• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Final Days of "Star Trek: The Next Generation"

As much as I adore TNG and part of me wishes it could have continued forever (or at least until season 8), the more logical and detached side of me acknowledges that it absolutely needed to end in season 7 based on how the quality of the episodes were. Season 7 felt closer to season 1 and 2 in that there were a couple of great episodes sprinkled throughout an otherwise thoroughly mediocre and unimpressive season. I'd even go so far as to say I much prefer season 1 to season 7 (possibly a controversial opinion). So many of the episode premises in season 7 had me shaking my head and thinking "Really, guys?" Lower Decks and The Pegasus really were two of the only truly standout episodes (the latter being in my top 10 favourite TNG episodes).
 
I have had something of an epiphany regarding my own opinions. Granted, this is a "hindsight is 20/20" kinda deal, but still, hear me out:

Star Trek: The Next Generation should neve have been cancelled and replaced by a film series.

Why? Because obviously the TNG movies are almost unanimously controversial and at least 3/4 of them are critically panned, to say nothing of the fact that only one of them did any good at the box office. Now I'm discovering that Generations contributed negatively to the lack of good episodes in Season 7, which again was because of the movie that was coming out in less than a year after the finale. I honestly feel sorry for the cast and crew of the show, and if it weren't for Generations I'm absolutely 100% positive Season 7 would have been much better.

Granted, accommodations would have had to have been made, but I would gladly have accepted them. For example, Patrick Stewart and Brent Spiner both seemed ready to move on. You know what? LET THEM. Cut 'em loose like Tasha and Wesley, but have them return as guest stars from time to time. As for the plot for future seasons?

EASY:

Season 7 would end with an abridged 2-part episode version of Generations instead of All Good Things, where Picard has to get help from William Shatner as Captain Kirk, who he finds in the Nexus (make it a random anomaly instead of an effects-heavy energy ribbon) in order to stop Soran from blowing up the Veridian III star. This time Kirk rides off into the sunset, and the Enterprise-D is not destroyed. Maybe at the beginning of Season 8, promote Picard to Admiral and have him return to Earth to serve as an instructor at the Academy. Have Data take over at the Daystrom Institute, teaming up with Bruce Maddox to create more androids. Riker takes over command of the Enterprise, bring back Shelby as his first officer or make up a new character, and have someone take over Ops from Data (again, this could be a totally new character or an old one, take your pick). Have the show run concurrently with DS9, and maybe Voyager (in my head rewrite Voyager never happens, so there are always two Star Trek shows running concurrently, no more and no less). Make the show last through the Dominion War, depict the lives of the Enterprise-D crew and see what they have to face through a new lens (plus think of the DS9/TNG crossovers!), have Picard and Data come back every once in a while for guest appearances, but KEEP THE SHOW GOING. Maybe end it alongside DS9, heck go nuts and have it end AFTER, but no sooner. I'm sure it would have been much more successful than the TNG movie series was. And I kinda wish that it was our reality now that I'm thinking about it.
 
Like your idea just fine. If Voyager does happen, no need to turn it into TNG Lite because we have TNG Regular. So, they can have the show go the way it was originally meant to: Maquis tensions, resource deprivation, running out of photons/shuttles/deuterium/COFFEE!
 
Like your idea just fine. If Voyager does happen, no need to turn it into TNG Lite because we have TNG Regular. So, they can have the show go the way it was originally meant to: Maquis tensions, resource deprivation, running out of photons/shuttles/deuterium/COFFEE!

I'm beginning to see why they backed off.

It would made for mind-numbingly depressing TV. :(
 
I'm beginning to see why they backed off.

It would made for mind-numbingly depressing TV. :(

There was actually a really good YouTube video on that subject, about how in many ways Voyager was a great "comfort Trek" during the pandemic because of the same things that made it fall short of its potential. It actually made me see the direction the series went in a more positive light (they still should have promoted Harry, though).
 
I hate to believe now that when Jonathan Frakes originally asked to direct, they gave him the brush off. Like Sofia Coppola, he's been more successful behind the camera than in front of it.

Frakes is a competent director and the only one who directed the "good TNG" films IMO. First Contact hits all the right beats emotionally and is a true film, Insurrection isn't perfect for a lot of reasons but feels a lot more like TNG than either Generations or Nemesis. Frakes knew the characters and more importantly the actors playing them and did the best at constructing feature films for the series. It's too bad they didn't have him direct Nemesis as well, but he was likely wrongly blamed for the production failures in Insurrection despite the script and production values being the bigger issues.

I have no love for anything post Berman, as the writing from the episodes I've seen is atrocious, but if there was any way to actually help revive the true spirit of Trek in a new production, Frakes would be on the short list to direct the pilot/film.
 
As much as I adore TNG and part of me wishes it could have continued forever (or at least until season 8), the more logical and detached side of me acknowledges that it absolutely needed to end in season 7 based on how the quality of the episodes were. Season 7 felt closer to season 1 and 2 in that there were a couple of great episodes sprinkled throughout an otherwise thoroughly mediocre and unimpressive season. I'd even go so far as to say I much prefer season 1 to season 7 (possibly a controversial opinion). So many of the episode premises in season 7 had me shaking my head and thinking "Really, guys?" Lower Decks and The Pegasus really were two of the only truly standout episodes (the latter being in my top 10 favourite TNG episodes).

I actually believe S7 is light years worse than S1 and S2. Season 7 of TNG is one of the worst seasons in the franchise.

The only S7 episodes I really enjoyed were:
Gambit 1&2
Parallels
Lower Decks
Preemptive Strike
...All Good Things
 
Like your idea just fine. If Voyager does happen, no need to turn it into TNG Lite because we have TNG Regular. So, they can have the show go the way it was originally meant to: Maquis tensions, resource deprivation, running out of photons/shuttles/deuterium/COFFEE!

I agree about the Maquis tensions, resource deprivation, and running out of photons/shuttles/deuterium. But running out of coffee? Nah. The DQ is way too small for a really cranky Janeway. Several members of the crew wouldn't have survived that, much less those poor Kazon/Krenim/Borg/8472's/ you name it. The DQ would have been significantly depopulated after a few years.
 
I agree about the Maquis tensions, resource deprivation, and running out of photons/shuttles/deuterium. But running out of coffee? Nah. The DQ is way too small for a really cranky Janeway. Several members of the crew wouldn't have survived that, much less those poor Kazon/Krenim/Borg/8472's/ you name it. The DQ would have been significantly depopulated after a few years.

The whole series would be derailed into a never ending search for Coffee. By season 7 the Voyager would be a warship which Janeway uses to invade planets and search them for coffee or coffee-like substances. And every planet that fails to have any gets blown up.
 
Now I'm discovering that Generations contributed negatively to the lack of good episodes in Season 7, which again was because of the movie that was coming out in less than a year after the finale. I honestly feel sorry for the cast and crew of the show, and if it weren't for Generations I'm absolutely 100% positive Season 7 would have been much better.

I think Moore, Braga and Echevarria's episodes were always hit and miss, though in season 7 their output went more to the misses, I think that is mostly from Piller and Taylor being less focused due to Deep Space Nine and upcoming Voyager and probably some impact from Generations also pulling attention (though Moore and Braga had *a lot* of time to write the film).

Have the show run concurrently with DS9, and maybe Voyager (in my head rewrite Voyager never happens, so there are always two Star Trek shows running concurrently, no more and no less). Make the show last through the Dominion War, depict the lives of the Enterprise-D crew and see what they have to face through a new lens

TNG doing plots like the Klingons breaking the alliance with the Federation (for more than two episodes) and the Dominion War it would be a very different, I think probably too different show, too much from pretty utopian to pretty failed utopia.
 
As much as I adore TNG and part of me wishes it could have continued forever (or at least until season 8), the more logical and detached side of me acknowledges that it absolutely needed to end in season 7 based on how the quality of the episodes were. Season 7 felt closer to season 1 and 2 in that there were a couple of great episodes sprinkled throughout an otherwise thoroughly mediocre and unimpressive season. I'd even go so far as to say I much prefer season 1 to season 7 (possibly a controversial opinion). So many of the episode premises in season 7 had me shaking my head and thinking "Really, guys?" Lower Decks and The Pegasus really were two of the only truly standout episodes (the latter being in my top 10 favourite TNG episodes).

In hindsight, season 7 is pretty crappy. Seasons 1 and 2 still had that spirit of exploring space, by season 7 that concept was long gone, to the detriment of the series
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top