• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Primeval S4 - Who's Watching?

Australis

Writer - Australis
Admiral
Currently watching 4x5. I dunno, it's disjointed.

Not enjoying the Matt character at all, too busy with his own agenda. He's definitely no Cutter or Quinn. He's crap at his job.

Siddig's character is too 'evil businessman', very two dimensional. He neuters Lester waaaayyy too much.

The Emily thing is, right now, a distraction. She's two dimensional as well.

Why is Abby looking so sick?

The creatures don't seem to be any kind of recognisable thing from our past.

Using these pulse weapons is stupid - sometime lead is what you need to blast through a door or similar.

Looking back at prevous eps this season,
-- 4x1 was a good comeback.
-- 4x2 was a good callback to Connor's flatmates from the old days, though the Jess's flat thing was left up in the air.
-- 4x3, Burton and his agenda are too, well, uninteresting, and the guys from elsewhere too self-obsessed to be interesting.
-- 4x4, the school story line was okay, especially letting the pretty girl get eaten (not something you'd normally see), but the other story was dull, though it shouldn't have been.

I finally figured out the thing I'm disliking - it's not a team any more. They all go off on solo jaunts, rather than banding together, which was what worked before.

For all that, I'll keep watching, it's still worthwhile.

Anyone else have thoughts?
 
Last edited:
I've been enjoying the new season, I think it's on average pretty good. Now if only we could get some stunt casting and have Colm Meany show up on the show that would be great.
 
I like the show for the most part. I think Abby just isn't wearing as much makeup (especially eye makeup) as before which makes her look a little washed out. I don't care for Siddig but I never liked him in DS9 either. His only purpose here seems to be to give Lester a way to be the hero instead of the guy who always says no you can't do that, etc.
Having people come through the anomaly in addition to the usual animals is interesting, but if that guy turns out to be Jack the Ripper I'll be disgusted.
 
It was that shot of Abby in the cave at the end of 4x5, her eyes looked particularly baggy and dark.

Don't misunderstand me, I'm not minding this series, it's just the whole 'team scatters to the four points' thing doesn't work for me.
 
I'm enjoying the new season but I miss the old characters. Still, the show basically exists to see CGI dinos running around modern day UK and it succeeds in that ;)
 
I watched the first episode, plan on watching them on ITV player somewhen, but you could have said spoilers in the title of this thread or used spoiler tags as just saying "who's watching?" and then going on a tangent about what has been happening episode by episode is a little unfair.
 
The creatures don't seem to be any kind of recognisable thing from our past.

Well, aside from the "Tree Creepers" in episode 3, they're all based on real prehistoric creatures (and one thing I've liked about this show is that it doesn't limit itself to the very narrow range of prehistoric creatures that are "recognizable" to most of us but actually broadens it beyond the cliches of dinosaurs and mammoths) -- but sometimes very loosely based. For instance, the Kaprosuchus in episode 2 that looked practically nothing like the real thing and moved and acted more like a felinoid than a crocodilian.

All in all, though, I'm getting tired of this show's total neglect for any kind of credible animal behaviorism this season. First off, and this has always bothered me, why would any animal come through an anomaly in the first place? You'd think they'd be afraid of it. Maybe one coming through by accident now and then, but in this show, you routinely have animals come through within moments of an anomaly opening, as if they were waiting for it. And in episode 4 (the furthest we've gotten in the States), you had a whole herd (or pack, I guess, since these were predators) coming through.

Second, why does every animal that comes through the anomaly try to kill people? Most animals would be afraid of things that are unfamiliar. They wouldn't come into this horribly alien world and decide that the first thing to do was start killing the nearest bipeds; they'd probably be scared out of their ever-loving wits and try to hide, only attacking if threatened.

Not to mention the therocephalians in episode 4 somehow being superstrong enough to smash through walls, metal, glass, etc. and not be fatally lacerated (and apparently to shrink down and hide inside a vending machine, or so it seemed). They're not writing them as animals anymore (inasmuch as they ever did), they're writing them as monsters.

Of course, the credibility of the creatures went out the window in series 3, which gave us such idiocies as the fungus men from the future. But at least in the first few seasons, we had some variety in the creatures; they weren't always hostile, and those that were at least had some taxonomic variety. So far this year, every creature-of-the-week has been scaly, sharp-toothed, and enthusiastically homicidal. (Even though it's theorized that therocephalians might've had fur.) I want some variety!
 
Sorry Dimesdan, did not intentionally set out to spoil.

@Christopher, yeah, the creature behaviour is a bit ordinary. More familiar creatures that aren't too big might be good. Hell, all they need to do is refer back to the original Walking With Dinosaurs.

Still, there was a slight spoiler at the end of next week's trailer, which will be interesting, and a special guest in the season finale. Or so I'm told. :)
 
I'm enjoying it, though it isn't the greatest show in the world and doesn't seem as good as Series 1 and 2 were (never seen 3 so can't comment.)

I'd agree about the team dynamic, having just Connor and Abby hunting the creature this week seems odd for such a large organisation that can deploy dozens of people at times (low profile I know) the stun guns seem a trifle silly, though their effects are good. Alexander Siddig I love to bits, but I am hoping he isn't as 2 dimensional as he appears.

Don't see anything wrong with Abby, if anything she looks realistic (hard to stay looking glam out in the field) but then I could stare at Hannah Spearitt all day so I might be biased!

Emily isn't that interesting but Ethan is very intriguing. Definitely not Jack the Ripper (He'd have killed Emily for starters) and definitely not a Victorian given that he can drive a car and said (I think) "I am home". It seems likely he's originally from the present day but was somehow lost in (or thrown into) an anomoly.
 
if that guy turns out to be Jack the Ripper I'll be disgusted.

Why? I thought it was a requirement of time travel shows that you have to eventually a) visit the Titanic or b) meet Jack the Ripper or c) run into someone after they have died.

The Titanic coming thru an anomoly is a bit of a stretch, so we are left with Jack, or a dead person. Now as much as I'd love Helen to pop up again, Jack is a good choice to honor the trope.
 
Mm, she was looking good, I have to say. Still not bringing Becker into things, and the whole Matt mystery is getting ooooolllddd.
 
jenny, abbie and emily all looked MIGHTY FINE at the wedding.

loved Connor's blurting out 'we should get married here' and Abbie's shocked reaction.
 
Umm.... I'm guessing that the finale aired in the UK before on BBC America cause I have no idea what you guys are talking about... we just got the episode about the trailer park on the cliffside last night...
 
^Not the finale. There are 7 episodes in this season, and this weekend brought episode 6 in the UK and episode 5 in the US. So I'd like to remind UK viewers to be circumspect about spoilers, please.
 
This week's was very interesting. Ethan is clearly from our time...but I'm not sure Matt is!

Really nice to see Jenny, er Lucy, er Jenny again, that woman is gorgeous!
 
Shit... Really? Just eight episodes? I had no idea the Brits were this cheap... :lol: They didn't even get to the standard half season (12EP's) limit. Terrible, utterly terrible...
 
Short seasons = less filler episodes, I'd hate it if something like Who or Primeval ran to 20+ episodes.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top