Similarities in music from Pirates of the Caribbean to ST6?

[Opus]

Re: Similarities in music from Pirates of the Caribbean to S

Therin of Andor said:

OphaClyde said:
TUC was a rip-off of Holst' 'The Planets'

No, it was a homage.

You say tomato...

 

[Doomsday]

Re: Similarities in music from Pirates of the Caribbean to S

Nebusj said:

Therin of Andor said:

OphaClyde said:
TUC was a rip-off of Holst' 'The Planets'

No, it was a homage. "Rip-off" implies there was no attempt to acknowledge the ST VI soundtrack's influences.

Also, space movies that try to be at all serious are required to rip off ``Mars, the Bringer of War''. See also: The Right Stuff, Apollo 13, From The Earth To The Moon, and many other movies and made-for-TV movies that amount to fan fiction of those.

Not to mention that little-known flick...what was it's name...Star Wars? Even Darth Vader's theme was reminiscent of Mars.

Speaking of Rosenman's score for TVH, it's almost a direct copy of his score for the 70's animated Lord of the Rings movie.

 

[RyanKCR]

Re: Similarities in music from Pirates of the Caribbean to S

Doomsday said:

Nebusj said:

Therin of Andor said:

OphaClyde said:
TUC was a rip-off of Holst' 'The Planets'

No, it was a homage. "Rip-off" implies there was no attempt to acknowledge the ST VI soundtrack's influences.

Also, space movies that try to be at all serious are required to rip off ``Mars, the Bringer of War''. See also: The Right Stuff, Apollo 13, From The Earth To The Moon, and many other movies and made-for-TV movies that amount to fan fiction of those.

Not to mention that little-known flick...what was it's name...Star Wars? Even Darth Vader's theme was reminiscent of Mars.

Speaking of Rosenman's score for TVH, it's almost a direct copy of his score for the 70's animated Lord of the Rings movie.

When I hear Rosenman's scrore for TVH I keep thinking I'm in the Carotid Artery about to be sucked in a whirlpool or I'm going through the heart as it is being stopped for no more then 1 minute. Ot any other part of the upper body heading to a clot in the brain.

 

[P0sitr0nic]

Re: Similarities in music from Pirates of the Caribbean to S

Actually, the Pirates soundtracks sounds a LOT like "the Time machine" (the new one)... Good reason too, same composer.

 

[James Tiberius Kirk]

Re: Similarities in music from Pirates of the Caribbean to S

Hell, the last notes right before the Death Star blows up in Star Wars are identical to the ending of Mars