• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Retro Review: The Cloud

TrekToday

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Voyager encounters a particle-rich nebula which the crew hopes can resupply their decreasing energy stores. Plot Summary: As Janeway walks through the ship to check on her crew, pondering how to be a leader so far from home, she wishes that Voyager had sufficient spare power to replicate her morning coffee. Chakotay saves her from […]

More...
 
The nebula turns out to be.......a life form. What were the odds. I don't mind the anomaly stuff since this episode is more about getting to know the characters (Janeway and Chakotay do the animal guide thing, Neelix is now head chef, Tom likes screwing around on holodecks).

It makes sense that the backdrop to all this should be some straightforward and predictable plot about an anomaly that turns out to be a real boy. There's some reasonably good character development here so the main story is incidental.

The one scene that really annoyed me though, is the one where Tuvok reprimands Kim for saying "I've never seen anything like it!" (as Kim's wide eyed surprise at what he sees will make the junior officers nervous)

When Tuvok later says, "I am unable to identify", Kim then uses his comm to petulantly say "so you don't know what it is either, oh I promise not to tell the junior officers"

What a massive dick. Tuvok wasn't telling Kim that he isn't allowed to not know what something is, he was simply telling him that expressing his ignorance in such an alarming, excitable manner will make the junior officers nervous (Not that I ever noticed any these junior officers)

I really hope Tuvok had words with the little tit after that

Oh and this is the episode that gave us....."there's coffee in that nebula"....so it's instantly a classic
 
My review:
This episode is actually good, not so much for the somewhat unrealistic main plot but more for the glimpses of daily life on board Voyager that we see here: Sandrine's, Chakotay teaching Janeway how to find her spirit guide, Janeway's musing over how to run the ship and the crew. A nice and enjoyable episode.

3 points out of 5
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top