• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Would Nemesis have been better if Jonathan Frakes had directed?

I went to see NEM a few times at the theatre when it first came out. I usually do this for Trek and Batman films as I enjoy the communal experience as well as the big screen and big sound. With NEM, though, it was more like "giving it a second and third chance in case I missed something important." The thing is, I really disliked this film at first and thought that maybe it was me so I went back to make sure. This is a weak film in which the writer just didn't know the characters and how to write for them successfully. When you discuss the plot, it sounds good, but the execution was weak. The characters were out-of-character most of the time, although not all of the time. Unlike GEN, which gets worse for me with every viewing, NEM improves. I'll never see it as a great film but it doesn't suck nearly as bad as GEN and certainly not as bad as TFF. What bothers me most about this film is that it did so poorly at the theatres that we may never see TNG on TV or at the movies ever again. That's unforgivable.
 
NKemp3;7064941 Sirtis at times is nothing more than a little gossip queen in regards to Trek. I suppose that is what her career has come down to. Unfortunately she gets stuff wrong way too often. Always has. And she has always been one to take shots (some subtle said:
Very, very "This".

Sirtis has often been quite unkind about "Deep Sleep Nine" (her pet-name for the series at a few conventions in the 1990s), and has always been a bit bitter at the end of TNG.
 
Let's not turn this into a Marina Sirtis bashing topic.

DS9 isn't for everyone.

Sirtis not liking it doesn't make her a lesser person.
 
Let's not turn this into a Marina Sirtis bashing topic.

DS9 isn't for everyone.

Sirtis not liking it doesn't make her a lesser person.

No, it doesn't. The reason people find her remarks off-putting is because one would hope that she would be more professional in her comments about another Star Trek series. She may not care for Deep Space 9, but there are many people who are fans of both it and The Next Generation.
 
Let's not turn this into a Marina Sirtis bashing topic.

DS9 isn't for everyone.

Sirtis not liking it doesn't make her a lesser person.

No, it doesn't. The reason people find her remarks off-putting is because one would hope that she would be more professional in her comments about another Star Trek series. She may not care for Deep Space 9, but there are many people who are fans of both it and The Next Generation.


it's especially insulting when two of her castmates from TNG went on to BE in DS9.
 
Let's not turn this into a Marina Sirtis bashing topic.

DS9 isn't for everyone.

Sirtis not liking it doesn't make her a lesser person.

No, but her bitchy comments make her seem, at best, very unprofessional.

Agreed. Her comments on DS9 always just struck me as her being upset that TNG ended and it being a convenient target to vent that towards.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top