Why all the 'These are the Voyages...' hate?

[TEACAKE'S PLEATHER DOME]

It was a dodgy holoprogram Riker picked up from a guy selling them out of a suitcase on the pavement of Rigel X. All the "history" was soap opery claptrap that had little to do with actual events. But Riker was only hoping to get Troi all sympathetic over him, he wanted to tell his sob story and have her help him and it would be hot. He didn't care about any ENT history lessons.

 

[Kobayshi Maru]

If they had to do an episode after this, it'd have to begin in the alternate timeline all those characters appeared to be from!

Riker and Troi leave the holodeck, return to the bridge and we find a slightly different take on The Next Generation episode "The Pegasus", complete with rewritten Picard, Data, Admiral Pressman etc. Only then do we find it's all a "butterfly effect" built up over the years, that goes as far back as the Temporal Cold War manipulation during Enterprise's era.

By the end of the episode, they've reset everything so the series goes forward from 2155 again. Plus we know Future Guy's identity, and by the time we reach the signing of the Federation charter, the Romulan War appears to have had more of an impact on the crew and a different fate for Trip.

You know what could have been funny? If future guy was actually Riker, trying to change the timeline so he could be Captain of the Enterprise instead of Picard!!!

While all he needed to do is prevent him from being stabbed in the heart!

 

[TEACAKE'S PLEATHER DOME]

That does sound like Riker's fat arrogance and also I suppose that is why Future Guy was always sitting down to keep the stick firmly wedged.

 

[LMFAOschwarz]

I'm with 2takesfrakes in that it was great to see these characters again. I'm sure that was the basic idea behind it, and I was grateful for that. But what was not good at all is why it needed to be tied into The Pegasus, or any other episode, at all? Why not just some stand-alone segment of Riker and Troi interacting? The Pegasus aspect was more distracting than anything else.

Had they done a 'generic' Riker-and-Troi-on-Enterprise D, we might now all be speculating on when it took place, rather than pointing out all the reasons it didn't work instead.

 

[T'Girl]

they wanted to do something that could be seen as a finale, but which they could also cheat their way out of somehow if the show (by some miracle) had managed to actually get itself belatedly picked up for a fifth season

If that were the case (and it's an interesting idea Lance), then they should have done it like with TOS and TNG where at the conclusion of the last episode the ship is seen heading out for it next mission, which we never see.

Open ended.

 

[M.A.C.O.]

I wonder why they didn't try to shop ENT around. It had 98 episodes (2 short of syndication), but UPN went off the air the same year as ENT. What would they have done if ENT did get a 5th season?

 

[Nebusj]

I wonder why they didn't try to shop ENT around. It had 98 episodes (2 short of syndication), but UPN went off the air the same year as ENT. What would they have done if ENT did get a 5th season?

Had UPN picked up Enterprise for a fifth season the show would've been fit somewhere on the CW schedule. Among the former-UPN shows on the CW's first season were Veronica Mars, Everybody Hates Chris, and Girlfriends; there were slightly more WB shows that went into the joined network.

It's also misleading to say Enterprise was ``two episodes short of syndication''; a hundred episodes is regarded as a good, reliable syndication-friendly package and reaching the hundredth episode is a neat landmark. But it's not like 98 episodes is substantially less desirable. Syndication packages are deals between media corporations, not princesses and Rumpelstiltskin.

 

[RandyS]

Friends, friends, friends,

While I certainly agree with alot of your critisims of TATV, you guys seem to be missing the most important point: They killed off Trip, the single most annoying, least likeable, worthless jackass in the history of Star Trek.

For THAT alone, this episode should go down in history as the single greatest, most satisfying, award winning piece of television that is ever likely to exist.

 

[asl]

They killed off Trip, the single most annoying, least likeable, worthless jackass in the history of Star Trek.

Huh? Trip was very likeable. Did you even watch the show?

 

[TEACAKE'S PLEATHER DOME]

Trip was annoying and lovely and saved by an excellent actor. An everyman who worked.

 

[RandyS]

They killed off Trip, the single most annoying, least likeable, worthless jackass in the history of Star Trek.

Huh? Trip was very likeable. Did you even watch the show?

Yes I did. That's how I know he wasn't likeable. Reed was much more likeable than Trip ever was. Trip was a jerk, and believe me, that's the NICEST thing that could ever be said about him.

 

[Kobayshi Maru]

I'm with 2takesfrakes in that it was great to see these characters again. I'm sure that was the basic idea behind it, and I was grateful for that. But what was not good at all is why it needed to be tied into The Pegasus, or any other episode, at all? Why not just some stand-alone segment of Riker and Troi interacting? The Pegasus aspect was more distracting than anything else.

Had they done a 'generic' Riker-and-Troi-on-Enterprise D, we might now all be speculating on when it took place, rather than pointing out all the reasons it didn't work instead.

I agree the TNG story needed to be as unimportant as possible. Plus they should have stayed for the speech. It makes no sense that they reviewed the whole story and left out the speech that's supposed to be etched in their history textbooks. It would be like watching a movie about De Gaulle and missing the part where he gives his June 18th appeal.

 

[LMFAOschwarz]

Bla bla bla....

I agree the TNG story needed to be as unimportant as possible. Plus they should have stayed for the speech. It makes no sense that they reviewed the whole story and left out the speech that's supposed to be etched in their history textbooks. It would be like watching a movie about De Gaulle and missing the part where he gives his June 18th appeal.

That's a very large part of it, yeah. Imagine The Omega Glory fading back to the ship, just as they get to the part where Kirk is holding the constitution, saying "Over the years, you have slurred the meaning of the words..." . And in that example, we already know the words, even!

Once I realized that the Riker/Troi stuff was referencing The Pegasus, I started thinking about that episode, instead of the one I was watching. Admiral Pressman and phasing cloaking devices were not relevant here, yet they were foremost on my mind.

 

[dub]

Trip was a jerk, and believe me, that's the NICEST thing that could ever be said about him.

Trip was awesome, fun and the opposite of bland...so yeah, I guess I just blew your definitive statement out of the water so hard the humpback whales' friends had to send another probe.

 

[TEACAKE'S PLEATHER DOME]

Easily the most popular character on ENT.

 

[Dukhat]

They killed off Trip, the single most annoying, least likeable, worthless jackass in the history of Star Trek.

Huh? Trip was very likeable. Did you even watch the show?

Yes I did. That's how I know he wasn't likeable. Reed was much more likeable than Trip ever was. Trip was a jerk, and believe me, that's the NICEST thing that could ever be said about him.

Trip was, in essence, meant to be McCoy. That was the ONLY reason why they made him from the South, to be a McCoy clone. The problem with this is that McCoy, while often sparring good-natured "insults" with Spock, never came off as downright mean or racist. And McCoy's Southern upbringing was also much more of a humorous aspect of the character, while Trip's was more in-your-face, "hey, everyone, I'm from the South!"

But as someone else correctly pointed out, Connor Trineer worked with what he was given, and he gets a lot of credit for turning Trip from that jerk into debatably the most popular character on that show.

 

[RandyS]

Huh? Trip was very likeable. Did you even watch the show?

Yes I did. That's how I know he wasn't likeable. Reed was much more likeable than Trip ever was. Trip was a jerk, and believe me, that's the NICEST thing that could ever be said about him.

Trip was, in essence, meant to be McCoy. That was the ONLY reason why they made him from the South, to be a McCoy clone. The problem with this is that McCoy, while often sparring good-natured "insults" with Spock, never came off as downright mean or racist. And McCoy's Southern upbringing was also much more of a humorous aspect of the character, while Trip's was more in-your-face, "hey, everyone, I'm from the South!"

But as someone else correctly pointed out, Connor Trineer worked with what he was given, and he gets a lot of credit for turning Trip from that jerk into debatably the most popular character on that show.

I've never had a problem with the actor. I just don't like the character.

 

[Kobayshi Maru]

Yes I did. That's how I know he wasn't likeable. Reed was much more likeable than Trip ever was. Trip was a jerk, and believe me, that's the NICEST thing that could ever be said about him.

Trip was, in essence, meant to be McCoy. That was the ONLY reason why they made him from the South, to be a McCoy clone. The problem with this is that McCoy, while often sparring good-natured "insults" with Spock, never came off as downright mean or racist. And McCoy's Southern upbringing was also much more of a humorous aspect of the character, while Trip's was more in-your-face, "hey, everyone, I'm from the South!"

But as someone else correctly pointed out, Connor Trineer worked with what he was given, and he gets a lot of credit for turning Trip from that jerk into debatably the most popular character on that show.

I've never had a problem with the actor. I just don't like the character.

The character is a little too colorful for my taste. It's like he needs to be the center of attention in every scene he's in. To quote Archer: "Let me play Captain for once!"

 

[ReedEnterprise]

I don't entirely hate TATV, the concept was good.....as far as Troi and Riker. It wasn't executed correctly. How would I do it? I don't entirely know, but it wouldn't be that way.

Number 2....don't kill Trip. He is my second favorite character in all of Trek (Worf first, Reed third).....he was funny, down to earth....he basically was us on a ship. The wonder, innocence, the ingenuity, the hardness he felt after the Xindi attack.

That is my reason. I am one that is grateful for "The Good That Men Do", and the novels that follow.

 

[Kobayshi Maru]

I don't entirely hate TATV, the concept was good.....as far as Troi and Riker. It wasn't executed correctly. How would I do it? I don't entirely know, but it wouldn't be that way.

Number 2....don't kill Trip. He is my second favorite character in all of Trek (Worf first, Reed third).....he was funny, down to earth....he basically was us on a ship. The wonder, innocence, the ingenuity, the hardness he felt after the Xindi attack.

That is my reason. I am one that is grateful for "The Good That Men Do", and the novels that follow.

It definitely wasn't the worst episode of that series. A Night In Sickbay deserved that title.