VFX tried to put a couple of LD's ships in but were told no:
https://twitter.com/esdi/status/1569438674852675584
Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 3x01 - "The Next Generation"
- Thread starter Commander Richard
- Start date
VFX tried to put a couple of LD's ships in but were told no:
https://twitter.com/esdi/status/1569438674852675584
Criminy. So many comments already. But just this: The bunk beds killed me dead.
I wonder if aside from the wine bottles (or there's any chance something from 2400 could be a "2401 vintage") there's anything in "The Star Gazer" and "Farewell" explicitly set in 2401? You'd almost have to shift season 1 to really early in 2399 to make it all fit.
That's one detail I wish I hadn't been spoiled by months ago
Last edited:
The main characters rarely have sufficient interplay throughout Picard.
Like the others, this one also suffers from trying to spin needless elements into what already smacks as another long-winded spin-off episode.
I'll watch the next one with fingers crossed again.
Yeah I think we have to assume season one was very early in 2399, and season two mid-to-late 2400. Rios says the Stargazer is a ship from the year 2400 when he's in jail, for what that's worth.
Well, it's Guy, so...
His point was superficial.
Her selfish right to comfort is not more important than the half million members of Star Fleet who grab for a side arm whenever they hear her name spoken aloud.
https://www.usbirthcertificates.com/articles/illegal-baby-names
In America today it is (mostly, state by state) illegal to name your child or file for a legal change of name to "7 of 9".
Although "Seven of Nine" would be perfectly acceptable.
Last edited:
It looks like CBS (or whoever) pulled Angry Joe's review of the episode, he and the others were being a little rough on its but not unreasonably so and I don't think they were using an excessive number of clips beyond what's expected in a review.
This kind of stuff need to really stop.
This kind of stuff need to really stop.
Okay, good. 2401 works a lot better than 2411. Mainly because the amount of time that's passed since TNG almost matches both in Picard and in Real Life.
And it makes "In the 25th Century... " more appropriate instead just being a variation of what TWOK did. It makes more sense because it's the first season to take place fully in the 25th Century, and 2401 is the first year of it. So we're getting a proper introduction to the new century (instead of the brief glimpse we get last season) as the characters themselves are entering it. In fact, it fits even better in PIC than it did in TWOK, looking at it like that, since TWOK takes place in the 2280s. Over there, the 23rd Century isn't starting, it's almost over!
At first I thought it was a bit much as well, but when Riker said that the ash was unusual it occurred to me that perhaps the aliens physiology is such that ANY phaser hit would reduce them to ash.
It may also be purposeful on their part in that they don't want to leave behind any identifiable remains.
So, I really enjoyed this episode. I give it an 8. I hope it turns out better than seasons 1 and 2, whose introductory episodes I think were also strong before those seasons hit turbulence.
I think this is a plausible explanation, and if true argues to me that i should maybe lend Matalas a little slack when I see things initially that seem a little "off" - maybe there is a good explanation beyond just that "it looks cool".
As for the action, only Beverly did any real action and other than over-pumping her shotgun phaser (which I blame more on the editor than the actor), all the real stunt work was probably handled by a stunt double. Riker and Picard didn't do much other than complain about being old and one elbow to the face, so I thought that was done well.
I like that there are closing credits (don't know if they will stick around). I have always disliked how Paramount+ jumps to commercial, and then only after the commercial break shows the closing credits. I always get lost expecting more of the episode, only to be tricked once again. The serialization doesn't help here either due to the sometimes lack of a clear ending point for a given week's episode.
I never liked PIC's theme song, it was always too bland. So I am liking the new credits much better this season.
I could actually do with less telegraphing, but I think they do set Picard's arc up with the talk about not needing a legacy. It might be that the "next next generation" is his or part of his legacy.
The US Army was officially founded before the US existed, so there is precedent.
TrekMovie's AllAccess Podcast pointed out (and I think they are right), that Beverly was probably reviewing old logs to figure out ways to hide from her pursuers. Picard hid from the Borg in BOBW by hiding in a nebula, just as Beverly does in this episode.
Well, for 1) she was very unhappy and apparently thinking about not being in Starfleet anymore already, and 2) if Picard and Riker show up, I think anyone (other than Clancy from Season 1 or Shaw) would immediately go with "you know, maybe I should go along with what these multiple universe saving Starfleet heroes are trying to do, in case it ends up saving everyone?" I know I would.
I can't remember "Making of the Atomic Bomb" well enough to confirm this, but by the time we got around to being ready to test the bomb, it was the military in charge of things and ordering the test to happen. So, it was in the best interest that the scientists be involved to minimize the chances of everyone dying. Not that there aren't ethical issues with their participation anyway, just that it wasn't the scientists really in charge anymore at that point.
Hmm, I don't have as much problem with the interior lighting as others seem to have. As for the exterior shots, I have always felt that while some of DIS's and PIC's earlier ship shots could be beautiful (often Discovery just hanging in space near some nebula), most of their space shots were ugly and indecipherable. I will take PIC s3 ship shots being a little flat and overlit over the disaster of earlier DIS/PIC shots any day.
I think there is a good reason for this, beyond just modern "cool" factor. At first, I too dismissed it as stupid for the same reason.
Anthony and Laurie from TrekMovie surmised that: given Matalas has said there will be fallout from the Dominion War, plus Beverly saying to trust no one, and her kid saying that the attackers have different faces, and Riker making a special point about the ash left behind - maybe the attackers are shapeshifters in some way (don't know why they seem to be wearing masks though). As we saw in DS9, shapeshifters are very hard to kill with conventional phasers or Klingon disruptors, so maybe Beverly retrofitted a more powerful "shotgun" style phaser rifle out of other parts. This would also explain why the phaser discharges so quickly after a limited number of "shots". It combines the output of many normal phaser beam emissions into one powerful shot.
I think this is a plausible explanation, and if true argues to me that i should maybe lend Matalas a little slack when I see things initially that seem a little "off" - maybe there is a good explanation beyond just that "it looks cool".
I actually like Raffi (and Rios, but he is gone) best out of the new characters. And I thought Hurd did great in all her scenes, so I am glad she is here.
As for the action, only Beverly did any real action and other than over-pumping her shotgun phaser (which I blame more on the editor than the actor), all the real stunt work was probably handled by a stunt double. Riker and Picard didn't do much other than complain about being old and one elbow to the face, so I thought that was done well.
I think they did get confirmation from higher ups. Riker mentioned that the Titan is one area where he still has some pull. I think Shaw just doesn't like them because he is straight-laced and they are loose cannons (to him). At least he doesn't have any real reason to be suspicious until Picard screws up the starbase designation, and that comes long after he is rude to them.
I think some of the best character writing can come from some characters coming off as bad/evil/terrible, then we find out over time that we haven't understood big aspects of their character/motivations/etc. that reveals what they are really like. I think this is likely what Shaw will be like. I think unsubtlety is ok here. A great example of this is Jack Bristow from season 1 of Alias. Going from terrible dad to misunderstood great dad over the course of the first season (or so), is great tv.
I like that there are closing credits (don't know if they will stick around). I have always disliked how Paramount+ jumps to commercial, and then only after the commercial break shows the closing credits. I always get lost expecting more of the episode, only to be tricked once again. The serialization doesn't help here either due to the sometimes lack of a clear ending point for a given week's episode.
I never liked PIC's theme song, it was always too bland. So I am liking the new credits much better this season.
Picard was saying he was going to "think" about writing his memoirs, but even that was just to show Laris that he was happy about going with her and would be living in the moment and not dwelling on distant events. Plus they burst that little bubble and started talking more seriously about the trip/change of life circumstances.
Last edited:
^^^
No, if there's one constant about the character of jean-Luc Picard it's that he's OFTEN a hypocrite; and that statement just shows he's still being true to form.
Fair point, Sci, although I still don’t buy it. To me, it’s even crazier than Tilly being promoted to First Officer because Tilly at least had been through the Academy and had some rather extraordinary experience in the field subsequently. While I can accept Seven would have been given a jumpstart at the Academy based on her experience and even age, I still imagine there would still be very tight competition for Executive Officer jobs (lots of commanders, but only so many ships). If Seven jumped straight from a (likely shortened) Academy stint to First Officer of a starship, I can only imagine it would have pissed off fellow officers a helluva lot as they themselves spend years, even decades, rising through the ranks. So, nah, I can’t really buy it. It’s a case where the plot demands it regardless of the logic. But, this is Trek, it’s full of things that don’t entirely make sense, so I can accept it.
Beverly hits one of them and they don't turn to ash until she strides up and shoots a second time.
Because it happened off-screen.
I enjoyed the episode- nice that Raffi’s circumstances where better than they looked.
Captain Shaw will undoubtedly end up KO or in the brig so Picard and Riker can do their thing. He probably has Wolf 359 history in his past.
Nice visuals- if the Titan was refit to the Neo-Connie it would have been cheaper to build a new ship surely?
Liked Bev’s ship. Compact little private craft.
Will watch more.
Captain Shaw will undoubtedly end up KO or in the brig so Picard and Riker can do their thing. He probably has Wolf 359 history in his past.
Nice visuals- if the Titan was refit to the Neo-Connie it would have been cheaper to build a new ship surely?
Liked Bev’s ship. Compact little private craft.
Will watch more.
That thread mentions "legal issues". The hell? Paramount owns ALL of this
! How can they be legally prevented from putting in a ship from another show THAT THEY ALSO OWN?Maybe the one from "I Borg" that they were going to use on Hugh?
Yeah he's just speculating. They just told him "no Lower Decks ships". Probably why we see reference to Voyager-B instead of A, which Prodigy hinted at.
I presume the Hellbird virus infected the Enterprise-D during the downtime at the start of Part II when they repaired the blown-out deflector.
I presume the Hellbird virus infected the Enterprise-D during the downtime at the start of Part II when they repaired the blown-out deflector.
Similar threads
- Poll
