Discussion in 'Star Trek: Deep Space Nine' started by ElimGarak, Apr 21, 2012.
a show with such fantastic writing ends with such a contrived pile of garbage - why?!?!
I assume you are referring to the "Satan vs. Jesus" thing between sisko and dukat, and I agree.
Wow. I love the ending. It's so...epic! Different strokes...
Gotta love this ending, probably my favorite and often considered the best.
Definitely the best Trek series ender of all.
Well thats a broad generalisation of the episode, do you have specifics that you didn't like?
I'm not sure I'd go that far - "All Good Things" is probably my favorite. But DS9's was fantastic as well.
Course when we say "best" ender...there are really only three, right? TOS didn't really have an "ender" - it just ended. I don't know about ENT, though.
As the show was ending I knew something unconventional was needed.
Never really liked the whole bajor religion thing to begin with, such dull people the bajorans, as for the ending it was as bad as I had expected it would be, but ending a show is always tough.
Kira staying was the right choice in my opinion as was ezri , quark and bashir, just as o brien , odo and worf moving on.
I think it finished great EXCEPT for this whole sisko dukat nemisis thing.
The writers producers and directors etc wanted dukat as the arch villian, not the dominion and maybe its me but dukat was far less evil than the dominion, so this sisko dukat thing was always gonna be the crux of the ending to them and while I never cared for the ending on that issue everything else finished up perfect .
Both TOS and TNG had similar ending, when we last see them, both Enterprises are sailing away toward their next mission, which is my favorite way to end a series.
Voyager completed it "mission," by arriving back at Earth, job done.
Sisko paid the price the Prophets said he would have to pay, in Sacrifice of Angels. Living up to their name of "Prophets."
Would someone please tell me what the hell to last episode of Enterprise was about?
Everything in it was great up until the comic book style ending. It was just too corny for me. Much better than Voyager's and Enterprise's ending, but a bit too much.
Wasn't it about the creation of the Coalition of Planets, I do seem to recall they made an episode of TNG set on the holodeck of the Ent-D with a recreation of events circa 2161 called "These are the Voyages" after this story however.
Didn't one of the writers say something like "even Shakespeare would have had a hard time writing the end of Deep Space Nine"?
I don't think any television series finale pleases all fans, but "What You Leave Behind" was/is a great sendoff for DS9.
While there were certain aspects of the finale I did not like, I would hardly call it a "contrived pile of garbage." However, unlike your vague generalization, I will list the things I didn't like.
1. I really did not like the reuse of battle footage from a previous episode for the "final battle." I felt it was an incredibly cheap move, especially for the series finale.
2. The whole "Sisko abruptly leaving to go die in a fire cave with Dukat" thing was totally contrived. If they spent more time on that scene, it might have worked better, but it felt like it was just thrown in at the last minute.
3. Damar's death was also very contrived.
Other than those three points, the finale was just fine.
That is actually quite funny.
I'd argue against calling it a "cheap move". Just because it's the last episode doesn't mean they have an bottomless money pit to call on.
I have 3 gripes with the final as well.
First, is to do with the reused battle footage. I don't think all the reused footage was bad. The only stuff that was out of place was the Sacrifice of Angels footage, you cut that out and the new and old footage gels far better.
Second, there should have been a scene with Ben and Jake after he joined the Prophets. I don't think you'd lose anything with the final scene with Jake looking out at the wormhole if they did have a chat before hand.
Third, the lack of Jadzia in the flashback. As I understand it there were problems due to them previously using her image earlier in the season. It would have been nice if something could have been figured out.
Other than those 3 things I enjoyed the finale.
I guess I must be the only one who honestly never really noticed any reused battle footage in the finale. Maybe it's because I don't really care for battle scenes in general to begin with. And to be honest, even with the knowledge that there are in fact reused shots, they don't really bother me at all. I guess I'm just wired differently.
As for the finale itself; it's not bad, but I was never a big fan of it. I don't know why, but somehow it feels disconnected.
same here, all this pedantry over re used scenes is hardly an issue to most people except the complete nerd
I like TNG, don't get me wrong, but on it's best day it was only as good as a moderately good ep of DS9.
DS9 did far more, and far more interesting things with it's characters than TNG was ever allowed to do (thank the Great Bird for Berman's contempt of DS9 in this case).
The finale of DS9 therefore FELT like a finale. The crew was breaking up, going on to the next chapter in their lives. Things would never be the same again.
AGT felt like just another ep (2-part ep but ep nonetheless). The status quo prevailed, and we were left with the impression that their journey together was not over yet, that we could come back and pick up right from there and nothing would have changed. Which indeed it was the case with 4 feature films yet to come.
Arguably, TNG's true "finale" was Nemesis. Some characters moved on, one (Data) died, new characters were coming in (Madden), and the status quo came to an end.
totally agree with you ian
Totally disagree with you, Ian and Gazomg, but that's OK. I love both shows, so perhaps I'm biased, but I honestly thought AGT was the almost perfect ending. But then, so was WYLB. I really don't feel a need to quantify which one (show or finale) was better. They were great, and I'm happy to leave it at that.
P.S. I also never noticed the reused battle scenes. To be honest, very few battle scenes stay in my mind longer than, oh, 27 seconds or so.
27 seconds ?
thats longer than the memory of a goldfish....or so we are told .
How exactly they work that out I am not sure
Separate names with a comma.