The Now-Official TNG Hurt/Heal Game: Season Two

[Michael]

Now we're finished with the first season, I take the liberty to post the thread for season two. Hope everyone's okay with that.

Here's the ranking of the first season:

1st: Conspiracy
2nd: 11001001
3rd: The Arsenal of Freedom
4th: Where No One Has Gone Before
5th: The Big Goodbye
6th: Hide and Q
7th: Symbiosis
8th: Heart of Glory
9th: Datalore
10th: The Neutral Zone
11th: The Battle
12th: Coming of Age
13th: Lonely Among Us
14th: The Last Outpost
15th: Encounter at Farpoint, Part 2
16th: Encounter at Farpoint, Part 1
17th: Too Short a Season
18th: Home Soil
19th: We'll Always Have Paris
20th: Skin of Evil
21st: Haven
22nd: When the Bough Breaks
23rd: The Naked Now
24th: Angel One
25th: Code of Honor
26th: Justice

On to the new round ...

________________________________________________

The Rules

• Each episode starts on 10 points.
• 1 Vote every calander day per member.
• On each vote you must both:
• Heal your favorite story + 1
• & Hurt your least favorite stoy -2
• (You cannot hurt without healing or vice versa)
• Once an episode reaches zero it's out
• Episodes are ranked in order of elimination
• Please indicate which episoes you have voted for

________________________________________________

Season Two:

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 10
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 10
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 10
The Royale 10
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 10
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 10
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 10
Shades of Gray 10

 

[Michael]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 10
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 10
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 10
The Royale 10
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 10
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 10
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11 +
Shades of Gray 8 -

 

[cultcross]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11 +
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 10
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 10
The Royale 10
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 10
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8 -
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11
Shades of Gray 8

Looking at that list, I'd forgotten how awful season 2 was. This should be a fun round. prediction:
Measure of a Man by ~100

 

[Jadzia]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11+
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 10
The Royale 8-
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 10
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11
Shades of Gray 8

 

[Bosch571]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 10
The Royale 8
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 11 +
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11
Shades of Gray 6 -

 

[Garth Rockett]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 10
The Royale 8
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 12 +
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11
Shades of Gray 4 -

 

[ZMistress]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 12 +
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 10
The Royale 8
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 12
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11
Shades of Gray 2 -

 

[Defcon]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 13 +
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 10
The Royale 8
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 12
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray -

 

[Geck]

prediction: Measure of a Man by ~100

I dunno, I think it'll be a close two-way race between Measure of a Man and Q Who.

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 13
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 11 +
The Royale 6 -
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 12
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray

 

[erastus25]

I'm starting the Q Who push early!

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11 -
The Dauphin 10
Contagion 11
The Royale 6
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 13 +
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray[/quote]

 

[Captain Kate]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 8 -
Contagion 11
The Royale 6
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 10
Q Who? 14 +
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 6 -
Contagion 11
The Royale 6
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 11 +
Q Who? 14
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray

 

[KeepOnTrekking]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 8-
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 6
Contagion 11
The Royale 6
Time Squared 10
The Icarus Factor 10
Pen Pals 11
Q Who? 15+
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray

 

[Orac]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 10
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 6
Contagion 11
The Royale 6
Time Squared 11 +
The Icarus Factor 8 -
Pen Pals 11
Q Who? 14
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray

 

[Holdfast]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 11 +
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 4 -
Contagion 11
The Royale 6
Time Squared 11
The Icarus Factor 8
Pen Pals 11
Q Who? 14
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray

 

[Mallory]

I dunno, I think it'll be a close two-way race between Measure of a Man and Q Who.

I agree. Q Who? won the last time, but who's to say that the result won't be different this time around? Those are definitely the two best episodes of the season, IMO.

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 11
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 10
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 2 -
Contagion 11
The Royale 6
Time Squared 11
The Icarus Factor 8
Pen Pals 11
Q Who? 15 +
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray

 

[Defcon]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 11
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 11 +
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 2
Contagion 11
The Royale 4 -
Time Squared 11
The Icarus Factor 8
Pen Pals 11
Q Who? 15
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 11

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray

 

[Michael]

The Child 10
Where Silence Has Lease 11
Elementary, Dear Data 11
The Outrageous Okona 10
Loud As A Whisper 10
The Schizoid Man 10
Unnatural Selection 10
A Matter Of Honor 11
The Measure Of A Man 11
The Dauphin 2
Contagion 11
The Royale 2 -
Time Squared 11
The Icarus Factor 8
Pen Pals 11
Q Who? 15
Samaritan Snare 10
Up The Long Ladder 10
Manhunt 8
The Emissary 10
Peak Performance 12 +

Eliminated:
22nd: Shades of Gray

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Just an AD:

If anyones interested:Hurt/Heal Game: Best Voyager Episode: Season 1

is now running in the Voyager forum.
Ive not done one for DS9, as I dont know much about it and would not get as much enjoyment from it, but if anyone is in the mood ........... (Ill vote) and perhaps all the H/H tread results for TOS, TNG, Voyager etc can combine as a final. final ?

 

[Defcon]

Just an AD:

If anyones interested:Hurt/Heal Game: Best Voyager Episode: Season 1

is now running in the Voyager forum.
Ive not done one for DS9, as I dont know much about it and would not get as much enjoyment from it, but if anyone is in the mood ........... (Ill vote) and perhaps all the H/H tread results for TOS, TNG, Voyager etc can combine as a final. final ?

Looking at the Who's online site I think NCC-1701 is creating a DS9 hurt/heal thread right now. Not that I'm a stalker or anything.

*Hides behind a bush to wait for someone else to stalk*