• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TV Picard > Movie Picard : Prove me wrong

Which Picard was better


  • Total voters
    26

PCz911

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
Sorry for the click bait title. But on the Nemesis is better than Insurrection thread the discussion turned to the change in the character of Picard from the tv shows to the movies. What was observed was His transition from erudite intellectual to action man. And I was curious if that was a common perception or if it was just we few, we happy few, who thought that way
 
Sometimes I think we need a ban on often repeated topics.

Anyway, no Picard going all action man doesn't bother me much. He was a bit of a wild child in his youth, and from personal experience, some people when they get older revert to traits from their younger days. Probably more thought put in here than anything Stewart or any of the writers did, but what is Star Trek if not retconing persevering?
 
Sorry for the click bait title. But on the Nemesis is better than Insurrection thread the discussion turned to the change in the character of Picard from the tv shows to the movies. What was observed was His transition from erudite intellectual to action man. And I was curious if that was a common perception or if it was just we few, we happy few, who thought that way
While I think TV Picard was better done in TNG, this idea that he was just an intellectual is also a mistake. He did his action hero bit in "Starship Mine," and goes on an intelligence operation in Chain of Command. I think both can fit, and part of later seasons of TNG was showcasing some of that, including The Gambit.

The films went off the rails for me with buggy scene in Nemesis and the fight scene in Insurrection at the end.
Sometimes I think we need a ban on often repeated topics.

Anyway, no Picard going all action man doesn't bother me much. He was a bit of a wild child in his youth, and from personal experience, some people when they get older revert to traits from their younger days. Probably more thought put in here than anything Stewart or any of the writers did, but what is Star Trek if not retconing persevering?
I mean, we're Star Trek fans. We're going to talk on topics that interest us, including the repetitive ones.
 
The more well informed folks on this forum mentioned this to me. Like Craig in the Bond series, giving too much creative power to actors is not always a good thing.
Giving Patrick Stewart more creative control was only half of what worked against Movie Picard. The other half was the direction the film industry was going in overall. They were going to make the movies more action-oriented no matter what. Combine that with Patrick Stewart's demands and Action-Hero Movie Picard was born.
 
Giving Patrick Stewart more creative control was only half of what worked against Movie Picard. The other half was the direction the film industry was going in overall. They were going to make the movies more action-oriented no matter what. Combine that with Patrick Stewart's demands and Action-Hero Movie Picard was born.
The film industry direction played a role, but it was mostly Stewart's demands. Contact came out in 1997, right in between FC and INS. There was still a market for good, intelligent sci-fi that didn't rely on action.
 
Contact came out in 1997, right in between FC and INS. There was still a market for good, intelligent sci-fi that didn't rely on action.
Yes, I know. But I think Paramount wanted to pigeonhole the Star Trek movies into a specific lane. Especially after TMP wasn't loved and they didn't want to make another comedy like TVH.
 
The more well informed folks on this forum mentioned this to me. Like Craig in the Bond series, giving too much creative power to actors is not always a good thing.
If Craig is responsible for those movies in any way beyond acting, more power to him. :techman:
 
all good things ends with picard joining the poker game, closing the distance he had been still been keeping with officers he had considered friends for years.

then generations happens, and he has a mid-life crisis afterwards, and having less regard for his personal safety, at least, so starts blasting at things and ignoring the prime directive to drive a shiny new car around :p
 
all good things ends with picard joining the poker game, closing the distance he had been still been keeping with officers he had considered friends for years.

then generations happens, and he has a mid-life crisis afterwards, and having less regard for his personal safety, at least, so starts blasting at things and ignoring the prime directive to drive a shiny new car around :p
When you put it THAT way……😜
 
Agreed.
I get so tired with people insisting that fictional characters should stay exactly the same through out the entire run of a show and/or movies. People change in real life, so should fictional characters.
But that's the point. This isn't real life. We get enough real life in... real life. People go to the movies to get an escape from real life, and in the 1990's when people were showing up to see a TNG movie, they wanted to see the characters they knew and loved from TNG. It's the same kind of thing as Sulu and Chekov still being at the helm and navigation consoles after decades. It would make no damn sense in real life, but people wanted to see a movie with those same people at their familiar posts. And I have no problem with that.
 
But that's the point. This isn't real life. We get enough real life in... real life. People go to the movies to get an escape from real life, and in the 1990's when people were showing up to see a TNG movie, they wanted to see the characters they knew and loved from TNG. It's the same kind of thing as Sulu and Chekov still being at the helm and navigation consoles after decades. It would make no damn sense in real life, but people wanted to see a movie with those same people at their familiar posts. And I have no problem with that.

I disagree. They were still the same people. They just changed because of experiences.
I've got AuDHD, meaning there is a shit ton of autism in me. If someone like me, that hates different circumstances, can accept that fictional characters change, 'normal' people (neurotyicapals) certainly can.
Fuck it, Chekov still being at the helm after 30 years is just bad writing. And he wasn't. He was simply a commander with a very different posting who was asked to go on a mission where he was at the helm. In TMP he wasn't at the helm, he was a tactical officer. That is called character development/
 
While I didn't like TMP I did like seeing different characters in different roles. TUC probably did this the best in some degree with Sulu a captain, Chekov as security and anticipated retirement.
 
Either way, the character has aged poorly. Hoping we never see Stewart again on Trek TV/movies.
 
Either way, the character has aged poorly. Hoping we never see Stewart again on Trek TV/movies.
I know Picard season 3 is much derided around here, but for me personally I thought it did a good job of rectifying much of the damage of Nemesis. I was glad to see the cast back and I am glad they did it.

That being said, I think TNG's time is over. They had their reunion and their last hurrah. I would agree that we don't need to see those characters in Trek TV or movies again.
 
But that's the point. This isn't real life. We get enough real life in... real life. People go to the movies to get an escape from real life, and in the 1990's when people were showing up to see a TNG movie, they wanted to see the characters they knew and loved from TNG. It's the same kind of thing as Sulu and Chekov still being at the helm and navigation consoles after decades. It would make no damn sense in real life, but people wanted to see a movie with those same people at their familiar posts. And I have no problem with that.

I really understand and agree with what you're saying here. I really do. I've been saying for decades that almost all movies released after the early 2000s were way, WAY too dark, gritty and serious. In the 90s we had some pretty heavy movie releases, but they were balanced out by fun and campy ones, and some films (I use Independence Day here but Jurassic Park or The Fifth Element work just as well) managed to balance hopeless disaster with overly cheesy fun. I have yet to see a movie in the post 2000s era that approaches the fun of what the 90s classics were capable of. Marvel comes kinda close, Star Trek 2009, again, kinda close. But most movie audiences want as you would put it, "real life in their movies". I don't. I go to the theater to escape from the burning, dying embers of society we currently are living in. And the last thing I wanna see is desperation, hopelessness, war, or even worse, TeRrOrIsM just for the sake of it.

Now with Picard, I also agree, you may be onto something here. I love First Contact because it was a great movie, and because Picard vs the Borg seems like the likeliest way to get melodrama dragged out of him. But I will also gladly admit that the other 3 movies should have had less action hero Picard and more thoughtful Picard. Maybe it's the way the writers and actors and director handled it, but most of the TNG movies seem to me at face value to be in-character, even if they aren't. Someone posted in this thread or another one that the TNG movies were handled like family reunions and everyone was just having fun. At the end of the day, that much is evident, and it makes it easier to sit back and enjoy the film, as ridiculous as it might be. After all, it was the 90s...surely the best of times.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top