight.

I held off on this until I could get the pilot movie from Netflix. It's actually a surprisingly faithful adaptation of the first couple of Wonder Woman comics. The Paradise Island sequence follows her debut in All-Star Comics #8 quite closely, and the following stuff in the US shares the broad outlines of the story's continuation in Sensation Comics #1, right down to having Diana pose as a nurse before becoming Steve Trevor's assistant (although they wisely dropped the part about her just happening to run into a real Nurse Diana Prince who looked just like her and bribing her into letting Wonder Woman take her place).

And it's a pretty effective pilot aside from that. Lynda Carter is, let's face it, a mediocre actress, but that kinda worked for Wonder Woman's guileless and wholesome personality. And since I was seven when this show began, I don't think I ever really appreciated just how beautiful she was. She certainly has a radiant smile, and fantastic legs (though not quite as fantastic as Joanna Cameron/Isis). And whaddaya know, she really did wear satin tights!

She's also surprisingly tough in the pilot. In contrast to Jaime Sommers' preferred nonviolent uses of her bionics, Wonder Woman is shown punching people out, and she even crashes a plane into a Nazi sub and presumably kills everyone aboard it. Although that was toned down some in episode 2, where she was just shoving people around. And one thing featured prominently in both episodes so far are prolonged catfights with the villainesses. Why am I not surprised?


Interesting that in the early episodes, Wonder Woman's clothing are held in her hands after completing the magical spin, instead of disappearing as seen in later episodes.

Yeah -- I guess the original idea was that she was just stripping down so quickly that she seemed like a whirlwind, although the slow motion kind of works against that. Later they changed it to a simple fadeout and then added the big noisy flash of light that nobody ever sees or hears.


The episode was written by Margaret Armen, best known for being a prolific contributor to Star Trek, with no less than five stories (combined) for TOS and TAS.

And not that well-written, I fear. Maybe Armen was deliberately going for a stilted, comic-booky dialogue style, but it was laden with awkward "As you know, Bob" expository monologues.

This episode also features the debut of Beatrice Colen as Etta Candy, though you'd hardly know it. She's just kind of there in a couple of scenes in the back half without any prior introduction. I wonder where this episode fell in production order.

Plus we get some of the bondage that was so prominent in Marston's WW comics. Although they've changed the rules; in the comics, if Wonder Woman let herself be bound by a man, she'd lose her superstrength. Here, she was able to break free of the chains with no problem.


One thing I find rather silly in both episodes is the conceit that pinning back her hair and putting on comically oversized glasses is somehow supposed to make Lynda Carter look plain and unattractive. I mean, sure, it does hide her looks a little, but not to the extreme degree the dialogue implies. I wonder if the writers were deliberately poking fun at the conceit by exaggerating it that way. This is, after all, from one of the head writers of Batman, Stanley Ralph Ross, so it has some of the same campy flavor. I also have to wonder whether Diana's feminist statements are being presented sincerely or being poked fun at like Batman's ultra-square wholesomeness.


But that theme song is rather amazing, isn't it? It's a hell of an earworm. And I love the lyrics. They're hilariously corny, but I also kind of admire their idealism, and their outright embrace of the feminism that Marston intended to promote with Wonder Woman but that his successors on the comic did their best to downplay.
 
"The Town That Wasn't"

How do you get utilities and such in a mobile town like that? Would have been nice to see something of that end of the operation instead of just being expected to take it at face value while the actual moving got done between scenes.

And what were the crooks planning to do with all of their prisoners in the long run, anyway...?


*******

"Tomb of Zaharan"

Lois was 26 in 1956. Noel Neill was 26 in 1946. Is everybody in this show playing 10 years younger?

Jimmy's mother is like the Jenny Piccalo of this show...or Aunt Petunia in FF comics. (Both were eventually revealed, of course.)
 
"The Town That Wasn't"

This was pretty mediocre. Superman vs. the small-town speed trap? Not to mention the contrivance that, out of all the highways in the country, both Lois and Jimmy just happened across this same scam.


How do you get utilities and such in a mobile town like that? Would have been nice to see something of that end of the operation instead of just being expected to take it at face value while the actual moving got done between scenes.

I was wondering why a town with just four buildings (as Jimmy said) had three cells in its jail. Sure, I can see the bad guys needing to lock someone up, but keeping them for any length of time would be a liability if they needed to move. And what about that first truck driver? He'd evidently been their prisoner since the start of the episode, so logically they moved the town while he was in their custody, yet he knew nothing about it. Did they do it while he was asleep, maybe giving him a sedative?

Also, when Jimmy was telling Clark and Henderson that they were exactly where the town had just been, there was clearly tall grass in the field behind them, where the buildings would've presumably been just a couple of days before. Not the best job of location scouting.



"Tomb of Zaharan"

Lois was 26 in 1956. Noel Neill was 26 in 1946. Is everybody in this show playing 10 years younger?

I was struck by that myself. No way she could pass for 26. She did look kinda nice in that diaphanous outfit, though.

I could've done without the constant tendency of American TV writers in earlier generations to lump all Eastern cultures together. These guys were some weird hodgepodge of ancient and modern Middle Eastern cultures, with turbans and fezzes and Turkish or Arabic-style names but worshipping an Egyptian-style deity. All kind of ridiculous, really. And of course they were white actors pretending to be Middle Eastern, but that kind of goes without saying in that era. (One of them was apparently Jack Kruschen, whom we recently saw as Eivol Ekdal in Batman's "Zelda the Great" 2-parter.)


Jimmy's mother is like the Jenny Piccalo of this show...or Aunt Petunia in FF comics. (Both were eventually revealed, of course.)

I think we've seen her on the show at least once.
 
Not to mention the contrivance that, out of all the highways in the country, both Lois and Jimmy just happened across this same scam.
Because the bad guys were perpetrating two scams...Jimmy got caught in the speed trap, Lois went looking for the missing trucks.

Also, when Jimmy was telling Clark and Henderson that they were exactly where the town had just been, there was clearly tall grass in the field behind them, where the buildings would've presumably been just a couple of days before. Not the best job of location scouting.
And in-story, you'd think the buildings would have left more of an imprint in the landscape than a few nails lying around...especially when one of the people looking is Clark.
 
Because the bad guys were perpetrating two scams...Jimmy got caught in the speed trap, Lois went looking for the missing trucks.

Which is exactly why it's such an unlikely coincidence. Jimmy just happened to be coming back from his vacation, and Lois was randomly wandering the highways looking for a needle in a haystack. It's unlikely enough that she stumbled upon the bad guys at all, out of all the small towns in all the highways in the country. It's unlikely squared that Jimmy had also randomly encountered them just days before.
 
Man, this show is on the decline lately. It's lost its best writer, Jackson Gillis, and the other writers aren't doing so well either. I don't think I've liked any of this season's episodes so far.

"The Man Who Made Dreams Come True" was silly because it depended on the con man's mark, the king, being utterly stupid and gullible to the point of self-destruction. It doesn't make the villain very impressive when his target has to be such a complete pushover. The only points of interest were a couple of familiar faces -- Cyril Delevanti as the superstitious king and Sgt. Schultz himself, John Banner, as the king's bodyguard. And this time Schultz actually got to see and hear something.

"Disappearing Lois" wasn't much better; this time it was Lois herself whose behavior was totally ludicrous and contrived. Arranging her own mysterious disappearance and making Clark fear for her safety just so she could scoop him on a story? That's horrible! These characters have a history of trying to trick each other out of stories, but this crosses a line. And it didn't even turn out being particularly relevant to the story. It also didn't make sense that they could hide from Superman when he showed up at the hood's apartment. Surely his super-senses would've picked up their presence.

I'm unclear on whether Mort Weisinger was still involved with the show in this season. IMDb says he was still story editor despite no longer being credited, but IMDb can't always be trusted. A change in story editors could explain the drop in quality. Anyway, we've got 20 episodes to go... I wonder how many of them will be worth sitting through.
 
I have to wonder how involved Weisinger was with the show...it could be that he just ran through scripts to make sure there was nothing blatantly out-of-step with the Superman mythos.

And the show seems pretty consistent in portraying Superman's super-senses as something that he has to deliberately turn on.
 
^From what I read, Weisinger actually travelled out to Hollywood to work on the show. After all, they didn't have modern communication, so it's not like he could've consulted from DC's New York offices all that effectively. He could've talked over the phone, of course, but outlines and scripts and footage would have to be mailed, and that would've been too slow a process.
 
Last edited:
Note: tomorrow night's feature on Svengoolie, Weird Woman, is actually the first movie adaption of the novel Conjure Wife by Fritz Leiber. As I recall, it's a somewhat loose adaptation that doesn't really capture the feel of the novel, but I haven't seen it in decades so I'm curious to check it out again.
 
I'll have to record it. I'm being dragged off to see a Bon Jovi tribute band. Unless it's cancelled because of the weather (please, please, please....).
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top