• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Shatner has a new book ...

Star Trek V: The Final Frontier was directed by Captain Kirk star William Shatner and is regarded as one of the worst movies in the franchise. The film currently sits with a 22 percent Fresh Rating on Rotten Tomatoes and even the most hardcore fans agree that it's really bad. In Shatner's new memoir Live Long and... What I Might Have Learned Along the Way, which is due out next week, the actor admits that he should not have directed the film and regrets the decision.

https://movieweb.com/star-trek-5-final-frontier-william-shatner-regrets-directing/
 
Honestly, I thought his direction was fine. At least as far as pacing, energy, the shots and so on. Where the film slipped - and this is something he never seems to get - is his story was poorly conceived. That's what everyone was objecting to. The fact that Paramount accepted his story or that he would even be the one to supply it, was where the film failed. Did his contract say he had to provide that story? Because, if all he was guaranteed was the director's chair. someone up top should have said, "Bill, we're fine with you directing, but someone else will supply the story." Granted, Shatner may have taken his marbles and gone home in that case, but someone should have said something. It's as good as it was because they pulled back from actually saying it was "the devil" and making it about the quest.

But maybe they thought fans would buy into anything at that point. Or perhaps Shatner's clout was that powerful at the time. Trek was riding high in the mid-late 80's. Anyways...
 
Honestly, I thought his direction was fine. At least as far as pacing, energy, the shots and so on. Where the film slipped - and this is something he never seems to get - is his story was poorly conceived.
To be honest, the story was totally shit but you're probably too polite to say so.
 
The chemistry between them in that movie was amazing though. It’s worth watching just for that.
As I've said - edit it down to a short film about them going camping and include it as a bonus feature on The Voyage Home...
 
As the movie progressed and the comedy was replaced with serious stuff, those bits hold up the best.

The campground scene with The Big Three did work, as had Sybok's attempt to administer his mind control routine on them. Those were great.

Seeing the bulk of the crew controlled like a cult was pretty good overall. The obligatory chase scene didn't not work.

Lawrence Luckinbill was rather good as Sybok...

Seeing Spock on the bridge as he sees Sybok was really nicely done...

As was when they reach Vorta'Vor, Sha'ka'ree, Sha'na'na, or whatever everyone calls the planet. Seeing representatives of the major empires all in awe of the discovery is, in a word, awesome. The movie's ending is reminiscent of "Day of the Dove" except Korrd isn't belting Kirk with as much thrust in order to sabotage the efforts to get the emotional vampire whirlygig out of the ship.

The twist that God is inside all of us while deftly not vomiting exposition over the trapped entity proclaiming to be God was fairly novel, though it received criticism at the time for being sacrilegious?

As I recall, Scotty and Uhura as an item was pretty cool - except it came out of nowhere and had no real build up or flow and isn't discussed in any later movies. Love can develop between people at various times, but there's interaction long before he tells her about Sybok's influence on her mind.

More time devoted to building that instead of "I know this ship like the back of my *slams into metal pipe*" or "78 decks" would have helped. Good idea, bad execution...

Lots of little moments had some real potential, but the movie just never gelled into something larger than the sum of its parts. Most of it is due to writing choices, either by the writers (Shatner and a couple others all worked on it) or what Paramount demanded they do - especially the comedy thanks to IV being so popular. The implied gas-passing joke was one of many misfires... Thew navigator and helmsman getting lost, etc... just does not work.
 
A story where an individual, one who doesn't feel he fits in with his own people (a race that has established mental abilities), is contacted by this very alien entity and somehow the individual is convinced this is his god and he's so thrilled to go meet said god that he wants everyone else to join him along for the trip, but he needs a means of transportation, that's where our characters come in. Then later after the crew is caught up in this, it's revealed the entity isn't anything but a tricky alien that's trapped and needs a ride out of there to go whatever it feels like, whether it's Charlie Evans after his mortal body died, a bad Organian, Trelane's brother Rex who is secretly god X, Gary Mitchel after he dug out of that hole, this is what the Decker Unit turned into, or some other thing, is not a bad story idea.

Stuff that really doesn't have anything to do with that, climbing a mountain and having your ass saved by a guy wearing rockets on his feet, a "planet of peace" that's a real crap hole full of stupid asses, said stupid asses are better infantry than our crew, how they distracted the stupid asses, the ship is a piece of junk and yet another "starting over" when we started over for Star Trek 1, 2, and 5, The way the Klingon was included, as a bored ship captain without anything more interesting to shoot at.

If they wanted to involve Romulans and Klingons, then it would have been better to have them hear of the quest and try to get in on it, but that's kind of the plot to The Chase. Actually The Chase is kind of the same story but with archaeological evidence rather than a charismatic individual driving the quest. The end of that seemed like a let down, too.
 
Yeah as you describe it, it’s a great idea. But Shatner’s was “evangelist hears god, turns out to be the devil while everyone in the crew but Kirk falls for it. Then they walk into hell...” Literal hell.

Thank Harve Bennett for steering it away from that.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top