• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Legacy of Liz Sladen

I agree that first scene is awkward and artificial but, for me, it's worth it because then we get this scene:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

I still get teary-eyed every time I watch it. Yes, it's geared towards the Old School Fans but this scene hits all of the right notes.

When I first watched that scene I'm 99% sure I'd never seen any Classic Who story with Sarah Jane, but it still gave me goosebumps just based off of how its written, acted and filmed.
 
It's weird. The super-young Tennant in Series 2 doesn't look "right" to my anymore.

The clip also reminded me of how much I disliked the scene because of how artificial it felt. The first teacher Sarah introduces herself to just happens to be the Doctor, she just happens to muse about her Doctors when he says his name is "John Smith." It's a scene written for the audience, especially the Old School Fans, and not for the characters inside the dramatic moment.

I don't mean to harsh on "School Reunion." As a fan who grew up with a childhood crush on Lis Sladen, I loved it. I'm not sure it's actually a good episode, though.
As an episode, it's not my favorite. But SJS elevates her parts of it. And K9. And her interaction with Mickey.
 
The official Doctor Who channel has been posting a lot of Sarah Jane Smith stuff ever since this thread was posted.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Sarah Jane......I think a lot of people love her and she was one of the best travelling companions the Doctor had. Unforgettable
 
I've been thinking about the upcoming Big Finish audios with the tenth Doctor and Rani, and it would be really interesting to me if these audios took place, for Rani, after Sarah Jane's death. The tenth Doctor had just relatively recently in his timeline had an adventure with Sarah Jane and a teen Rani ("Journey's End" or "The Wedding of Sarah Jane Smith"), and now he's having an adventure with an older Rani.

The Doctor knows that their companions have short lives, and traveling in time and space will take him into times and places where companions are dead, and I'd kind of like to see... well, hear Tennant play the Doctor's grief at knowing that one of his best friends is gone. He's known this day would come, he undoubtedly knew when and where and how it happened, and now it's in front of him in a way he can't deny. I feel that would add more poignancy to the Sarah Jane cameo in "The End of Time."

I hope there's more than just three. I'd love for Ten and Rani to deal with Dhawan's Master, as much timeline spaghetti as that would be!
 
Damn, I hadn't heard about those upcoming Big Finish audios. That will certainly be a lot of fun to listen to and I agree that it would be a fascinating if they're set after Sarah Jane's death for both of them.

I would also love to see Rani meet Dhawan's Master. :D
 
Honestly, I think I would have preferred the 14th Doctor and Rani, but I imagine that's off limits.
Yes, and also yes. Fourteen would be better (because then Dhawan becomes less messy as the Master, and, honestly, Fourteen is basically a blank slate), and Fourteen and Fifteen are almost certainly off-limits to Big Finish.
 
Yes, and also yes. Fourteen would be better (because then Dhawan becomes less messy as the Master, and, honestly, Fourteen is basically a blank slate), and Fourteen and Fifteen are almost certainly off-limits to Big Finish.
10/14 - think anyone will really notice? :evil:
 
I suppose it's possible the audios are Officially Ten, but there's enough wiggle room that someone could hear them as Fourteen. Would Rani even recognize the difference? She'd just assume he had different clothes, and while the TARDIS interior would be vastly different she might know that it can change; maybe Sarah Jane talked to her and Clyde about what the Console Room looked like in her say. Maybe.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top