What I'm saying is this: it's bad enough when Trek writers go into fan mode about Trek characters. It's positively ridiculous to import a character from another tv show and do the same thing.
I'm not quite sure what you're going for here, but I suspect you're talking about Hugh Cambridge and comparing him to Gregory House. That's not quite accurate. Cambridge is more inspired by Hugh Laurie in general than that character exclusively. Certainly there are some similarities to Dr. House, but Cambridge is a distinct character, nowhere near as antisocial and maladjusted, much better at respecting authority (otherwise he never would've made it in Starfleet), and much more capable of entering into an emotional relationship with another person. And, of course, English-accented.
And other original characters in Trek Lit have been inspired by earlier screen characters or actors. Captain Gold in S.C.E./Corps of Engineers was basically Col. Potter from M*A*S*H, but Jewish. And when Keith DeCandido hired me to write the S.C.E. story introducing Commander Tev, the brief he gave me for the character was "Charles Emerson Winchester the Tellarite" (after David Ogden Stiers' M*A*S*H character). There was a character on the Sagittarius crew in Vanguard who was basically Jack Black. And of course, the entire book Articles of the Federation was an extended homage to The West Wing.
There were also a couple of characters in one of the Vanguard books where were more or less Trek versions of main characters from Clerks.I'm not quite sure what you're going for here, but I suspect you're talking about Hugh Cambridge and comparing him to Gregory House. That's not quite accurate. Cambridge is more inspired by Hugh Laurie in general than that character exclusively. Certainly there are some similarities to Dr. House, but Cambridge is a distinct character, nowhere near as antisocial and maladjusted, much better at respecting authority (otherwise he never would've made it in Starfleet), and much more capable of entering into an emotional relationship with another person. And, of course, English-accented.
And other original characters in Trek Lit have been inspired by earlier screen characters or actors. Captain Gold in S.C.E./Corps of Engineers was basically Col. Potter from M*A*S*H, but Jewish. And when Keith DeCandido hired me to write the S.C.E. story introducing Commander Tev, the brief he gave me for the character was "Charles Emerson Winchester the Tellarite" (after David Ogden Stiers' M*A*S*H character). There was a character on the Sagittarius crew in Vanguard who was basically Jack Black. A
nd of course, the entire book Articles of the Federation was an extended homage to The West Wing.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.