Poll: Star Trek (2009) vs Into Darkness (Spoilers)

Discussion in 'Star Trek Movies: Kelvin Universe' started by Aike, May 11, 2013.


Star Trek (2009) vs. Into Darkness

  1. Star Trek (2009) is the best

    14 vote(s)
  2. Into Darkness is the best

    50 vote(s)
  3. Equally good

    23 vote(s)
  1. Aike

    Aike Commander Red Shirt

    Aug 18, 2008
    Which one is the best?

    I find them equally good.

    What do you think?
  2. BillJ

    BillJ Fleet Admiral Admiral

    Jan 30, 2001
    Considering I find about a third of Star Trek 2009 unwatchable, I figure Into Darkness is going to be better though I haven't seen it yet.
  3. teacake

    teacake Fleet Admiral Admiral

    Jan 20, 2007
    inside teacake
    2009. A near perfect film IMHO.
  4. Destructor

    Destructor Commodore Commodore

    Feb 19, 2003
    Melbourne, VIC
    I vastly preferred Into Darkness. I though the plot made a lot more sense, the jokes 'landed' a lot more than in the original (which I thought was a lot 'broader' in terms of humour with the fat hands and the bumping-of-heads on the ceiling and such) and thought it was generally more spectacular and satisfying. Yes the plot had problems but I was grinning the whole way through STID- not the case with ST09.
  5. Edge of Forever

    Edge of Forever Lieutenant Junior Grade Red Shirt

    Jun 4, 2009
    I liked both equally, but I reckon Into Darkness was better.

    Honestly, 2009 had a better pacing to it and it felt fresher but was weighted down by some poor character judgement (by which I mean the villain was weak as all mighty hell).

    Into Darkness had a better villain -Cumberbatch nailed it. I reckon he had far more depth than both of his predecessor although I don't think he nailed the revenge aspect I also don't really think that was the point of this literation of the character- this time it was more about family.

    Family being said, the crew worked brilliantly as well and the Spock and Kirk scenes, especially when Kirk saves everyone was brilliantly acted.

    I also really liked how they didn't kill Harrison at the end. That's a nice change from the standard blockbuster (Only other two I can think of like that was The Dark Knight and the Avengers).

    Also, I love that Carol Marcus is part of the crew now. Really love that. The core crew needs at least another women and I'm so happy that's happening. I look forward to seeing her back.

    I reckon the script in Into Darkness was a slightly a bit worse but that's mostly because they really upped the fanservice and I'd be lying if I said I didn't like it.

    I'm a fan of good script work which is probably why I enjoyed both equally. Overall though I reckon Into Darkness was better simply for the acting and the character work.

    Also, loved the empty getting blown to pieces at war, that was some beautiful work.

    The Klingon looked awesome as well. Actually alien, well more alien. And it was nice to see that they're still suffering the Worf Effect. Getting their arse handed to them to prove just how badass the villain is. It wouldn't be Star Trek without it.
  6. Jon1701

    Jon1701 Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Jun 24, 2005
    Manchester, UK
    At the moment I'd say Trek 2009 but I need to give ID a second viewing.
  7. Michael

    Michael Le modérateur de fanart Moderator

    Jul 10, 2007
    Aloha Quadrant
    Didn't love the 2009 movie, but liked it a great deal. The plot was full of holes and Nero was a weak villain, but the presentation was fresh and it was nice to witness these characters again. This time around, the new-ness had worn off for me, which led me to focus much more on the story itself. And unfortunately I didn't find a lot to like about it. Weak performances, too much fanwank and a plot that didn't make a lot of sense. STID looks amazing – even more so than its predecessor – but felt rather hollow to this fan.
  8. Cid Highwind

    Cid Highwind Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Jun 28, 2001
    I saw both movies in a double feature on premiere night. Although I had seen Star Trek several times already, several of its scenes still moved me more than anything in STID. Combined with the (IMO) sometimes rather strange story choices of STID, this makes Star Trek the better movie for me.

    LOKAI of CHERON Commodore Commodore

    Star Trek 4/5
    Star Trek Into Darkness 5/5
  10. lau03143

    lau03143 Lieutenant Junior Grade Red Shirt

    Dec 10, 2010
    Glasgow, Scotland
    Definitely Into Darkness for me.
  11. Kruezerman

    Kruezerman Commodore Commodore

    Jun 3, 2012
    Meatloaf with Macaroni and Cheese
    This is going to be THE thread in the next few months, because this comparison is very important. It needs to show a positive trend for the survival of the franchise, or else...
  12. 3chordboy

    3chordboy Commander Red Shirt

    Jun 12, 2010
    West Yorkshire, GOC, UK
    just got back from seeing Into Darkness for the second time. took my fiancé along who is not a scifi fan (the most scifi she will go is Lost/Fringe) and she thought it was great. she said as a non-scifi fan she really liked how real it felt, even the space/ ship parts.

    definitely enjoyed this film a lot more the second time around. first viewing i was trying to anticipate what would happen and see if the way i'd pieced together the trailer clips in my head played out as a though. they didn't thankfully :)

    this film felt like a Star Trek film - not that '09 wasn't. dare I say it, it felt like a Trek adventure that could easily slot in with the vibe of the original series. :eek:

    loved how much of the movie was actually spent in space on the Enterprise. and Klingons! FUCK YEAH!! :klingon: now if the third movie can boldly go somewhere and have an exploration type story to it I will be a happy boy :techman:
  13. jangotrek

    jangotrek Cadet Newbie

    Jan 23, 2013
    United Kingdom
    Star Trek Into Darkness is definitely better.
  14. Dick_Valentine

    Dick_Valentine Commander Red Shirt

    Aug 6, 2011
    Birmingham, UK (Not Alabama)
    I went to see this move with my Dad who didn't rate the first one at all (mainly because he hated the Spock/Uhura relationship and hates it when Spock shows any hint of emotion, plus doesn't really understand the whole timeline issue...but then this was a guy who didn't understand the Batman movies were a reboot and asked me how Heath Ledgers Joker took over from Jack Nicholson's Joker, bless him )

    Afterwards he was stunned by how good it was and said it was the best star trek movie of all of them!

    I was stunned by this myself, he only came begrudgingly because it was my Birthday and he thought he might get some Space Battles out of it (he's not an action fan per se but since he didn't like the first one he thought that's the only part he'd like...) and ended up loving it so much he sought out a documentary on JJ on the BBC this evening...."Oh, he was the Cloverfield guy, well that explains it I liked that too..., OH and LOST as well!!"

    I think this film converted him and might even make him reconsider the first one in retrospect.

    Me? Well I loved the first and thought this was even better, the best summer blockbuster by far and one with a lot of heart and character to go with its awe-inspiring action scenes.
  15. Galileo7

    Galileo7 Commodore Commodore

    Sep 19, 2010
    east coast U.S.
    I liked ST (2009), but definitely STID.:vulcan:
  16. Sky

    Sky Captain Captain

    Feb 9, 2009
    Equally fanwankish and badly written, sadly. Pretty to look at but no depth. ST09 felt better maybe because it was new.
  17. CommanderRaytas

    CommanderRaytas Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Oct 1, 2006
    Intergalactic Planetary Planetary Intergalactic
    What he said.

    Especially the fanservice was awesome...and the scene where Harrison kicks the crap out of those Klingons. I could watch that over and over.

    In any case, well put, I agree with everything.
  18. donners22

    donners22 Commodore Commodore

    Jul 12, 2001
    Victoria, Australia
    I disliked 2009 but felt that this one made attempts to address its problems. Aside from one badly misjudged scene and some wonky writing, STID was quite enjoyable.
  19. CommanderRaytas

    CommanderRaytas Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Oct 1, 2006
    Intergalactic Planetary Planetary Intergalactic
    Which is a clear case of YMVV. I found nothing wrong with the writing...or at least, it didn't bother me in the slightest.
  20. Aike

    Aike Commander Red Shirt

    Aug 18, 2008