• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Very Dark "Family" Christmas shows

the G-man

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Based on this thread, I got thinking about Christmas shows or specials that, while ostensibly for kids/the family, had really dark or disturbing elements.

While the king of these might be "It's a Wonderful Life" (if that counts as a 'family' flim), I hadn't seen it until I was in college. When I was a kid, these are specials that kind of freaked me out.

The Little Drummer Boy: Creepy puppets, murdered parents, dead animals and the baby Jesus bringing said dead animals back, Lazarus style.

The Littlest Angel: Much like "Casper," this story is--when you get right down to it--about a dead kid. But, unlike Casper, they start the movie off with the kid dying (and going to heaven) and then have a scene or two where the little dead boy returns to earth and discovers he's invisible to his grieving mom. To make matters worse, I figured out within a few seconds that the "teacher" angel was...Herman Munster.

The House without a Christmas Tree: This was about a young girl whose mother had died and whose father now refused to let her have a tree because of the memories it brought back to him. It was a moving story, but incredibly sad. And the dad was played by Jason Robards, who is always a little scary.

A Christmas Carol (1971 cartoon): Of course, every version of this is a 'ghost story.' But this version (which won an Academy) had a distinctive visual style (and voice work by Allister Sim) that made it especially dark for an ostensibly kid-oriented cartoon. And their version of Jacob Marley was no guy in a bandage in simple bandage. He was a deformed, screaming, banshee.

Any one else?

(And please, no "Black Christmas," "the Ref," "Bad Santa" or other overtly adult stuff. I'm talking about stuff FOR KIDS/FAMILIES)
 
The Little Match Girl. I remember watching a filmstrip of this each year in elementary school, and it is very depressing. A poor child from an abusive home dies of hypothermia because she is unable to sell her daily quota of matches.
 
The Little Match Girl. I remember watching a filmstrip of this each year in elementary school, and it is very depressing. A poor child from an abusive home dies of hypothermia because she is unable to sell her daily quota of matches.

Yeah, I vaguely remember that film strip also.
 
There was also an animated version of "Carol" from the late sixties on CBS that was, while not as well-animated, also notable for having some pretty creepy ghosts.
 
It's a Wonderful Life is actually pretty dark- for most of the movie, the main character is trying to top himself.
 
...and before that he's embittered, conflicted about his relationship with his wife and family, and in one scene beaten as a child. Really, until the last scene, the film is almost a tragedy.
 
"Lifetime" channel is full of this crap for the Christmas season - broken families, messed-up relationships and the parade of ubiquitous evil insensitive white males who are unapologetically used as plot devices for causing all the problems in the first place. I guess the endings are supposed to be uplifting but...Feh...
 
Based on this thread, I got thinking about Christmas shows or specials that, while ostensibly for kids/the family, had really dark or disturbing elements......

A Christmas Carol (1971 cartoon): Of course, every version of this is a 'ghost story.' But this version (which won an Academy) had a distinctive visual style (and voice work by Allister Sim) that made it especially dark for an ostensibly kid-oriented cartoon. And their version of Jacob Marley was no guy in a bandage in simple bandage. He was a deformed, screaming, banshee.

Any one else?

(And please, no "Black Christmas," "the Ref," "Bad Santa" or other overtly adult stuff. I'm talking about stuff FOR KIDS/FAMILIES)

I remember that cartoon Christmas Carol, or at least, I remember cowering behind the sofa until Marley's Ghost was gone. It scared me senseless!
scared0016.gif
 
One Magic Christmas, as my thread on it was the inspiration for this thread. You forgot the link ;)

Is that the one with Harry Dean Stanton as an angel who was once a cowboy? Always liked that one cos of him. Dunno if I'd want to revisit it now, though, since these things never live up to the memory...
 
The Little Match Girl. I remember watching a filmstrip of this each year in elementary school, and it is very depressing. A poor child from an abusive home dies of hypothermia because she is unable to sell her daily quota of matches.

This. Is this anything to be showing a first grader? I think not. :evil:
 
One Magic Christmas, as my thread on it was the inspiration for this thread. You forgot the link ;)

Is that the one with Harry Dean Stanton as an angel who was once a cowboy? Always liked that one cos of him. Dunno if I'd want to revisit it now, though, since these things never live up to the memory...


Yeah, see the thread I made for my comments on it. Basically, it's still a good movie after all these years, it's just that the heavy stuff seems really heavy for a Christmas movie and hits me harder as an adult.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top