Answer to the question is Price (when paying for pitching, pretty much always buy as young as you can afford). But since they'd have to TRADE for Price, kinda eliminates the Yankees from considering him right now, doesn't it? We've been over this a few times, but Yankees aren't exactly flush with prospects or exciting young players to use as trade chips. As in, not sure they have much of any tradeable assets, and definitely not enough to land a marquis Ace.
True. So the Yankees will basically be aiming for Lester, Scherzer or Shields.
I think they have to land one of these. My prediction is Scherzer. (just rumblings I've heard)
I'd love Lester. Consistent, top notch lefty...
But that said, with all the injuries and pine-tar the Yankees dealt with on their pitching staff, their pitching wasn't the reason they didn't make the play-offs. They couldn't score runs. Hell, they scored less runs than they did in 2013 with all those season ending injuries. They got to get some pop back in the line-up.
They have a
lot of holes, though. The rotation is a patchwork mess (Sabatha is old, shitty and probably broken for good and that contract is a mess; Tanaka's arm is a ticking time bomb; God knows what they'll get out of Nova and Pineda is probably looking at a harsh regression -- his walk rate is crazy low and well out of line with his norms, and his BABIP against isn't sustainable), and beyond that there are holes at short (well, there
already was a hole at short), second, third, right, DH and arguably first (Teixeira may be toast at this point, and his contract is an albatross, too). Rodriguez's return has the potential to help out if he shows up in shape, but that depends on whether or not his hips have ground to dust at this point.
The other thing working against the Yankees (and everyone else this winter) is that this is
not a particularly deep free agent class. There's a clear top tier of pitchers with Scherzer and Lester, then a few rungs below that you have Shields, and after that it's a pile of mediocre has-beens and reclamation projects all around. On the position player side ...
ouch. No one is going to confuse guys like Hanley Ramirez or Pablo Sandoval huge stars, and they're probably the best hitters who will be on the market, along with Russell Martin (who's on the wrong side of 30 and will probably need a position change at some point).
This is not an offseason for huge spending. (Which means Rube is going to drop like 5/95 on Aramis Ramirez or something.)