• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

TOS movies: Lacking a certain sense of the bizarre?

I like the TOS films for what they are, but I feel that in most cases they really miss the sense of otherworldly adventure that had to have been a major selling point of the series [...]

Am I alone in feeling this?

As an Artist, myself, I definitely understand what you're trying to say, here. In a curious way, having the ca$h to blow on a project takes the fun out of it. If you don't have the budget for a commercial film, you have to go Artsy with it. But ...

Once you've got the budget to go commercial, the urge to be Artsy doesn't go out the window, necessarily ... it's just going the path of least resistance to throw money at a problem. If you can easily afford the life-sized T-Rex robot, then that's what you're going to get. That's when the Artsyness sort of shifts from the obvious to the subtle, because now, it's all in the details. Instead of trying to figure out how to suggest a T-Rex with shadows and keeping things mysterious, you can now present yourself, properly In a way that can be universally understood.

See, I think that's it. Going Artsy is a bit of a risk. You think you're doing good things, but it comes off funny, or weird, or pretentious. When you're after their money, it's not such a bad idea to keep things more-or-less straightforward. I mean, yeah, you budget for ILM, but to get the most bang for the buck, there can't be any ambiguity. It can be a made-up thing, like a Ceti Eel, but it's got to remind people of something living. It can't come off as an Artistic bent, like Disney's "Fantasia" or whatever else, like that ...
 
I always felt that "Star Trek VI" has some great "moments" that resonate like when you first saw the original TV episodes.....When Kirk and Bones are trailing Martia who is shapeshifting as they move and Kirk looks dumbfounded....that scene looked like (In my mind) almost like Kirk and McCoy on the same set as the original Captain Pike in "The Cage". The Kirk vs. Kirk fight reminded me of the craziness from "That Which Survives"....
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top