• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

G Rated Episodes

For those of us that come from countries with different rating systems, could you explain what "G" means, please.

From Wikipedia page, the "G" ("General", as "suitable for everyone") rating is used in

  • Australia
  • Canada
  • Israel
  • Maldives
  • New Zealand
  • Philippines
  • Romania
  • Serbia
  • United States
 
I don't recall "The Child" dealing with rape. I'll have to review the episode.

It's sort of a Hail Deanna, Mother of God episode.
Yeah, I guess that's true, but still, she had her body invaded against her will.

I have to admit I kind of had "The Child" and "Man of the People" crossed up in my mind, though. It is the one that is more like "Fusion" in that respect.

Qualifying as rape is different than dealing with rape. While one can have an opinion that what happened was rape, it's not really accurate to say that the story deals with issues of rape as a story element. It's been a while since I've seen the episode, though, so I can't be 100% sure if the "against my will/I was violated" ever came up in dialog.
 
And "The Child" was originally a story idea or script for the aborted* Phase II project, with Ilia as the focus.

* = yeah, poor choice of words, given the context
 
It's been a while since I've seen the episode, though, so I can't be 100% sure if the "against my will/I was violated" ever came up in dialog.
I recall Deanna appearing quiet and troubled in the conference room scene, would have to review the dvd to say more.

:)
 
Looking at a transcript, the closest reference I'm seeing is the Observation Lounge scene where they're discussing the pregnancy and what to do about it.
TROI: Last night, while I slept, something which I can only describe as a presence, entered my body.
Later in the scene, she announces she's going to have the baby.

If there's any allusion to rape, it must be after Ian makes his entrance, I didn't look past where Picard meets him.
 
(Memory Alpha says "Carpenter Street" was the first episode of any Trek series to get a TV-MA rating, and iTunes lists that as TV-PG as well.)

I'm seeing TV-14 from Memory Alpha, as it doesn't seem too severe to warrant an MA.

I'll admit I don't really remember that episode. What occurs that merits even a TV-14? Most Trek is pretty solidly in the TV-PG realm.
 
(Memory Alpha says "Carpenter Street" was the first episode of any Trek series to get a TV-MA rating, and iTunes lists that as TV-PG as well.)

I'm seeing TV-14 from Memory Alpha, as it doesn't seem too severe to warrant an MA.

I'll admit I don't really remember that episode. What occurs that merits even a TV-14? Most Trek is pretty solidly in the TV-PG realm.

I've found that for Trek episodes (and probably for more and more shows, that is), the line between TV-14 and TV-PG gets reevaluated when it's rerun or released in a different format (so that episode was TV-14 on broadcast, and then TV-PG on iTunes).

Memory Alpha says that the episode was originally TV-14 because it dealt with drugs and prostitution, and that seems about on par with a lot of Law & Order episodes that deal with those situations, too. But yes, most of Trek is very much in the TV-PG realm, which makes that particular episode unique in its own right. I'm hard-pressed to think of Trek episodes that would reach TV-14; perhaps a few DS9 wartime episodes, but the rating system, unless it's blatantly obvious MA material like The Walking Dead or Game of Thrones, is often arbitrary.
 
And "The Child" was originally a story idea or script for the aborted* Phase II project, with Ilia as the focus.

* = yeah, poor choice of words, given the context

On the other hand, Ilia was in the only "G" rated Star Trek movie.
 
It's been a while since I've seen the episode, though, so I can't be 100% sure if the "against my will/I was violated" ever came up in dialog.
I recall Deanna appearing quiet and troubled in the conference room scene, would have to review the dvd to say more.

:)

As are a number of women who have an unwanted or unexpected pregnancy after consensual sex.

Like I said, I can see the point of view where opinion is that Troi was raped. However, the story isn't "about" rape.
 
Hello
There is always G rated episodes in a row, has anyone seen that?


I have all of TNG, DS9, VOY and Ent on VHS, and all of TNG & DS9 on DVD. In the context of the DVDs, all of the episodes within a series conform to one "umbrella" age rating.
However the VHS versions, which are at least a decade older, give one rating to two episodes per VHS.
I am not going through them all as there are literally hundreds and I would spend all day writing this post. Consequently I shall use DS9 Season One to demonstrate.

(UK = U [Universal] > PG [Parental Guidance] > 12 > 15 > 18)

Volume 1 - Emissary - PG
Volume 2 - Past Prologue & Man Alone - PG
Volume 3 - Babel & Captive Pursuit - U
Volume 4 - Q-less & Dax - U
Volume 5 - The Passenger & Move Along Home - PG
Volume 6 - The Nagus & Vortex - U
Volume 7 - Battle lines & The Storyteller - PG
Volume 8 - Progress & If Wishes Were Horses - PG
Volume 9 - The Forsaken & Dramatis Personae - PG
Volume 10 - Duet & In The Hands of the Prophets - PG

Henceforth, with the exception of the latter volumes, the episodes do not appear to conform to any pattern or system.

On the subject of Enterprise, VHS 1.5, 1.6 & 1.7 have a rating of U, whilst the rest of season one have a PG rating. Thus 1.9 (Fusion & Rogue Planet) received a PG.

With regard to TNG "The Child", VHS Volume 14 received an age rating of PG.

On the subject of the movies, while The Motion Picture is the only one rated U, First Contact is the only one rated 12 with the following breakdown of criteria on the back:
> Language - Infrequent, Mild
> Sex/ Nudity - None
> Violence - Some, Moderate, Fantastic.

The last descriptor was not wrong, but I do not see how it relates to age censorship!
 
I remember "back in the day", The Wrath of Khan was rated 15 in the UK (before they introduced the "12" rating). How times, social-norms and what is acceptable to be viewed by minors change.
 
For those of us that come from countries with different rating systems, could you explain what "G" means, please.
I linked to the definition of TV-G, upthread:
The ratings are described here.

Forgive me if I don't blindly click on un-named links from a work computer. Or from my home computer come to that...

Yeah, there's nothing unnamed about the URL, because the full URL is right there for you to see. If you don't trust URLs in my post, why would you trust information in it either? I've given you the URL, which you can validate as an authoritative link to the information yourself. Or not....
 
I remember "back in the day", The Wrath of Khan was rated 15 in the UK (before they introduced the "12" rating). How times, social-norms and what is acceptable to be viewed by minors change.

I kind of know what you mean, the actual 12 certificate was introduced one year before I was born for cinema releases (but four years after for video releases :wtf:), however the 12A was introduced when I was twelve. The need for that rating is still beyond my comprehension to this day! :confused:
Also, TWoK is a 15 on VHS, I was being lazy not wanting to pull all of the VHS out of the cupboard........and thought I knew all of the movie ratings without having to check!! (At least now I shall remember that one forevermore!!!)
 
I remember "back in the day", The Wrath of Khan was rated 15 in the UK (before they introduced the "12" rating). How times, social-norms and what is acceptable to be viewed by minors change.

Yep. They also released a "PG" version as well, which was edited.

"Batman" in 1989 was also released as as a '15' on video, because '12' hadn't moved across to VHS-land yet.
 
For those of us that come from countries with different rating systems, could you explain what "G" means, please.
I linked to the definition of TV-G, upthread:
The ratings are described here.

Forgive me if I don't blindly click on un-named links from a work computer. Or from my home computer come to that...

http://www.tvguidelines.org/ratings.htm

Movies: http://www.mpaa.org/film-ratings/
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top