• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers "Regeneration" did not deserve the hate.

Neb Lleb

Lieutenant
Red Shirt
Before watching the classic Next Generation story "Q Who", where Q convinces the Enterprise crew they need him by sending them into a sector of space where they get a good ol' fashioned Borg-style asskicking, I actually decided to skip a few episodes of Enterprise onto the relevant episode, "Regeneration", where an Arctic research base gets assimilated by freshly thawed out Borg left behind from the events of Star Trek: First Contact. It goes without saying that the new Collective take over the research vessel and proceed to go on a rampage, leading to Archer and co. to pursue them.
This is a very controversial story, and it further cemented Enterprise as a punching bag amongst Star Trek Elitists. Indeed, despite getting a high rating nowadays on IMDB, the first featured review is that of one such elitist ranting and raving about how Enterprise was the devil and this story was its legion.

And honestly, it does not deserve the hate. It's a damn fine adventure. And a really fun Borg story. I love how the first Borg the NX-01 crew encounters are people in the midst of becoming fully-fledged drones. The fact that they're already threats is a true testament to the Borg's assimilation skills and how fast said assimilation is. The newborn drones and the headache they cause for Tucker and Reed are one of my favourite parts of the story, and I also really like how they explained the Borg's assimilation and regeneration: Nanomachines might be a bit cliche nowadays, but it's a very solid reason as to why the Borg assimilate, infect and get back up so quickly. And finally, the explanation they gave for why these events are common knowledge is actually sound: the ending implies that since the Borg signal won't reach the rest of the Collective until the 24th Century, that the incident will be swiftly covered up and scrubbed from records, hence why Q giving the Enterprise-D crew a kick in its complacency is still a big deal timeline wise.

It also has strong pacing, action, atmosphere, and a good soundtrack from Bryan Tyler which serves the atmosphere. So ultimately, yeah. "Regeneration" is one of my favourites from Enterprise. Right up there with "The Andorian Incident", "Cold Front" and the rather overlooked "Two Days and Two Nights". It's just a riveting thrill ride and a blast from start to finish.

EDIT: Oh, and "Q Who" is another fantastic story ICYC.
 
The only thing I didn't like is that they didn't adapt to plain old phase pistols till the end of the episode, when they adapted to 24th century phasers much faster. But it's a nice little time loop and features the E saucer as a debris piece :D
 
I imagine the people who hated "Regeneration" over the continuity issues were finished off by Discovery and the rest of modern Trek:lol:
Yeah... I actually like some of modern Trek (namely the Kelvin Trilogy, current flagship show Strange New Worlds and sitcom Lower Decks) but there's no denying that Discovery and the Chabon/Goldsman seasons of Picard did quite a number on continuity and... quite a lot of other things really (including discourse given the rise of media grifters and breadtubers in the Trek fanspace). In fact, though I'd happily watch season 3 of the latter, both DISCO and Chab-PIC are shows I refuse to watch.
 
The only thing I didn't like is that they didn't adapt to plain old phase pistols till the end of the episode, when they adapted to 24th century phasers much faster. But it's a nice little time loop and features the E saucer as a debris piece :D
TBH, I wouldn't be surprised if the writers did this as a nod to the Star Trek Voyager: Elite Force games that were out at that time (the second and final one came out in the same year). In those games, Seven of Nine had created an experimental weapon called the i-Mod, which automatically went through a variety of frequencies to prevent Borg adaption. Having Reed and the Engineering division modify the frequency of the NX-01's shipment of Phase Pistols was probably their way of laying the foundations for the i-Mod.
 
To be honest I think Enterprise deserved the scorn for Regeneration and Acquisition and bringing back the Klingons but only when paired with how sucky Season 1 and 2 was. I love Regeneration and I think it's a good contender for the third best Borg story but the episode doesn't exist in a bubble. It comes after seasons full of retreads, ill conceived or not fully considered storylines, or just plain dull stories. I think if Regeneration had been a Season 5 story, after what the previous season had shown the show capable of, it might have still been seen with skepticism but I think might have had the benefit of the doubt.
 
To be honest I think Enterprise deserved the scorn for Regeneration and Acquisition and bringing back the Klingons but only when paired with how sucky Season 1 and 2 was. I love Regeneration and I think it's a good contender for the third best Borg story but the episode doesn't exist in a bubble. It comes after seasons full of retreads, ill conceived or not fully considered storylines, or just plain dull stories. I think if Regeneration had been a Season 5 story, after what the previous season had shown the show capable of, it might have still been seen with skepticism but I think might have had the benefit of the doubt.
Personally, I actually really like Season 1, mainly due to the character dynamics and sense of wonder and danger, and I can't wait to watch the rest of Season 2, but at the same time, I do understand your frustration.

EDIT: Besides, we all know that the worst first season of any classic-era Trek show is easily Next Generation's, with the handful of good stuff being outweighed by either dull or preposterous stories before "Conspiracy" comes along and the show finds its footing. "Naked Now" and "Code of Honour", anyone?
 
I remember there was a lot of negativity towards the episode before it aired, from the "preserve continuity" crowd who didn't want the Borg to show up in the 22nd century as well as those who just didn't want to see the Borg again period, this being two years after Voyager ended, so Borg Fatigue was in full swing. Hell, when the first rumors leaked about this episode, we had one poster here who claimed they threw a brick at their television because of this. But once it aired, it was generally well received and even today is generally considered one of the better episode of Enterprise as well as one of the better Borg episodes in the franchise overall.
 
I remember there was a lot of negativity towards the episode before it aired, from the "preserve continuity" crowd who didn't want the Borg to show up in the 22nd century as well as those who just didn't want to see the Borg again period, this being two years after Voyager ended, so Borg Fatigue was in full swing. Hell, when the first rumors leaked about this episode, we had one poster here who claimed they threw a brick at their television because of this. But once it aired, it was generally well received and even today is generally considered one of the better episode of Enterprise as well as one of the better Borg episodes in the franchise overall.
Yeah, the thing about Enterprise was that its two infamous canon-breaking episodes are actually a lot of fun, moreso "Regeneration" due to it actually giving a reason as to why no-one in the 24th century know what the Borg are, but also "Acquisition" as well. The show does its best to make you forget that what you're watching should not have happened and still make you have fun with the stories.
 
I don't hate it but I don't love it either. It's a technically well made episode and the script is pretty good for the most part but what bothers me is that Phlox was able to cure assimilation with the equipment and knowledge he had, that's the one thing I cannot accept. Had they just avoided infecting him with nano probes necessitating a cure the episode would have been great but they didn't and it's not.
 
I actually love "REGENERATION".

When the trailer for it aired, I was very irritated and did a double facepalm for two reasons.

1. "ACQUISITION" was terrible, so why bring back another TNG 'first contact' race?

2. The Borg were WAY overdone. VOYAGER completely and utterly defanged them as a threat and terror.


But I was quite pleasantly surprised at how good the episode actually was. Not only was it a good story, but you get a really tough call for Archer (opening the airlock) and you see it affect him, and more importantly... the Borg were made terrifying again. I truly didn't think that would be possible.

My only real issue was Phlox being able to get rid of all the nanoprobes he had in him, but considering how good the episode was and how it achieved such an impossible feat, I can overlook it.

Definitely a top 5 of ENT season 2.
 
Regeneration is the third-best Borg episode in the entire franchise. The other two are Q Who and The Best of Both Worlds, Part I. Why? Because the Borg were once again actually scary, a true force of nature. Voyager neutered the Borg so badly that I was sick to death of seeing them. Enterprise managed to make them both terrifying and interesting again.
 
Regeneration is the third-best Borg episode in the entire franchise. The other two are Q Who and The Best of Both Worlds, Part I. Why? Because the Borg were once again actually scary, a true force of nature. Voyager neutered the Borg so badly that I was sick to death of seeing them. Enterprise managed to make them both terrifying and interesting again.
I would agree with you about those other two, but "SCORPION" is definitely an honorable mention. (One of Chakotay's best scenes is him against Janeway when he says allying with the Borg was wrong.)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top