• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

You can handle the truth!

Ummmm...yeah

Much of the hatred for Shatner from the STAR TREK fans is because he looked them straight in the eyes and told them 'to get a life'. The image of TREK fandom being populated by 35year old men who are still living at home playing their XBOX360s is not just limited to Shatner; thats the image of Trek fans by most of the rest of the world's population. Its an image that, sadly, is still as clear as it was 20 years ago (except it was Ninetindo 64)....

Shatner is also hated by some because he had the guts, 40 years ago, to shove the lower rung actors into the backround, where all of them belonged, and fight to be front and center in the camera, even going so far as stealing other people's lines (Something that other stars of TV shows from those days, and these days, did and will always do). Homerun shatner!

So when any other TREK actor comes along and voices his opinion about the TREK they were on and how bad it was, Robert Beltran specifically, some in the fanbase attack them. But everything Beltran says about that show is pretty much discussed on the board all the time as being...spot on. Lack of writing..lack of continuity...ect ect ect...he is right. IMO.

Now we have Bakula airing some of his opinions about his TREK, and some of the fans cant wait to get on his case.

Me? I think he is dead on with what he is saying just as Beltran was 100% right about everything he said about that show...and Shatner has told it like it is from day one...

I can handle the truth. Star Trek, all of it, has been far from perfect. If we can sit here and bicker back and forth, then they too, since they were there, can launch their verbal opinions. The truth hurts sometimes....and I love freedom of speech.

Rob
 
Have a read of the 'what I hate about Star trek' thread in this very forum and I'm sure you'll find people who agree with you on this (myself included).
 
Gotta say I agree also. It's very hypocritical of fans to blast the actors when they voice their opinions. Actually they have more of a right to talk about then the fans do since Mr. Scorpio said
since they were there
 
Gotta say I agree also. It's very hypocritical of fans to blast the actors when they voice their opinions. Actually they have more of a right to talk about then the fans do since Mr. Scorpio said
since they were there

Well said that man! It hits upon a certain truth about being a star trek fan: that we can unfortunately be a bit to precious about the whole thing. We've all got things we like and dislike so lets discuss them like grown up nerds!;)
 
Have a read of the 'what I hate about Star trek' thread in this very forum and I'm sure you'll find people who agree with you on this (myself included).

Whew..I just posted there. Glad to get some of that off my chest!!!..

As for ranting and raving? Its friday. Thats when I do must of my ranting and raving....My MIRRROR UNIVERSE counterpart comes over here and posts on friday and then he goes back home and I'm like..dude...what the hell was that???

Rob
 
Have a read of the 'what I hate about Star trek' thread in this very forum and I'm sure you'll find people who agree with you on this (myself included).

Whew..I just posted there. Glad to get some of that off my chest!!!..

As for ranting and raving? Its friday. Thats when I do must of my ranting and raving....My MIRRROR UNIVERSE counterpart comes over here and posts on friday and then he goes back home and I'm like..dude...what the hell was that???

Rob


Does he have a goatee?
 
Spot on, RobertScorpio! :techman:

Much of the hatred for Shatner from the STAR TREK fans is because he looked them straight in the eyes and told them 'to get a life'.
To me, Star Trek is a hobby. And I learned a long time ago that, for me, any hobby that takes itself too seriously and has no sense of humor about itself gets very boring very quickly. So Shatner poking a little fun at us fans is just fine with me!

Shatner is also hated by some because he had the guts, 40 years ago, to shove the lower rung actors into the backround, where all of them belonged, and fight to be front and center in the camera, even going so far as stealing other people's lines
I suspect all of this has been greatly exaggerated over the years, but even if it hasn't been, I don't care. The end result of this "underhandedness" was a tightly focused and dramatically exciting show light-years ahead of the typical meandering soap operas (with their lame and distracting B-plots tacked on for the sole purpose of giving the minor characters who had no purpose in the main plot something to do) that we see so often in modern TV show. ;)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top