• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Theory: The weapons that burned Owen and Beru Lars down to skeletons were simply blasters

Unimatrix Q

Commodore
Commodore
Considering that the attack on the homestead was meant to look like being the work of the Tusken, who neither own nor use flamethrowers and especially not disintegrators, and we don't see both kind of weapons in the Sandtroopers arsenal for this mission, the most likely weapon that caused the condition of Owen and Beru's corpses are blasters.

Blasters were shown to be able to turn people into charred corpses a short time later in ANH, when we see Han shoot Greedo in the Mos Eisley cantina. Perhaps another reason for this scene, beside giving him a reason to travel with Obi Wan and Luke to Alderaan.

And why would Sandtroopers, trying to imitate a Tusken raid, give their victims a funeral? We never seen or heard about them doing this anywhere.

And simply burning along with the homestead also doesn't make sense, because the corpses lay outside and not in one of the destroyed rooms of the moisture farm.

And people often forget that George hadn't the idea of stormtroopes using thermal detonators, flamethrowers or disintegrators when he made ANH or at least didn't introduced them at this point. The only hand weapons we see anyone use in the movie are blasters, gaffi sticks and lightsabers.

So i think highly powered blaster fire from more than one Stormtrooper was the most likely cause for Owen and Beru Lars becoming charred skeletons.

At least that was most likely the reason George Lucas had in mind, when he created the first movie.

Edit: Edited with aditional text because there are more things to consider.
 
Last edited:
Considering that the attack on the homestead was meant to look like being the work of the Tusken
It was? That wasn't stated in the film. The attack on the Jawas was intended to look like it was by the Sand People. But I don't recall Luke encountering any evidence of a Sand People attack at his homestead.
 
It was? That wasn't stated in the film. The attack on the Jawas was intended to look like it was by the Sand People. But I don't recall Luke encountering any evidence of a Sand People attack at his homestead.

I think it's logical to assume, because they made the attack on the sandcrawler seem like a work of them.

I thought it was always meant to be blasters anyway?

Whenever this theme comes up in discussions, most people seem to assume the Sandtroopers used flamethrowers, thermal detonators or disintegrators.

And some of them frame Boba Fett killing them with one of these weapons ;)
 
Was pretty brutal for Stormtroopers. Usually a blaster shot and left for dead, Owen and Beru were nearly desintigrated....so yeah could be the work of Fett.

In hindsight I am surprised they weren't taken into custody and taken to a Star Destroyer to be interrogated more thoroughly.
 
Pretty sure this was the weapon responsible.

As for the why: -
In-universe, it's probably the same reason they slaughtered the Jawas and burnt out the sandcrawler; because they were destroying all possible trace of the plans. Sure, they could spend hours and hours going over the place with a fine tooth comb, making sure no extra copies have been made and stashed somewhere . . . or they could just torch the whole joint and the people with it. Job done!
Framing the Tuskens just makes for fewer complications if any other locals start poking around. It's a small planet. Word gets around. Better that they not ask too many questions they could make it look like the Empire managed to let a group of rebels steal highly sensitive military secrets from one of their most secure facilities. As a general rule, totalitarian regimes don't like to admit to any kind of failure, or appearance of weakness and will go to enormous lengths to supress it.

Out-of-universe, it's because George really wanted to visually quote this rather iconic image from 'The Searchers'.
 
Last edited:
The Lars were roasted by a light sabre.

Obi Wan literally had to severe the connections to Luke's family, before he could take Luke to Aalderan for training.

Although...

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Owen knew who he married.
 
Last edited:
Pretty sure this was the weapon responsible.

As for the why: -
In-universe, it's probably the same reason they slaughtered the Jawas and burnt out the sandcrawler; because they were destroying all possible trace of the plans. Sure, they could spend hours and hours going over the place with a fine tooth comb, making sure no extra copies have been made and stashed somewhere . . . or they could just torch the whole joint and the people with it. Job done!
Framing the Tuskens just makes for fewer complications if any other locals start poking around. It's a small planet. Word gets around. Better that they not ask too many questions they could make it look like the Empire managed to let a group of rebels steal highly sensitive military secrets from one of their most secure facilities. As a general rule, totalitarian regimes don't like to admit to any kind of failure, or appearance of weakness and will go to enormous lengths to supress it.

Out-of-universe, it's because George really wanted to visually quote this rather iconic image from 'The Searchers'.

But why didn't they burn the Jawas themselves in this case, considering that they did this to the couple?
 
Maybe Robot Chicken was onto something in their skit about Vader ordering Owen and Beru to be burned in retaliation to the "little orphan Ani" joke they made just after Shmi died?
 
But why didn't they burn the Jawas themselves in this case, considering that they did this to the couple?
Because nobody is going to examine the bodies of Jawas to see if they were killed by blasters or gaderffii sticks (probably not even other Jawas.) Fire destroys evidence.

And again, real world reason: smoking skeletons are way less horrific to show than actual recognisable corpses.
 
My idea was that Boba Fett killed them after being beaten half to death by Lars. I would have Lars played by John Lithgow who is as tall as Jason Momoa. He shoves his wife down turns around and gets the flamethrower. Boba in an uncontrolled rage from being bested by a hillbilly finishes the compound with his rocket launcher.
 
It's my belief that the Emperor never lost track of Luke, and never lost track of either sets of Death Star plans.

Shiv needed luke to be a broken Jedi who would lose it, fumble, and then the Emperor could live youthfuly for another century in young Skywalker's soul hole.

The Death Star was bait for a trap.
 
Whatever the weapons were, they effectively killed 1.4 million people.
Owen...
Beru...
And everyone on that Death Star.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top