• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Who would've replaced Scotty in Generations if Doohan had said no?

Now let's compare that with FC/INS/NEM: Hey, the entire TNG crew are all serving together for three movies...why, again? By this time they're all of command rank and should either be getting ships of their own, serving on other ships, or graduating to higher levels of Starfleet Command. Yet here they are all together for no real reason other than the writers just wanted to maintain the status quo of TNG despite it not making any sense (and also trying to shoehorn in Worf with decreasing levels of logic.)
I understand what you're saying, but it never bothered me. So from a production standpoint, it's just easier to have them all together. If not, you have to explain how and why everyone's meeting up again. If Riker had his own command, presumably we have to see the bridge and the exterior of the ship at a minimum. Plus some of his crew. More time, more money.
 
I understand what you're saying, but it never bothered me. So from a production standpoint, it's just easier to have them all together. If not, you have to explain how and why everyone's meeting up again. If Riker had his own command, presumably we have to see the bridge and the exterior of the ship at a minimum. Plus some of his crew. More time, more money.

Oh, I doubt it bothered most people, myself included when I watched the movies first-run. But over time I've changed my opinions of how I think things should have happened. If anything, focusing on individual characters and what they have chosen to do with their lives would have been far more interesting to me, rather than just having them be brushed aside to focus on Picard & Data. Of course, that would only have allowed a niche audience to enjoy the movies (i.e. people who actually watched TNG), but then again, I really never believed that the TNG crew would have the same kind of attraction to non-fans that the TOS crew had.
 
And there's the rub: the story should have been better and more realistic about why these people should still be together for three more movies, rather than just the status quo of them serving on the same ship when they all should have gone their separate ways after the D was destroyed.
Why? Who cares? I consider it totally irrelevant. Don't waste story time trying to explain and justify them being together. They're together because it's a movie and we want the TNG crew to be together. I couldn't care less that it's not "realistic."
 
Why? Who cares? I consider it totally irrelevant. Don't waste story time trying to explain and justify them being together. They're together because it's a movie and we want the TNG crew to be together. I couldn't care less that it's not "realistic."

And you’re entitled to your opinion on the matter. I for one would have liked better closure for these characters than what we got in those films, and even better than what we got in PIC.
 
I suppose I wish the TNG films were something they were not and would never be.

Generations, for what it is, is fine. To me, it's the end of the TNG era in ways that "All Good Things..." is not -- the ship is destroyed, the mission ends, the crew theoretically will scatter.

After this, the sky truly was the limit, and the characters could have gone anywhere. Berman and his writers were not chained to the television series' status quo. They could have reinvented TNG, but they didn't.

There's no reason why Riker should not have his own command. Starfleet had offered several promotions over the course of the series, and he turned them all down. There's no reason for Riker not to accept promotion after the events of Generations; if he doesn't, at some point Starfleet is going to look at him like the alternate Picard of "Tapesty," a once-promising officer whose career stagnated and is on a path to nowhere. By the time of Nemesis, I sometimes I wonder why Starfleet even offered him the Titan. There are ambitious, battle tested officers throughout the fleet, and Riker's career is stalled out in a holding pattern. (Riker making Admiral in the novels before Picard was, imho, nonsense.)

Picard as an Admiral? He tells Kirk in the Nexus he's not planning on leaving the center seat, and Kirk's warning that "you can make a difference" from the center seat proves prescient when Picard's promotion to Admiral turns out to not make the difference he'd hoped. The Star Trek format doesn't really lend itself to this, though, arguably, no one has ever tried, but I would have been curious what a film with a character like Kirk or Picard as an Admiral, doing Admiral stuff, like a sector command or a fleet command, would have looked like. Yes, Kirk was an Admiral in the early films, but the films didn't really treat him any differently. Picard as an admiral, doing larger scale work, I can see the potential. Patrick Stewart might not have seen the potential -- he wanted to play an action hero -- but I wish they had tried.

I like Worf. Really, I do. But there's no need for him in the later films. First Contact does, at least, justify it. The other two.... Look, I get it. Michael Dorn wanted to hang with his friends, and there's a level at which these films seem to have been made for the cast to hang out and get paid for it.

It's the lack of ambition that saddens me. They could have carved out their own identity. I think of the TOS films as a distinct era of Star Trek, because they are. The TNG films are two-hour episodes on a feature film budget.
 
I suppose I wish the TNG films were something they were not and would never be.

Generations, for what it is, is fine. To me, it's the end of the TNG era in ways that "All Good Things..." is not -- the ship is destroyed, the mission ends, the crew theoretically will scatter.

After this, the sky truly was the limit, and the characters could have gone anywhere. Berman and his writers were not chained to the television series' status quo. They could have reinvented TNG, but they didn't.

There's no reason why Riker should not have his own command. Starfleet had offered several promotions over the course of the series, and he turned them all down. There's no reason for Riker not to accept promotion after the events of Generations; if he doesn't, at some point Starfleet is going to look at him like the alternate Picard of "Tapesty," a once-promising officer whose career stagnated and is on a path to nowhere. By the time of Nemesis, I sometimes I wonder why Starfleet even offered him the Titan. There are ambitious, battle tested officers throughout the fleet, and Riker's career is stalled out in a holding pattern. (Riker making Admiral in the novels before Picard was, imho, nonsense.)

Picard as an Admiral? He tells Kirk in the Nexus he's not planning on leaving the center seat, and Kirk's warning that "you can make a difference" from the center seat proves prescient when Picard's promotion to Admiral turns out to not make the difference he'd hoped. The Star Trek format doesn't really lend itself to this, though, arguably, no one has ever tried, but I would have been curious what a film with a character like Kirk or Picard as an Admiral, doing Admiral stuff, like a sector command or a fleet command, would have looked like. Yes, Kirk was an Admiral in the early films, but the films didn't really treat him any differently. Picard as an admiral, doing larger scale work, I can see the potential. Patrick Stewart might not have seen the potential -- he wanted to play an action hero -- but I wish they had tried.

I like Worf. Really, I do. But there's no need for him in the later films. First Contact does, at least, justify it. The other two.... Look, I get it. Michael Dorn wanted to hang with his friends, and there's a level at which these films seem to have been made for the cast to hang out and get paid for it.

It's the lack of ambition that saddens me. They could have carved out their own identity. I think of the TOS films as a distinct era of Star Trek, because they are. The TNG films are two-hour episodes on a feature film budget.

That's pretty much my take. On the one hand, I get the need to keep the status quo of 'crew on ship encountering weird stuff' as far as having casual moviegoers wanting to see the film, but on the other hand, instead of seeing these people we watched for seven years go in different directions, the producers chose to keep them stunted for three whole movies, with no development, no real reason to care about them, and who were ultimately overshadowed by Stewart and Spiner, who had far more creative control than they should have had, a lesson not learned in PIC.
 
That's pretty much my take. On the one hand, I get the need to keep the status quo of 'crew on ship encountering weird stuff' as far as having casual moviegoers wanting to see the film, but on the other hand, instead of seeing these people we watched for seven years go in different directions, the producers chose to keep them stunted for three whole movies, with no development, no real reason to care about them, and who were ultimately overshadowed by Stewart and Spiner, who had far more creative control than they should have had, a lesson not learned in PIC.
Well, that comes back to my basic premise that no one who is acting in a film or TV show should ever, for any reason, be given any level of creative control over that production. Ever. Full stop.

Sure, there are times when actors have had creative control and it has worked out okay. But there have been enough disasters created that I think the rule should stand.

Patrick Stewart, however, is I think one of the most egregious examples out there. He is unquestionably a brilliant actor. However, it is clear that he just did not like the character of Jean-Luc Picard. He was always, from the early days of TNG, fighting to remake him into a totally different character. And if that was the only way he was going to appear in the TNG films, I think they should have just done them without him rather than agreeing to what he wanted.
 
...and who were ultimately overshadowed by Stewart and Spiner, who had far more creative control than they should have had, a lesson not learned in PIC.
What I've never really understood is why Berman and the studio felt they had to cater to Stewart and Spiner. TNG was not a star vehicle for them in the way that TOS was for Shatner and Nimoy. TNG was always ensemble driven, but then the films reduced the rest of the cast to contractual obligation glorified cameos.

Sorry, I feel like I'm beating a dead horse.

Ultimately, I lay my issues at the feet of Berman. He didn't have a vision.
 
I think it's a completely different situation to the TOS movies. They had a decade of building fan demand for new adventures; TNG went straight into film production from the end of the series. The TOS movies also had the freedom to completely reinvent themselves. TNG had a status quo that had to be maintained, with DS9 being on the air. So any significant continuity change (the First Contact uniforms) has to be reflected in DS9. If anything, that seems to have kept them honest. Becasue as soon as they had complete freedom to do what they wanted, we got Nemesis.
 
What I've never really understood is why Berman and the studio felt they had to cater to Stewart and Spiner. TNG was not a star vehicle for them in the way that TOS was for Shatner and Nimoy. TNG was always ensemble driven, but then the films reduced the rest of the cast to contractual obligation glorified cameos.

Sorry, I feel like I'm beating a dead horse.

Ultimately, I lay my issues at the feet of Berman. He didn't have a vision.

To be fair, I think Berman was hamstrung by Paramount, just like he was later hamstrung by UPN. With GEN, they had a laundry list of stuff they wanted that he was basically forced to do (although I think the saucer crash was Braga's idea), and the success of FC made them think that this crew was as bankable as the TOS crew, which turned out not to be the case.
 
What I've never really understood is why Berman and the studio felt they had to cater to Stewart and Spiner. TNG was not a star vehicle for them in the way that TOS was for Shatner and Nimoy. TNG was always ensemble driven, but then the films reduced the rest of the cast to contractual obligation glorified cameos.

Sorry, I feel like I'm beating a dead horse.

Ultimately, I lay my issues at the feet of Berman. He didn't have a vision.
It became that, even with the "bones" thrown at other cast members.
 
To be fair, I think Berman was hamstrung by Paramount, just like he was later hamstrung by UPN. With GEN, they had a laundry list of stuff they wanted that he was basically forced to do (although I think the saucer crash was Braga's idea), and the success of FC made them think that this crew was as bankable as the TOS crew, which turned out not to be the case.
I think they lost momentum between 1998 and 2002. If they could have come up with another film that had the wider appeal of First Contact and got it out in 2000, that may have given them some momentum. I presume there would have been some scheduling conflicts with Stewart doing X-Men, but maybe that would have lead to some real creativity. They had everyone from DS9 available at that point...
 
I think they lost momentum between 1998 and 2002. If they could have come up with another film that had the wider appeal of First Contact and got it out in 2000, that may have given them some momentum. I presume there would have been some scheduling conflicts with Stewart doing X-Men, but maybe that would have lead to some real creativity. They had everyone from DS9 available at that point...

I honestly don't know what they were thinking with Insurrection. Right off the heels of FC, and that's what they ended up with?

(Actually, from what I understand, there was a different story in the works, involving Romulans, but they went with the INS story instead.)
 
(Actually, from what I understand, there was a different story in the works, involving Romulans, but they went with the INS story instead.)
Patrick Stewart hated the Romulans for some reason. Just absolutely hated them. ¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯
 
I honestly don't know what they were thinking with Insurrection. Right off the heels of FC, and that's what they ended up with?

(Actually, from what I understand, there was a different story in the works, involving Romulans, but they went with the INS story instead.)
That would make complete sense. They needed a strong villain from the series that they could make a great film with. Could have had Sela in it.
Patrick Stewart hated the Romulans for some reason. Just absolutely hated them. ¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯
Really? That's very bizarre, some of the most memorable TNG episodes were Romulan ones.
And yet they made Nemesis?
Exactly...
 
I wouldn't call Sela a strong villain.
Not for a film, no. Another character would need to be the top villain. I always thought there should have been some better closure or conclusion to the Sela character, and this could have been an opportunity.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top