Your Ranking of Every Season/Film Series of Every Trek

[Odo]

I’ve done it…I’ve finally seen ever Trek episode/film ever released…

I tried ranking them all - tbh I find things to enjoy in all seasons (even if im much more critical of some than others). Im sure I could rearrange some of these - is TOS Season 1 truly top dog? Did I really enjoy the last two Picard seasons least?

Well, anyway, here’s my preliminary ranking. What’s yours?

1. TOS1
2. TNG3
3. DS9-5
4. DS9-6
5. TNG5
6. DS9-4
7. TOS2
8. TOS-M
9. TNG4
10. TNG6
11. DS9-7
12. TNG7
13. LD2
14. DS9-3
15. ENT3
16. TNG2
17. DS9-2
18. SNW1
19. DS9-1
20. DISCO1
21. ENT4
22. KELVIN
23. VOY4
24. TOS3
25. LD3
26. PRO1
27. LD1
28. PIC1
29. VOY5
30. VOY3
31. ST
32. TNG-M
33. ENT1
34. DISCO3
35. DISCO4
36. VOY6
37. VOY1
38. TAS
39. TNG1
40. DISCO2
41. ENT2
42. VOY7
43. VOY2
44. PIC3
45. PIC2

Wild that ST’s first season is its best (imo)

 

[Odo]

Looking at my list and I already want to change it. SNW should be higher (though I thought the finale was the weakest part)

this may be fool’s errand haha

 

[NCC-73515]

https://www.trekbbs.com/threads/fin...ate-all-episodes-and-plot-the-results.304150/

Several other rankings and plots here

 

[Lord Garth]

https://www.trekbbs.com/threads/fin...ate-all-episodes-and-plot-the-results.304150/

Several other rankings and plots here

Thanks to NCC-73515, I can look at what I have over there! Bolding what I thought was the best season of each series (or best batch of films). These are on a 10-scale. Normally, I rate episodes 7s or 8s, so anything with an average below 7.5 means I thought there were more problems than usual. On the surface, a 7.0 might look "good" but if that was the average, then that means there was a lot of mediocrity in there (5s and 6s).

TOS Films --> 8.50
DS9 Season 4 --> 8.46
TOS Season 1 --> 8.27
TNG Season 6 --> 8.08
TOS Season 2 --> 8.04
VOY Season 4 --> 8.04
DS9 Season 2 --> 8.00
DS9 Season 7 --> 8.00
DS9 Season 6 --> 7.96
DS9 Season 5 --> 7.92
TNG Season 4 --> 7.87
TNG Season 3 --> 7.85
DS9 Season 3 --> 7.85
VOY Season 3 --> 7.85
VOY Season 1 --> 7.60
ENT Season 4 --> 7.55
TNG Season 7 --> 7.50
TNG Season 5 --> 7.42
VOY Season 7 --> 7.42
DS9 Season 1 --> 7.15
VOY Season 6 --> 7.12
ENT Season 1 --> 7.08
ENT Season 3 --> 7.08
TOS Season 3 --> 7.04
VOY Season 2 --> 7.04
Kelvin Films --> 7.00
ENT Season 2 --> 6.73
TNG Season 2 --> 6.68
VOY Season 5 --> 6.58
TNG Films --> 6.50
TNG Season 1 --> 6.23

I'm cutting it off at 2016 to avoid Recency Bias, and I think I might've rated some New Trek episodes too high upon First Reaction, whereas with Old Trek, these have had time to sink in.

These are also just snapshots of whatever I thought at the time I rated the episodes and a lot of it was based off faded memory. So don't take any of this as gospel.

EDIT: I've updated this list to include my averages for the films.

 

[Annorax849]

I’ll do a top 15 for now

PIC-3
DS9-5
DS9-7
ENT-4
TOS-1
TNG-6
DS9-6
VOY-4
DS9-4
TNG-5
VOY-3
TNG-4
SNW-1
TNG-7
DIS-2

 

[Uhura's Song]

I have not watched them all recently enough to rank each season of each show. I have seen then all.

But I can rank the shows, and the movies, pretty easily.

Shows:
1. TNG
2. TOS
3. DS9
4. SNW
------------
5. VOY
6. ENT
7. PIC
8. DISCO
9. LD
10. PRO
---------
11. TAS

Movies:
1. TOS: TWOK
2. TOS: TUC
3. TOS: TVH
4. TNG: FC
5. TOS: TSFS
-----------------
6. TOS: TMP
7. KELVIN: ST
8. TNG: INS
9. TNG: GEN
10. KELVIN: BEY
----------
11. TOS: TFF
12. TNG: NEM
13. KELVIN: STID

My favorite seasons, or ones that I recall as enjoying the most would be, in no particular order:

1. TOS 1
2. TOS 2
3. TNG 3
4. TNG 4
5. TNG 5
6. TNG 6
7. DS9 4
8. DS9 5
9. DS9 6
10. VOY 4
11. ENT 3
12. ENT 4
13. DISCO 1
14. PIC 3
14. LD2
15. SNW 1
16. PRO 1

There should be another VOY or two in there (3 + 1?). TNG 7. DS9 2 & 7. DISCO 4. PIC 1. LD 3 & 1. Off the top of my head, that would be the top 25.

TOS1 is the champ for me.

 

[ELCHawk]

I am not smart enough to list a top 15 of seasons but for NuTrek I know Picard 3, SNW 1, and Prodigy 1 will be on it. Possibly Discovery 2.

 

[gweeps]

Least favourites would be easier for me. Process of elimination.