• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Thunder of the Gods (Electrical Cosmology)

cyph

Captain
Captain
First of all, here's a link to the video giving a high-level overview of what Electrical/Plasma cosmology is: Link

Anyways... if you keep an open mind (and I do mean OPEN), then this is quite an entertaining theory. Plausible in my book... but maybe it's because I'm an electrical engineer... However, let's just say that fundamental cosmology IS wrong, that relativity isn't exactly right... I mean, with all the conceptual variables in things like string theory, why couldn't plasma cosmology be just as if not more valid?

I'll be putting my Holographic Universe book to the side for now while I look up for some literature on this...

:-D
 
What's the book? Have you read any of the 'quantum/holographic consciousness' stuff?

Have you come across the 'Tiller-Einstein theory of space/time'? which addresses some of the anomoalies in relativity?
 
Last edited:
What's the book? Have you read any of the 'quantum/holographic consciousness' stuff?

Have you come across the 'Tiller-Einstein theory of space/time'? which addresses some of the anomoalies in relativity?

I'm working on finishing up Briane Greene's Fabric of the Cosmos... I got the book "Holographic Universe", but haven't had the time to crack it open. :lol:

Honestly, when it comes to books, i'm hella A.D.D. about it! I get a quarter way in, then another book shines to my eyes and I ditch my last book to look at the next... *sigh*
 
Anyways... if you keep an open mind (and I do mean OPEN), then this is quite an entertaining theory.

Thanks for posting this - I'd never heard of plasma cosmology and I did find it interesting, though unconvincing ("entertaining" is a good word choice). I wasn't personally able to verify or disprove anything the first half of the video, so it was fun enough. But about halfway through, they start talking about the Sun.

Those in the video are very impressed that the Sun's corona is so much hotter than the surface and suggest that the "extra energy" must therefore come from the galaxy itself. However, they fail to point out that the corona is only one-billionth as dense as the surface region (photosphere), and while there's uncertainty as to the exact mechanism of energy transfer from surface to corona, no "energy from the galaxy" is needed.

Then they go on about how sunspots allow one to see into the interior of the Sun, but sunspots are dark, and thus the interior of the Sun must be cold. Um, no. Sunspots are regions where magnetic activity impedes convection from the interior and are thus deprived of the heat from the interior and are therefore relatively colder (and thus relatively darker, though still blindingly bright).

Those two items (which seem like willful ignorance) were enough to call their entire scientific discussion into serious question. I also looked up David Talbott, the head of this group. He's apparently a follower of Velikovsky's ideas, which was a big, red flag on its own. But even the other Velikovskians seem to reject him. His previous big idea before this one, "The Saturn Myth," was pretty soundly disproved, so it looks like he and his group have moved on to greener pastures by stirring mythology, plasma cosmology, quantum physics, and whatever else was on the shelf into "Thunderbolts of the Gods."

Playing around with mythology is fine, even to the point of bringing in science to explain some of it. But it's a mistake to use mythology to reinterpret science (that leads to things like the laughable "Young Earth creationism"). Science already has a mechanism in place for new ideas: journals and peer review. That's the route which those attached to this project should be following. But instead, they only seem interested in selling their DVDs and books to the public (which is fine if they're sold as mythology/science fiction but not if sold as science).
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top