• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

"What if you can find brand new worlds, right here on Earth?"

So which Hodgkin's Law planet was the most interesting?

  • Miri

    Votes: 3 11.1%
  • A Piece of the Action

    Votes: 3 11.1%
  • Patterns of Force

    Votes: 2 7.4%
  • The Omega Glory

    Votes: 3 11.1%
  • The Paradise Syndrome

    Votes: 2 7.4%
  • Bread and Circuses

    Votes: 10 37.0%
  • Other since I'm good at forgetting things

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Token "none of the above" answe

    Votes: 4 14.8%

  • Total voters
    27
I disliked all of these, purely for their stupid premise.

“What if Earth but different” is a common sci-fi trope that has been around as long as the genre itself, it’s only natural that Star Trek would dabble in it.

The one I found most interesting was Bread and Circuses, mostly for its satirical take on the television business in the sixties.
 
@Mr. Laser Beam Disagree with the assessment that the Omega Glory documents would have crumbled to dust. The preservation of those documents would have begun with 20th century-ish level of knowledge, gradually declining over the centuries.

The Philadelphia's visit to Omega IV was only about a century prior to the events of the episode. By that time, all the "20th-century" knowledge the Yangs had would have already been wiped out - they were savages for a long time before the freighter ever got there. So the Yangs would have no idea how to preserve those documents.

If they had, they'd never have gone all "Eed pleb nista".

You know, the concept of parallel earths isn't that bad of a concept. But the rational has to be more than "they just happened to evolve to be similar". Because the chances of that are so astronomical that it strains suspension of disbelief.

Yeah, like nuBSG having "All Along The Watchtower" spontaneously be written both on Earth and the Twelve Colonies. ;)
 
The Philadelphia's visit to Omega IV was only about a century prior to the events of the episode. By that time, all the "20th-century" knowledge the Yangs had would have already been wiped out - they were savages for a long time before the freighter ever got there. So the Yangs would have no idea how to preserve those documents.
I think you missed the point. The preservation that would have protected them was begun with 20th century knowledge. So we are not talking about some parchments in a pottery jar as the starting point for the documents' deterioration. Hell if it were our Declaration, Constitution, and Bill or Rights, well, they have been in protective enclosures of one form or another since the 1920s or so. If the Yangs's documents were similarly preserved, they could have spent the first two thousand years after the war in the same type of hermetically-sealed enclosures. So it is a reasonable conjecture that they could survive and one does not need some random Earth ship* to make a small universe flyby to explain their existence.


*(The Philadelphia, really? That's cheesier than the Omega Glory ending.)
 
Yeah, like nuBSG having "All Along The Watchtower" spontaneously be written both on Earth and the Twelve Colonies. ;)

It's been forever since I've seen the last two seasons of BSG, but if I'm remembering right, the implication was that All Along The Watchtower is a memory implanted in the Thirteenth Tribe that later resurfaced on Earth.
 
It's been forever since I've seen the last two seasons of BSG, but if I'm remembering right, the implication was that All Along The Watchtower is a memory implanted in the Thirteenth Tribe that later resurfaced on Earth.

Genetic memory? I've heard of it. I thought that it had been debunked? :confused:
 
...Nor the first time some ancient mumbo-jumbo actually turned out to be how the world really works, as a modern approximation, even if in between was a period of relative infamy. Perhaps there's something to it after all? I mean, science still has zero idea why a pike knows how to swim the moment it is born, but an otter doesn't (and never will unless taught), even though the lives of both depend on it. Where within the single originating cell does the skill of swimming reside, exactly?

Of course, if we learn this, we can program the complete works of Frank Miller into our Thirteenth Tribe for shits and giggles. Heck, even if we merely strive to learn this, we'll get to the programming bit eventually. No need for "genetic memory" in the sense of "Oh, all the global deluge myths originate from the Med breaking its barriers and flooding about a million years before anybody knew how to write it down or even had a chance to meet enough kinsmen to pass the knowledge on in the form of poems, grunts or hand gestures". What we get in nuBSG could still be a good portrayal of the built-in potential of our nature, as suitably adjusted by technology.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Although not a true parallel Earth story, I went with "Paradise Syndrome" for the Preservers angle.

If I were to vote for any others, it would be:

"Miri" for the darker, spookier edge to the story mentioned earlier.

"Bread and Circuses" for 'modern Romans' televising gladitorial fights!

"Piece of the Action" just for the fun the actors seem to be having!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top