• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

With Liberty and Justice For All

Enterprise1981

Vice Admiral
Admiral
My entry for the June 2011 challenge. It concerns Cardassian politics following the Dominion War. Word count approximately 2700. Special thanks to Gul Re'jal for beta reading.

In addition to canon, this story draws on events established in A Stitch in Time, the Never Ending Sacrifice, and the Terok Nor trilogy.

Author’s Preface

The first Puritan settlers of America sought religious freedom, but only for themselves. While they accepted non-Christian faiths, the Puritans considered persons belonging to other Christian sects to be false Christians. The earliest settlers of the American south believed in the freedom to discriminate on the basis of race. More recently, sectarian warfare in Iraq between the Sunni and Shi’a sects of Islam was kept in check by the secular dictator Saddam Hussein. Following his downfall in Operation Iraqi Freedom, religious extremists considered themselves free to continue the blood feuds of the last thousand years. And in the 24th century during the waning months of the Dominion War, the Cardassians sought freedom from their Dominion overlords. But what exactly does freedom mean to a race that values order and security over what Terrans would label as individual civil liberties? Told from the vantage points of three major factions that arose from the fall of the Dominion-allied government, this is the story of how the populace basks in its newfound freedom.
 
“Freedom is ours for the taking!” Corat Damar proclaimed to his fellow Cardassians on a street in Cardassia City.

Those words spurred the civilian population of Cardassia to rise up against their Dominion overlords. For the last two and a half years, the Cardassian Union had been a protectorate of the Dominion. Initially, the alliance proved beneficial to Cardassia with the Dominion turning away Klingon occupational forces and eradicating a considerable percentage of the Maquis. But as the Federation Alliance War dragged on, and the enemy began pushing deeper into Dominion occupied territory, the Dominion was keeping a tighter leash on its Alpha Quadrant allies.

Legate Damar, as head of the Dominion-allied government, saw his people’s political autonomy dwindling. At first he was okay with that since the price of losing the war was too high for the Cardassian Union. He had had enough when Weyoun and the Female Changeling secretly formed an alliance with the Breen Confederacy that included turning over Cardassian territory to the Breen. And as if that wasn’t enough, the Dominion left the Cardassians to fend for themselves during the attack on Septimus Three.

While the Cardassian Liberation Front was eventually defeated, Damar was able to spark a popular uprising on Cardassia Prime. These rebels engaged in acts of sabotage against the Dominion while the final battle of the war was taking place. Despite the retaliatory strikes resulting in over eight hundred million deaths, Damar’s rebellion did not waiver, and the Dominion would soon be vanquished.

With the Dominion defeated and expelled from the Alpha Quadrant, an independent provisional government was in power on Cardassia Prime. Alon Ghemor, nephew of the late dissident Tekeny Ghemor, was anointed leader of the new order. The Ghemor name was revered throughout Cardassia when Tekeny led the Cardassian Underground in the overthrow of military rule shortly before the Klingon invasion. Alon followed in his uncle’s footsteps as an influential figure in a Cardassian government-in-exile. Now that the Dominion was gone, the populace had nearly unanimously supported Ghemor.

“We realize that many of you want revenge against those who caused such great suffering,” Ghemor stated in a news conference broadcast throughout the Cardassian Union. “We ask at this time that you continue to place order and security above personal honor and family honor and allow the courts and legal system time to locate and prosecute those responsible. Only a sane and careful investigation can allow us to separate those who were willing supporters of the Dominion-allied government from those who cooperated only in fear of their lives.”


###

“Just another politician,” Tahmin Rejal mumbled as he watched the live transmission of Ghemor’s speech during a gathering of surviving members of the Rejal clan.

“But also our best hope for a brighter future,” Gilora replied.

As a distant cousin of the old Detapa Council’s chief executor, Gilora’s voice carried little weight with the patriarchs of the Rejal clan. Add to that, because the Rejal clan comprised a long line of politicians, Gilora was not even very popular among her immediate family even though her talents and abilities were put to better use as a scientist and engineer. Following the Dominion massacre of Cardassia Prime, Gilora was one of the survivors from the Rejal clan, leaving her as a major representative of her extended family.

“Alon Ghemor isn’t like his uncle, Gilora,” Tahmin scoffed. “He could repeat the mistakes of my sister.” His sister was the late Meya Rejal, Chief Executor to the Detapa Council. Tekeny Ghemor was the inspirational leader of the Cardassian Underground, as a member of the Central Command even after he sought asylum on the neutral planet Mathen. Meya Rejal, on the other hand, led the coup d’etat that overthrew the military rule and returned political power to the civilian legislative body. For that reason, Rejal felt she deserved to lead the new Cardassia, not Tekeny Ghemor.

The more conservative elements of the Underground only acted on the belief that they had no obligation to recognize an entity with no legitimate political power—in this case, the Central Command. They had rejected certain Federation ideals such as representative democracy and individual civil liberties. Ironically, Rejal argued that to give Ghemor leadership of the Council would install another military leader, which the Underground had fought to abolish. In spite of her determination to lead a new Cardassia, she and the Detapa Council were ill equipped to handle the various crises from the Klingon War to rising poverty throughout the Cardassian Empire. For that, Meya Rejal was executed a year and a half later following another coup that placed Gul Skrain Dukat as leader of a new Dominion-allied military government. And many in her immediate family sought to distance themselves from Meya’s legacy.

“Worried he can’t deliver on his promises?” Gilora inquired. “Perhaps you should grab power for yourself and execute your dissenters.”

Tahmin shook his head and rolled his eyes, not wanting to be reminded of the harsh methods that Meya fought against, yet employed once she was in power. “Tekeny Ghemor was an inspiration,” a third person chimed in. Prenan emerged from a dark corner of the room. “What do we know of his nephew? Can he deliver on his promises to allow what’s left of the legal system to hunt down the traitors of Cardassia?”

“We’re not Klingons, Prenan,” Gilora shot back. “We don’t embark on personal quests of vengeance to assure that honor is satisfied. That’s what our courts are for.”

“What’s left of them after the Jem’Hadar laid waste to our home,” Dralin sneered. Others shouted in agreement that more drastic action was necessary to punish those who had sold out their people out to the Dominion.

“Gilora is right,” Tahmin offered. “We have moved beyond the need for clan wars.”

“But can we rely on the courts to identify and punish the traitors?” Prenan asked. “Recent history would suggest we cannot.”

“Maybe not in the short term,” Gilora answered. Addressing the rest of the crowd, she added, “But the alternative is anarchy and mob rule. We may not have the government in place to maintain order anymore. Order and security are still to be valued especially in times of turmoil. Would any of you really want to forsake five hundred years of history and tradition or stay true to our values?”

Most of the onlookers stood blank-faced, not sure what to make of Gilora’s statements. Many of them came to this gathering seeking to avenge the deaths of siblings, spouses, children, parents, and cousins who were lost to the Dominion in the closing weeks of the war. It was a matter of personal and family honor to avenge those deaths. But who was left to settle the score with the Dominion retreating to the Gamma Quadrant and many of the Cardassians who fought with the Dominion in the war’s final battle switched sides when they learned what was happening to the home planet? Damar was among the dead and Dukat was listed as persona non grata.

“You make some very persuasive points, Gilora,” Tahmin said with a nod. Addressing the rest of the group, he added. “And that is why, despite recent animosity between the Rejal and Ghemor clans, we will support the Ghemor regime. His leadership could eventually prove ineffective as my late sister’s did. For now, he is preferable to no central government at all.”

Gilora flashed a slightly wicked grin, pleased that she had gotten through to one of her most vocal opponents. Many onlookers shouted in approval. A few dissenters remained, but they simply stood quietly and said nothing.

On the monitor in the meeting hall, Alon Ghemor was concluding his speech. “We will rise from the ashes and begin anew as we have so many times before. This I vow with my life’s blood. For my son. For all our sons!”
 
One Month Later

Gul Enic Hadar snorted in derision as he read the latest newsreels on a padd.

The major headline of the last month was regarding the upcoming voting competition between the two major political movements that had emerged after the war. A great majority of the population had supported Alon Ghemor and the Reunion Project. Hadar was among surviving Supreme Guls of the Cardassian Guard who represented the opposing Directorate. Also representing the traditional interests were the patriarchs of the elite clans once represented by the old Detapa Council. But with the future of the Cardassian Union hanging in the balance, the patriarchs feared that their interests were being ignored.

Korbath Mondrig was one such patriarch, chairing a meeting of upper-class families and military leaders who had survived the war. Gul Hadar prepared to deliver the news of the latest projections; that the Reunion Project would become the dominant political power.

“Ghemor looks to be well on his way to becoming First Castellan,” Hadar announced to the rest of the meeting’s attendants.

Others in the meeting let out groans of disapproval upon being reminded that their empire was being contaminated by Federation ideals of peace, equality, and representative democracy. It was something many of them had feared since first making contact with the United Federation of Planets. The seeds of dissent for the political arrangement had been sown decades before, but the Federation made for a plausible scapegoat for the recent social and moral entropy. And now the final nail in the proverbial coffin was that every adult member of their society-- even those of moderate or lesser intelligence-- had the privilege of choosing the next leader of Cardassia.

“You know what this all goes back to?” Gul Aman Evek rhetorically asked the gathering. “When Damar’s rebellion gave the Federation the means to defend itself against the Breen energy dampening weapons.”

Raucous cheers and jeers erupted around the meeting table. “Exactly,” many of them called out.

“The rebellion was defeated because we didn’t stand a chance against Breen weapons,” one of the civilians chimed in.

“We couldn’t have defeated the Dominion and the Breen ourselves,” another chimed in.

“Maybe so,” Evek responded to the skeptics. “But because Damar was doing Starfleet’s dirty work, “it sent a message that the Federation was our best hope for salvation.”

“It let many of our people think that their way was the better way,” Gul Malyn Ocett added.

Many nodded in agreement. Their dislike for the Federation did not change because of the brief alliance during the Battle of Cardassia. The Federation often preached tolerance among its member races, but not for ways of life radically different from their own. Yet, it allied itself with the Klingon Empire, even to the point of refusing to become openly involved when the Klingons invaded Cardassian territory. Federation ideals of peaceful coexistence had now contaminated the Cardassian way of life and it was only a matter of time before Cardassia became another Federation member.

“We can still use these ideals to our advantage,” Mondrig offered.

“How?” Evek wondered aloud along with others voicing their curiosity.

“By assuring that our interests are sufficiently represented in the new government,” Mondrig explained slyly. Others in the meeting began nodding in agreement. “Hadar,” Mondrig continued. “What are the current poll numbers?”

“Eighty-seven percent support the Reunion Project,” Hadar replied with a glance at the padd.

“Eighty seven percent,” Mondrig repeated. “That means a sizeable portion of the population supports the Directorate. The people can have Ghemor as their new leader if they so desire. But he and his supporters will difficult time making Cardassia a Federation planet as long as we are in the mix.”

The rest of the gathering applauded by thumping on the table.

The applause was quickly interrupted by the sound of commotion outside the building. Everyone in the meeting clamored towards the window. On the street, a number of masked figures carrying torches were causing all kinds of mayhem. Some were setting fire to buildings; others were throwing explosive grenades, ransacking outdoor shops and threatening random passers-by.
 
Note: Contains interpretations of the Oralian Way based on lines of dialogue from the DS9 episode “The Darkness and the Light”, and may differ from those of other fan-fiction authors. The mob featured in this scene is an extremist branch, while Thrax represents a more moderate sect of the Oralian Way.


The looting and pillaging of the town square went on for nearly an hour. Nearly a dozen masked humanoids were causing all sorts of mayhem, acting on intelligence that members of the Directorate had gathered prior to the next day’s voting competition. Even as riot squads intervened, the vandalism of shops and the beatings of random passers-by only spread throughout the streets. Only when the number of law officers grew did the violence wane. Many individuals who were incited by the masked humanoids either ran away or surrendered to arriving troops.

Thrax Sa’kat led a team of local police to begin making arrests. At one point in his life, he had served as head of security under Gul Dukat on Terok Nor. He had eventually grown weary of Dukat and resigned his position and returned to police work on Cardassia Prime. During his stints as a law enforcer in Cardassia City, Thrax had used his position as a means of protecting followers of the Oralian Way, a religion that had dated back to the days of the first Hebitian civilizations. Since the founding of the modern day Cardassian Union five centuries earlier, the Oralians were marked for genocide, placing them on the verge of extinction in recent decades. Worshippers of Oralius were even more of a target under Dominion rule as believers in a false god. For that reason, Thrax led an underground railroad for those Cardassians seeking escape during the Federation Alliance War.

As the original rioters were apprehended, Thrax ordered his troops to escort them away. He pulled one of the masked humanoids aside and dragged that person into a side alley. “What is the meaning of this?!” he angrily demanded of one of the protestors, as he pulled off a male Cardassian’s mask.

“It’s about justice,” the young man replied. “It’s about retaliation for centuries of persecution at the hands of the legions of darkness.”

This is justice to you?” Thrax snarled. “Indiscriminate killing? We have stood for fighting against the casual brutality of the legions of darkness on our world and on Bajor. Even as we were being hunted down soulless minions and believers in false gods, we stayed true to our ideals.”

“The Directorate hides itself well,” the young man explained. “If they are allowed disrupt the new regime, then the dark leaders will continue to hunt us and kill us.”

“This is not how we expose the darkness to the light of justice,” Thrax insisted, grabbing the young man by the collar. “What of the innocent people wounded or killed just now? Was there any justice for them? Even if the Directorate and what if represents is a threat to us, they still have the right to peaceably assemble as we do. And so do the supporters of the Reunion Project. You’re only giving credibility to the propagandists by pulling these kinds of shenanigans. Am I clear, young man?”

“Yes, sir, very much,” the young man replied as if he was afraid for his life.

Thrax then motioned one of his subordinates over to him while letting go of the looter he had confronted. “Get him out of my sight,” he ordered.

The subordinate escorted the young man away leaving Thrax behind to stare at the carnage left behind by individuals who committed acts of terrorism in the name of the Oralian Way. Similar incidents of violence happened on Bajor during the early days of the Cardassian Occupation. One of the representatives of the Oralian Way suggested setting up an enclave on Bajor. That was the first step towards establishing a foothold, as well as growing discontent between Cardassians and Bajorans. That became Oralian Way’s legacy in recent decades.

Thrax feared that this scene he was now witnessing was a sign of things to come.


Just here arose the temptation of the historic slogan of the French Revolution which meant so much to Jefferson and his friends, 'Liberty, equality, fraternity'. No, that would be too fanciful, too many thousands of years off in realization. But we as a nation do stand square on the doctrine of liberty and justice for all..." Francis Bellamy, author of the Pledge of Allegiance
 
An amazing portrait of post-revolution politics. Cardassia is at last free, but--what now?

My compliments.
 
I like how you show three different, opposing points of view without validating which one is correct, without favouring anyone. In case of the Oralians we see extremists, but this is balanced by Thrax to show that this violence is by no means a typical Oralian conduct.

A good read!
 
Thanks for the reviews so far. The story premise was largely derived from the long term political implications of the Iraq and Afghanistan (all the conflict in the Middle East, of course, dating back to the breakup of the Ottoman Empire). And the religious extremists are an allegory for the Islam-o-phobia in the guise of "it's an evil cult rather than a religion".
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top